[Ir-l] Should the United Nations run the Internet?

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Mar 31 09:15:09 BST 2004


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://news.com.com/2010-1028-5181327.html

Should the United Nations run the Internet?
March 30, 2004, 4:00 AM PT
By Declan McCullagh

The United Nations wants to expand its influence over the Internet, but would 
it be wise to let that happen?

That question follows the conclusion of a two-day U.N. summit last week, in 
which delegates from sundry countries such as Cuba, Ghana, Bolivia and 
Venezula lectured North American, Asian and European countries about how best 
to run the Internet.

Their demands varied, but the bottom line was the same: They want a piece of 
the action in just about every way. The event's agenda was breathtakingly 
broad, taking in everything from spam and privacy to intellectual property, 
network security and the operation of root domain name servers.

Juan Fernandez, the delegate from Cuba's Ministry of Informatics and 
Communications, no doubt was sincere in the speeches he delivered at the 
summit. Less clear is why a nation that tolerates only one political party 
and last year imprisoned some 80 journalists and peaceful democracy activists 
should be a model for enlightened thinking about how to preserve an open and 
democratic Internet.

Iran was also among the delegates hoping to inject the United Nations into the 
process of overseeing Internet protocols, domain names and network stability. 
Before taking these folks too seriously, though, let's recall that Iran ranks 
in the bottom few percent of the 2004 Index of Economic Freedom, bans more 
than 10,000 "immoral" Web sites and jailed Iranian journalist and Web logger 
Sina Motallebi last year.

All this raises the question whether these are nations that should decide the 
rules for a worldwide Internet.

It is true that the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers 
(ICANN), which currently oversees address space and domain names, has its 
problems. It has moved with the speed of a crippled, three-toed sloth in 
approving new top-level domains. It is a little too cozy with large trademark 
holders. It needs to be more completely weaned from the U.S. government.

Developing nations have other legitimate gripes, too. China has been allocated 
about 45 million global Internet addresses, less than the combined total of 
Stanford University and IBM. That's hardly reasonable nowadays. But groups 
like the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) have been working hard on 
Internet Protocol version 6, the next-generation Internet protocol that will 
eliminate the shortage of addresses.

It is hardly clear that the United Nations would do a better job, and there 
are plenty of reasons to believe that it wouldn't.

The United Nations is home to the world's most bloated bureaucracy, employing 
more than 56,000 people at salaries roughly twice what they would be paid in 
the private sector. It refuses to subject itself to independent audits of its 
finances and does not even publish an annual financial report.
Demands for greater U.N. involvement in the Internet are not new.
What's more, the General Assembly, which had 191 members as of December 2002, 
has grown estranged from the United States in recent years and is hardly a 
place for enlightened political discourse.

Yet, the United Nations makes ICANN look like a paragon of political 
perfection. ICANN posts reasonably complete financial information online, 
broadcasts its board meetings over the Internet and permits the general 
public to attend its meetings at no cost. By contrast, writes Ted Carpenter, 
author of "Delusions of Grandeur: The United Nations and Global 
Intervention": "Most U.N. members are ruled by authoritarian regimes that 
rarely even make the pretense of being democratic, and the culture of 
governance at the United Nations itself is hardly sympathetic to the values 
of individual rights and tethered government."

Demands for greater U.N. involvement in the Internet are not new. As far back 
as 1999, a U.N. agency proposed taxing all e-mail messages to pay for 
development aid. The United Nations hastily backed away from that proposal, 
however, after prominent members of the U.S. Congress correctly slammed the 
organization as a "bureaucracy looking to get its greedy mitts on the 
Internet through new taxes."

While the politics of last week's summit was difficult to decipher and was 
cloaked in the argot of U.N. bureaucratese, the delegates fortunately didn't 
seem to be able to agree on specifics.

In a statement, the United Nations seemed to acknowledge this temporary 
setback, saying it hopes to "better coordinate the work of specialized 
bodies" like ICANN, the IETF, the Internet Architecture Board and the World 
Wide Web Consortium, and to "ensure the involvement of all 
stakeholders"--rather than invent a new organization to supplant them.

The next step is for U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan to create a "working 
group on Internet governance" that will make specific recommendations in time 
for a summit in November 2005.

It is highly symbolic that the United Nations' climactic summit next year will 
meet in Tunisia, a state that blocks access to many Web sites, spies on its 
citizens' e-mail and closely controls Internet service providers. The group 
Reporters Without Borders calls Tunisian president Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali a 
"predator of press freedom" and claims that he allowed Zouhair Yahyaoui, 
editor of news site TUNeZINE, to be arrested and tortured.

At next year's event, I'm sure that Tunisian politicians will be happy to 
share their experiences in how a free and open Internet should be run. 





==========

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html



-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.2-rc1-SuSE (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFAan4NtEaNwM05jx0RAm8tAJ44PFREUxINSyzLVViEQODVSoJeiQCgrDiZ
nQiMZWeao2ZPp2TcrQLRc7Y=
=AxOI
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----




More information about the Ir-l mailing list