[Ir-l] Ottawa's copyright plans wrongheaded, experts say

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Mon Nov 15 18:58:23 GMT 2004


http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20041111.gttwcopy11/BNStory/Technology/

Ottawa's copyright plans wrongheaded, experts say

Web users would have to pay levy on free material if changes become law

By JACK KAPICA
Globe and Mail Update 


Ottawa is about to blunder in cyberspace, lawyers and academics warn.

Last week, the standing committee on Canadian Heritage resubmitted its 
recommendations for updating the Copyright Act of 1998 and ratifying the 
World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) treaty. Copyright lawyers say 
that if the changes are made into law, you will not even be able to own your 
own wedding pictures or save a Web page without paying for it.

Among other things, the committee proposes that photographers keep the rights 
to their work and surfers would have to pay a levy for material even if was 
offered free of charge. Copyright holders could also shut down websites that 
they claim -- even erroneously -- are violating copyright, putting the burden 
of proof on the website charged.

Michael Geist, who holds the Canada Research chair in Internet and e-commerce 
law at the University of Ottawa, and Howard Knopf, a Canadian copyright 
lawyer and director for the Center for Intellectual Property at the John 
Marshall Law School in Chicago, have sharply condemned the proposals. Mr. 
Geist blames "an amazing lobby job" by the recording industry, and Mr. Knopf 
calls it a "travesty [and] an exercise in hyperbole."

The committee's premise is that all work on the Internet is someone's 
property. You can read it or listen to it, but unless there is an explicit 
legal notice saying the material can be used, you would not be permitted to 
save a copy to disk or print it out without paying a copyright collective 
such as Access Copyright.

"This last part is crucial," says Laura Murray, a Queen's University English 
professor who maintains a website called FairCopyright.ca. "It means that the 
bulk of sites used in educational settings -- resources designed by museums, 
libraries, universities, experts of various kinds -- that are intended for 
educational uses may be levied," with a government agency automatically 
charging for the content.

"It will be very difficult to communicate to the thousands of sites outside of 
Canada that are commonly used by Canadian students and educators (the Library 
of Congress, the British Library) that they must put such explicit notices on 
their sites," she adds. "This is perverse."

The educational community's proposal for special treatment to allow it free 
Internet usage also came under fire from Mr. Knopf.

"By asking for a special exception to clarify what the common law and the 
Supreme Court of Canada have already said is free, they will almost certainly 
ensure that everyone else will be liable to pay," he said. "It will also 
backfire on the educators when they are faced with exceptions to their 
proposed exception."

The committee's recommendation also gives copyright holders the right of 
"terminate and takedown," meaning an Internet service provider would have to 
take down material simply because the copyright holder demanded it be done, 
with no due process for defence. The Canadian Recording Industry Association 
asked for the ability to force Internet service providers to cut off all 
services to those who were accused of violating copyright, but the Heritage 
committee turned it down.

In defence of the recommendations, committee vice-chairman Gary Schellenberger 
said the report was well thought out and had the unanimous support of the 
committee, which included members from the major political parties. "There 
might be some frivolous things that could happen [if it were turned into 
law], but I hope we can get some of those wrinkles worked out and get some 
dialogue going," he said.

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which ratifies the WIPO treaty in the 
United States, gives copyright owners similar clout and is being challenged 
in the courts for stifling free speech, killing research and stalling 
security development in a legal quagmire. The European Union signed the WIPO 
treaty, but ratification has been mired in controversy.

How did it get this way? Both Mr. Geist and Mr. Knopf say the Heritage 
committee ignored evidence against the demands of the recording industry and 
Access Copyright, the book publishing industry's copyright arm.

"None of the requisite interests were represented," Mr. Geist said.

Mr. Knopf added that material supporting a more moderate approach was rejected 
because he had neglected to translate it into French.

The best answer to copyright reform has always been to maintain balance, the 
lawyers say. Society wants to maintain creative incentives, so laws are 
passed to protect creators; but society must also have access to those works 
to share in their knowledge.

"The danger of WIPO is that it threatens that balance," Mr. Geist said, "and 
replaces social rights with absolute rights."

There's also the potential for the recommendations to have a direct economic 
impact.

"The committee ignored solid evidence that the levy on blank CDs [meant to 
compensate artists for pirated content] would double as a result of the 
national treatment requirements of the WIPO treaties," Mr. Knopf said. "This 
could quickly cost Canadians more than $100-million annually.

"We could end up with the worst of all dystopian worlds," he added. "You could 
pay the levy on a CD and get sued anyway" over the disc's content.

"Copyright is not an easy issue," Mr. Schellenberger allowed. "But we've tried 
to make it the best of all possible worlds."

The proposals are so tough, Ms. Murray said, they have already encouraged the 
CanWest newspaper chain to introduce a new contract for freelancers that 
demands they hand over all their rights "throughout the universe, in 
perpetuity."

"You'd think this would make writers' groups wonder about why [the writers 
have] been busting themselves to support WIPO ratification [and] Internet 
licensing," she argued.

Still, Mr. Schellenberger cautioned that the report is still far from law.

"There's not even a bill on it yet," he said. "And when a bill is brought up, 
then there will be debate."

But Mr. Knopf is not mollified. "It's not a rational report," he said.



-- 

==============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html




More information about the Ir-l mailing list