[Ir-l] ACLU Suit Uncovers The Secrets of Secret Surveillance

tony at gaia.org tony at gaia.org
Sun Jun 6 17:15:56 BST 2004


From: "vera gottlieb" <veragott at mail.ocis.net

http://babelogue.citypages.com:8080/ecassel/2004/05/29

Story by Elaine Cassel ecassel1 at cox.net

Saturday, May 29, 2004

ACLU Suit Uncovers The Secrets of Secret Surveillance

Everyone knows by now (or should) that the Patriot Act allows the FBI
to
conduct surveillance on Internet and email usage. Using so-called
National
Security Letters (NSLs), the FBI directs Internet Service Providers
(ISPs)
to provide passwords and identifying information that will allow the
government to target people who are plotting terrorism or who are
otherwise potentially "dangerous" to national security. I am sure that
many of you reading this (and I, of course) have the government in our
computers.

The same mechanism of NSLs is used to obtain information from
librarians,
health care providers, and business records of individuals and
entities.
The party from whom the government demands information is forbidden
from
telling the client that the FBI is being provided information. And the
target of the investigation won't know about it until or if he or she
is
arrested for crime or detained without a charge (say, as a material
witness).

Until now, we did not know much about how the government goes about
this
procedure. Now we do. Thanks to a suit filed by the American Civil
Liberties Union (ACLU) in New York in behalf of an unnamed ISP. The
government has tried mightily to keep the entire suit under seal, but
the
federal judge has allowed the ACLU to release some information about
the
case.

Following is a report on the case, with some interesting heretofore
unknown details.  Never has the ACLU needed your financial support
more.
Clearly, it is the only thing standing between us and our fascist
government. Read the briefs and supporting documents in the case.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) yesterday released more
information about the heavily censored legal challenge it is bringing
against the government's use of a controversial provision of the USA
PATRIOT Act that allows the FBI to obtain from businesses sensitive
personal information about their clients. Among the documents unsealed
today is a declaration by the ACLU's anonymous client in the case, the
president and sole employee of an unnamed Internet Service Provider
(ISP),
referred to only as "John Doe." John Doe is prohibited by law from
revealing his identity to the public, even as he confronts the federal
government over the very section of the Patriot Act that forces him to
remain anonymous.

In his statement, Doe explains that his business provides access to
the
Internet, email accounts and space on the Web where people can post
their
own sites or store electronic files. He says some of his clients "are
individuals and political associations that engage in controversial
political speech," and that some "communicate anonymously or
pseudonymously," which allows them "to discuss embarrassing,
sensitive or
controversial subjects without fear of retaliation or reprisal."

Doe and the ACLU are asking the court to deem unconstitutional the
government's use of National Security Letters (NSLs), which allow FBI
agents to demand, with no judicial oversight, personal information
about
clients of Internet Service Providers.

"I believe that the government may be abusing its power by targeting
people with unpopular views," Doe writes. "I am challenging the
constitutionality of the NSL provision in an effort to protect all of
my
clients' interests."

In a memorandum to the court, the ACLU wrote that the statute
allowing the
broad use of National Security Letters gives the FBI "unchecked
authority"
to require businesses to reveal "a broad array of sensitive
information,
including information about the First Amendment activities of ordinary
Americans who are not suspected of any wrongdoing."

The memorandum continues: "The statute does not require the FBI to
seek
judicial authorization before demanding the disclosure of sensitive
information, and it does not specify any means by which a person
served
with an NSL can challenge the NSLs validity before complying with it.
In
other words, the FBI issues NSLs without judicial oversight of any
kind."

ACLU lawyers and their client are also disputing a section of the law
that
prohibits an entity that receives a National Security Letter request
for
information from telling anyone about the request. Ironically, this
gag
order is the same rule that prohibits the ACLU and John Doe from
talking
about many aspects of their case.

The ACLU challenge of the National Security Letters and the gag rule
has
been wrapped in secrecy since it was filed in early April this year.
The
civil liberties organization has been locked in constant disagreements
with the government over how much can be revealed about the case. The
group was not even allowed to announce the existence of the suit for
over
two weeks, and even after negotiating the right to publicize the
case, has
been subject to numerous restrictions on the kinds of information it
can
disclose.

Numerous words, sentences and entire sections of the documents
related to
the suit, which are posted on the group's website, remain blacked out.

Assistant Attorney General for Legal Policy Daniel Bryant defended
the gag
order last week at a House Judiciary subcommittee hearing, saying it
prevents people from interrupting terrorism investigations. But
critics
say the secrecy rule is designed to keep the public in the dark about
thegovernment's invasion into people's constitutionally protected
privacy.

"It is particularly troubling," writes ACLU Executive Director Anthony
Romero in a statement to the court, "that while the ACLU ... [has]
been
gagged from discussing the NSL power, President Bush and
representatives
of the FBI and Justice Department are engaged in a public campaign in
support of the Patriot Act. The gag provision silences those who are
most
likely to oppose the Patriot Act. [We] believe we have the right to
inform
the public of a great deal of the information the gag is suppressing."

In filings with the court, Both Romero and Doe described the
self-censorship they had been forced to engage in when asked by others
about the National Security Letters in general or the case in
particular.

"The government has now prohibited the disclosure of my name and my
company's name in connection with the case," said Doe. "They have
provided
no further clarification about what I can and cannot say." He says
that he
has found it difficult to have normal conversations. "[I] used to
discuss
topics related to politics and current events, but now I feel wary
when
I communicate ... I have steered clear of numerous topics of
conversation
as I am afraid.... The gag has put me in a very compromising
situation, as
I do not want to be dishonest in my communications [words blacked
out] but
also do not want to violate the gag."

Romero said that not only is the gag order affecting how he and other
staff at the ACLU can talk about the case, but it is having an impact
on
the broader activities of the organization, which has been actively
engaged in educating and organizing against the Patriot Act since the
law's inception in late 2001.

"[T]he scope of the gag in this case, and the refusal of the
government to
clarify what is prohibited, is intolerable," he writes. "The gag has
severely disrupted our ordinary course of business... More
importantly,
the public and even members of Congress are denied non-sensitive
information essential to public and legislative debate that is at the
heart of democratic self-governance."



More information about the Ir-l mailing list