[Ir-l] Spying a gap in the security of cyberspace

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun May 18 14:41:55 BST 2003


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://www.observer.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,958511,00.html

The mobile office:

Spying a gap in the security of cyberspace

Conal Walsh, The Observer, Sunday May 18, 2003

Mobile phone security is becoming more sophisticated, but data will never be 
totally secure - and intelligence agencies want to keep it that way


How secure are mobile phones? It is a question that will become ever more 
pressing as the new 2.5G and 3G phones take over in the next few years, 
providing their owners with powerful internet facilities and full access to 
their corporate intranets while out of the office. But there is also the risk 
that they will be vulnerable to attack from hackers.

More and more businesses, especially those with itinerant sales forces, such 
as insurance companies, have 'virtual private networks' (VPNs), allowing 
employees to view their corporate intranets from anywhere.

But the new mobile phones will multiply the number of people logging on. And 
with so much sensitive commercial information suddenly hurtling through 
cyberspace, a big concern will be to keep it out of the hands of saboteurs 
and corporate spies.

Security breaches are already thought to cost US businesses $500m a year, and 
safeguarding sensitive information is at the top of many 'to-do' lists in the 
IT departments of large companies.

'The true potential for generating revenue from mobile data services will only 
be realised if network operators guarantee delivery of the level of security 
their customers demand,' said a recent study by Lucent Technologies.

But Mark Blowers, an analyst at the Butler Group, fears that an industry-wide 
accepted strategy to combat security breaches is many years away.

'The new phones from Nokia, Siemens and others are basically little PCs. They 
are based on Java, or on the Symbian operating system, and they transport 
data around in "packets". So they're vulnerable to hackers or viruses in a 
way that phones never were previously,' he said.

Of course, internet technologies have their own security features, many with a 
good record. Secure socket layer (SSL), the encryption facility originally 
designed by Netscape, allows surfers to make credit card payments over the 
net. But it doesn't always work. And with new mobile technology bringing 
large volumes of sensitive corporate information on to the web, even one 
major leakage could be disastrous.

As it happens, the new mobile phones will use not SSL but newer security 
standards such as IPsec (short for IP security), which provide easy access to 
a greater variety of applications and folders on the corporate server and 
also transmit data faster.

But however effectively confidential information is encrypted, there is still 
no guarantee that the right person is receiving or sending it. Sometimes all 
a hacker has to do is get hold of the right password.

'Authentication is the biggest problem,' says Blowers. 'How do you really know 
who's logging on to your corporate system? Are passwords really the way 
forward? Maybe we should be focusing more on authentica tion technology. 
There are sophisticated voice-recognition and biometric identification 
systems out there, but the mobile industry hasn't shown much interest.'

At least mobile phone users are usually more easily identified than PC users, 
because of the SIM cards in the handsets. But there are still a thousand ways 
in which a phone and its Pin number could fall into the wrong hands.

In the absence of any more futuristic alternatives, businesses are being urged 
not to forget an old-fashioned system of passwords and usernames to give 
added layers of protection to their VPNs.

The likes of McAfee and Texas Instruments are busy developing 
security-enhancement products for mobile operators and the manufacturers of 
mobile phone devices, as well as large businesses with highly developed 
remote access systems.

But ultimately, the next generation of mobiles will offer no absolute 
guarantees of security from hackers, and it will remain the responsibility of 
companies to decide how much money they want to spend on keeping their 
systems secure.

Mike Gerdes, research director for the security firm Red Siren, has expressed 
a fear that unwise skimping might even extend to certain network operators 
reluctant to pay for the extra servers required to safeguard their clients' 
security.

On the other hand, the added security benefits of 3G and 2.5G phones are 
designed not only for phone users, but for the mobile phone companies 
themselves. Second-generation mobiles have always been vulnerable to hackers 
who set up their own transmitters, known in the trade as 'rogue base 
stations', to intercept or misdirect traffic or hop on to a carrier network 
for free.

Few, if any, mobile phone operators admit how much money they are losing 
through this practice, but many experts estimate that 'piracy' is costing 
them more than 10 per cent of total revenues. The new technology is designed 
to thwart it.

With encryption becoming ever cheaper, more powerful and more difficult to 
crack, a halt to progress may come from an unlikely source: our intelligence 
agencies. Correspondence between the British and US governments, obtained 
recently by the Guardian under America's freedom of information laws, reveals 
concern about encryption at the highest levels.

In May 1999, Janet Reno, then US Attorney General, wrote to Jack Straw, then 
Home Secretary, saying: 'I believe that the difficulties that encryption will 
pose for law enforcement are among the greatest challenges we will face in 
the coming years.' Straw replied: 'I fully share your concern at the threat 
posed by criminal use of encryption.'

Since then, the 11 September attacks have added urgency to official eavesdrop 
ping, and new laws make it easier for law enforcement agencies to confiscate 
encryption codes. They are unlikely to countenance any technology that makes 
it more difficult to catch terrorists. 


- -- 

============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.7 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQE+x42jtEaNwM05jx0RAjqIAJ9QBjH87SvE3DQnUJjrLikVtayYlgCfd2EN
fHN478RX3yM6nsfobVZnY48=
=7dbQ
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----




More information about the Ir-l mailing list