[Ir-l] Manchester police sideswipe at journalistic freedom

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Mon Dec 6 09:40:23 GMT 2004


http://observer.guardian.co.uk/uk_news/story/0,6903,1366841,00.html

TV man claims his exposé 'led to' arrest

Producer alleges he was held for murder so police could access controversial 
files

The Observer, Sunday December 5, 2004
Martin Bright and Tony Thompson


Senior officers at two police forces are facing an official investigation over 
allegations that a BBC TV producer was wrongly accused of murder in order to 
gain access to his confidential files.

Paul Atkinson, a former sergeant with Greater Manchester Police now working as 
a freelance journalist, claims that a search of his home by officers from 
Cheshire police in January led to the seizure of documents and videos 
connected to the controversial TV programme, The Secret Policeman, which 
revealed serious racism at a police college near Warrington.

His claim to the Independent Police Complaints Commission is that the material 
was later passed to GMP where it was used to identify serving police officers 
who had collaborated with the programme makers.

The Secret Policeman sent shockwaves through the police when it was broadcast 
in October 2003. An undercover reporter, Mark Daly, signed on as a recruit at 
Bruche police college, which serves the north-west of England and Wales, and 
filmed scenes of one recruit dressing in a mock Ku Klux Klan outfit and 
boasting about assaulting Asians.

Charges of deception against Daly were later dropped by the Attorney-General. 
Atkinson worked as an adviser to the programme, which was two years in the 
making.

The investigation by the IPCC may prove to be deeply embarrassing to the Chief 
Constable of Greater Manchester, Michael Todd, who has been tipped as a 
future Metropolitan Police Commissioner.

There is no suggestion that Todd was personally responsible for Atkinson's 
arrest, which was carried out by another force. But documents seen by The 
Observer show that he is named in complaints, including allegations of 
inappropriate conduct and collusion between the two forces over the 
investigation of Atkinson.

The IPCC has confirmed that it is in the process of selecting a chief 
constable to head its inquiry, a process only necessary when a high-ranking 
officer is the subject of a complaint.

Atkinson was initially interviewed in September 2003 by Cheshire police about 
the murder of a drug dealer, Brian Waters, who had been whipped, beaten and 
burnt to death by members of a rival drugs gang earlier that year. The gang 
was led by James Raven, who had worked on a number of BBC programmes as a 
consultant.

Raven was arrested the day of the murder and Atkinson's telephone number - 
along with that of dozens of other journalists - was found in his files.

Atkinson was interviewed as a matter of routine, but was not cautioned as he 
was not a suspect.

Despite this, in January 2004 Cheshire's murder squad arrested Atkinson at his 
home near London. He was taken into custody and kept for 15 hours.

He remains furious that he was not formally eliminated from the inquiry until 
April 2004, despite the fact that his wife gave the officers a verifiable 
alibi as he was being escorted to the police van - at the time of the murder 
he was with his wife in a hospital 250 miles away.

After the raid, Atkinson launched a complaint against Cheshire and Greater 
Manchester police for wrongful arrest and imprisonment. He also complained 
that journalistic documents, whose confidentiality is protected in law, had 
been taken from his house. Cheshire immediately asked neighbouring West 
Mercia to investigate the complaint. Todd decided to deal with the matter 
internally.

At the heart of Atkinson's complaint against GMP is a letter sent to Atkinson 
on 23 February 2004 saying that he was not the subject of an investigation 
into The Secret Policeman. But by 28 May, GMP was forced to write again, 
admitting that Atkinson had indeed been under investigation. A request under 
the Data Protection Act by Atkinson showed that GMP kept him under 
investigation for some time.

Nicholas Long, the IPCC commissioner in charge of the case, has drawn up a 
list of Atkinson's complaints against Greater Manchester and Cheshire which 
he accepts require investigation. Cheshire Constabulary has agreed to the 
IPCC inquiry but GMP, which must register the complaint before the 
investigation can proceed, has yet to respond to the commission.

However, a spokeswoman confirmed that the IPCC was determined to press ahead.

'Because the complaints are potentially of a serious nature, we are duty bound 
to ensure they are investigated,' she said.

Atkinson told The Observer he was still astonished by the arrest: 'All they 
had to do was knock on my front door and ask me where I was on the day of the 
murder. It would have saved a major police operation and a great deal of 
money.'

Cheshire and Greater Manchester police said they will not comment on the 
allegations until after the inquiry by the IPCC.

-- 

==============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html




More information about the Ir-l mailing list