[Ir-l] Is the Internet Dying?
Tony Gosling
tony at gaia.org
Mon Sep 1 16:14:12 BST 2003
Is the Internet Dying?
By Karl Auerbach
There are indications that the Internet, at least the
Internet as we know it today, is dying.
I am always amazed, and appalled, when I fire up a packet
monitor and watch the continuous flow of useless junk that
arrives at my demarcation routers' interfaces.
That background traffic has increased to the point where
it makes noticeable lines on my MRTG graphs. And I have
little reason for optimism that this increase will cease.
Quite the contrary, I find more reason to be pessimistic
and believe that this background noise will become a
Niagara-like roar that drowns the usability of the
Internet.
Between viruses and spammers and just plain old bad code,
the net is now subject to a heavy, and increasing level of
background packet radiation. And the net has very long
memory - I still get DNS queries sent to IP addresses that
haven't hosted a DNS server - or even an active computer -
in nearly a decade. Search engines still come around
sniffing for web sites that disappeared (along with the
computer that hosted them, and the IP address on which
that computer was found) long ago.
Sure, most of this stuff never makes it past the filters
in my demarcation routers, much less past my inner
firewalls. But it does burn a lot of resources. Not only
do those useless packets burn bits on my access links, but
they also waste bits, routing cycles, and buffers on every
hop that those useless packets traverse.
It will not take long before the cumulative weight of this
garbage traffic starts to poison the net. Already it is
quite common for individual IP addresses to be
contaminated from prior use. I am aware of people who are
continuously bombarded by file access queries because a
prior user of that address shared files from that address.
Entire blocks of IP addresses are also contaminated,
perhaps permanently, because they once hosted spammers
thus causing those address blocks to be entombed into the
memories of an unknown number of anti-spam filters not
merely at the end user level but also deep in the routing
infrastructure of the net. And a denial-of-service virus,
once out on the net, can only be quieted, not eliminated;
such viruses remain virulent and ready to spring back to
life.
The net does not have infinite resources - even if IPv6 is
deployed the contamination of IP address space will merely
be slowed, not stopped.
Better security measures, particularly on the sources of
traffic, will help, but again, unless something radical
happens, the contamination will merely be slowed, not
stopped.
I believe that something radical will happen: We may see
the rapid end to the "end-to-end" principle on the
Internet.
We are already observing the balkanization of the net for
political and commercial reasons. Self-defense against the
rising tide of the net's background packet radiation may
be another compelling reason (or excuse) for net
communities to isolate themselves and permit traffic to
enter (and exit) only through a few well-protected
portals.
This balkanization may be given additional impetus by a
desire to escape from the ill effects of poorly designed
regulatory systems, such as ICANN.
So, between spam, anti-spam blacklists, rogue packets,
never-forgetting search engines, viruses, old machines,
bad regulatory bodies, and bad implementations, I fear
that the open Internet is going to die sooner than I would
have expected. In its place I expect to see a more
fragmented network - one in which only "approved"
end-to-end communications will be permitted.
The loss of open end-to-end communications will, in
itself, be a great loss.
But of even more concern will be the fact that these
portals, or gates, will require gatekeepers, which is
merely a polite word for censors. Our experience with
ICANN has shown us how easily it is for focused and
well-financed interests to capture a gatekeeper. In the
present political climate in which government powers are
conferred, without a counterbalancing obligation of
accountability, onto private bodies, the loss will be much
greater.
---
Posted with permission from the CaveBear
http://www.circleid.com/article/215_0_1_0_C/
--
Visit Things From Another World for the best
comics, movies, toys, collectibles and more.
http://www.tfaw.com/?qt=wmf
---
Incoming mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.507 / Virus Database: 304 - Release Date: 04/08/03
-------------- next part --------------
---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Unless you're using Norton Antivirus.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.507 / Virus Database: 304 - Release Date: 04/08/03
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list