[Ir-l] search manipulation

Tony Gosling tony at gaia.org
Mon Jan 26 13:04:33 GMT 2004


Engineering Google Results to Make a Point

Kevin P. Casey for The New York Times
Anti-Bush George Johnston of Bellevue, Wash., is credited 
with linking the words "miserable failure'' to the 
official White House biography of President Bush.  

  
  
IME was - say, two months ago - when typing the phrase 
"miserable failure" into the Google search box produced an 
unexpected result: the White House's official biography of 
President George W. Bush. 

But now the president has a fight on his hands for the top 
ranking - from former President Jimmy Carter, Senator 
Hillary Rodham Clinton and the author-filmmaker Michael 
Moore. 

The unlikely electoral battle is being waged through 
"Google bombing," or manipulating the Web's search engines 
to produce, in this case, political commentary. Unlike Web 
politicking by other means, like hacking into sites to 
deface or alter their message, Google bombing is a group 
sport, taking advantage of the Web-indexing innovation 
that led Google to search-engine supremacy. 

The perpetrators succeed by recruiting a small group of 
accomplices to link from their Web sites to a target site 
using specific anchor text (the clickable words in a 
link). The more high-traffic sites that link a Web page to 
a particular phrase, the more Google tends to associate 
that page with the phrase - even if, as in the case of the 
president's official biography, the term does not occur on 
the destination site. 

"I'm actually surprised how easy it was to do," said the 
mastermind of the Bush effort, George Johnston, 46, a 
computer programmer in Bellevue, Wash., who writes a 
liberal-leaning Web log called Old Fashioned Patriot 
(oldfashionedpatriot.blogspot.com). "It took about six 
weeks to get Bush's biography as the No. 1 result. I had 
no idea when I started that I'd get people all over the 
world involved."

Google bombing has quickly become an armchair sport among 
those who have a message to broadcast and perhaps a bit 
too much time on their hands. For nearly a year, the No. 1 
search result on Google for the term "weapons of mass 
destruction" has been a satirical Web page made to 
resemble an error message that reads, "These Weapons of 
Mass Destruction Cannot Be Displayed." 

The Liberty Round Table, a libertarian group, started a 
Google bomb that linked the Center for Science in the 
Public Interest, a nutrition advocacy group, with the term 
"food Nazis." (As a follow-up, the group is trying to make 
the Internal Revenue Service site the No. 1 Google result 
for the term "organized crime.") Other recent Google bombs 
have sought to associate President Bush, Senator Clinton 
and Senator Rick Santorum, a Pennsylvania Republican, with 
various unprintable phrases. 

Google plays down the significance of Google bombing, 
saying the search results merely reflect what is actually 
happening on the Web.

"We're only seeing it with obscure queries where there's 
really not that much action on the Web about them," said 
Craig Silverstein, Google's director of technology. "I 
don't think it's possible to do this sort of thing on 
queries with well-defined results like ' I.B.M.' So given 
that it only affects one query out of the more than 200 
million a day we handle, it's hard to see it becoming much 
of a problem."

But some in the industry say Google may be more worried 
than it lets on. The company's success, to a large extent, 
has been built on its search algorithm's ability to return 
relevant Web pages and weed out irrelevant or outright 
bogus results. The growing popularity of Google bombing 
can't be a welcome development for a company that is 
expected to begin selling stock to the public in a few 
months.

"Google says they're just reflecting what's on the Web, 
but they're actually reflecting a very small number of 
people who are trying to manipulate the system," said 
Danny Sullivan, who edits Search Engine Watch 
(www.searchenginewatch.com). "Google bombing will never go 
away, but Google has got to make it less rewarding for 
people to spend time doing this." 

Google certainly isn't the only search engine whose 
results can be gamed by users acting in concert. President 
Bush's biography is also the No. 1 search result for 
"miserable failure" on Yahoo, which draws on Google's 
technology and that of HotBot; it's the No. 2 result on 
MSN Search. All search engines, to varying degrees, 
analyze links in calculating the relevancy of a page for a 
particular query. Seed the Web with enough links pointing 
to the same site using the same anchor text, and you alter 
the search results. The effect is magnified with less 
popular search phrases, since there are far fewer 
competing links. 

Some Google bombs may have been accomplished with as few 
as 20 links. What is important is not the number of links, 
but rather the popularity of the sites doing the linking 
and the relative obscurity of the search term.

Bombers aim at Google for the same reason Willie Sutton 
robbed banks - that's where the payoff is. Google handles 
more than 200 million requests a day and has a 34.9 
percent share of online searches in the United States. The 
nearest rival is Yahoo, with 27.7 percent, according to 
comScore Networks, which tracks consumer behavior. 

page1 of 2

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/22/technology/circuits/22goog.html
--
Visit Things From Another World for the best
comics, movies, toys, collectibles and more.
http://www.tfaw.com/?qt=wmf


---
Incoming mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.548 / Virus Database: 341 - Release Date: 05/12/03
-------------- next part --------------

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Unless you're using Norton Antivirus.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.548 / Virus Database: 341 - Release Date: 05/12/03


More information about the Ir-l mailing list