[Ir-l] Will UK politics ever wake up to the web?

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Nov 10 19:18:52 GMT 2004


http://www.guardian.co.uk/online/news/0,12597,1346182,00.html

Will UK politics ever wake up to the web?

Paul Carr
The Guardian, Monday November 8, 2004


It's been almost a week since John Kerry conceded victory in the US election, 
and I still feel sick to the pit of my stomach. And what made me sickest of 
all was the fact that Bush's victory was achieved, in large part, thanks to 
the internet. My dear, beloved, traitorous internet.

There's no doubt that the most important foreign election in any of our 
lifetimes was also the first to be significantly influenced by new media. 
Kerry and Bush both committed sizeable chunks of their war chests to building 
vast, all-singing, all-dancing campaign websites. These official sites had 
two key roles: to keep existing supporters on-message and to win over 
floating voters using mean-spirited video clips about their opponents' 
Vietnam records. And very impressive they were too.

But that was only part of the candidates' official web strategies. All across 
cyberspace, Bush and Kerry spent massive amounts on carefully targeted banner 
advertising.

John Kerry hit upon the brilliant idea of flooding high-traffic sites with 
targeted ads straight after the big televised debates. His reasoning - that 
the moment the debates finished, hundreds of thousands of undecided voters 
would flood on to the web in search of background information to help them 
make up their minds. The candidate with the most ads would grab the most 
eyeballs and therefore the most votes, so the theory went.

But Dick Cheney went one step further - during a televised debate he supported 
one of his arguments by encouraging voters to visit the bipartisan anti-spin 
site, factcheck.org. Unfortunately for the hapless vice-president, he gave 
the URL as factcheck.com, sending millions of potential voters to the 
official weblog of George Soros, a fierce critic of Bush.

And the official sites and advertising banners were small potatoes compared 
with the unofficial on line campaigning. Film-maker Michael Moore made his 
anti-Bush hate-umentary, Fahrenheit 9/11, available for download the day 
before the election to try to convince floating voters to come out against 
Bush, while the Democratic pressure group, Moveon.org, invited its users to 
create 60-second videos giving reasons why Bush shouldn't win a second term.

And yet win he did. Why? Because, while the Democrat supporters had right on 
their side, the Republican supporters were far, far better at fighting dirty. 
Conservative mega-sites such as Freerepublic.com galvanised their hundreds of 
thousands of visitors into an army of amateur attack dogs - ready to yap and 
snap the moment a foolish journalist wrote anything bad about Bush. Woe 
betide any TV reporter who didn't check his facts properly before claiming 
that George W didn't finish his national guard service. And pity any liberal 
British newspaper that launched an online campaign to convince the voters of 
a small county in Ohio of the merits of a Kerry administration. The mass 
yapping and snapping worked like a charm - making even the most fearless 
journalists think twice before they questioned Bush's suitability for a 
second term.

But at least American political parties know what the internet is, unlike 
their British counterparts. Just look at the official sites of the big three 
parties. Labour's site (labour.org.uk) looks so amateurish that it should 
probably be hosted on Geocities, while the Liberal Democrats' online home 
(libdems.org.uk) is all garish yellow boxes and dull transcripts.

In fact, only the Tories have put together anything resembling a professional 
web presence - but where are all the innovative viral campaigns and inspiring 
video clips so beloved of our American cousins? Where are the talking points 
and official blogs to get potential voters motivated? Where's the reason for 
anyone other than activists to visit any of these sites and to get involved 
in the democratic process?

Hopefully the outcome of the American election will wake British politicians 
up to the potential for the internet to seriously affect the outcome of 
elections. In these dissatisfied times, it's highly likely that the first 
British party to drag itself into the 21st century and properly embrace the 
web will soak up undecided voters come the next general election. Meanwhile 
any party that continues to ignore the power of the internet will do so at 
its electoral peril. Because, after all, in the kingdom of the bland, the 
wired candidate is king.

· Paul Carr is editor-in-chief of The Friday Project (thefridayproject.co.uk). 
His latest book, London by London: The Insiders' Guide, has just been 
published

-- 

==============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html




More information about the Ir-l mailing list