[Ir-l] Phishing phobia
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Thu Nov 18 12:17:32 GMT 2004
http://www.guardian.co.uk/online/story/0,3605,1353189,00.html
Phishing phobia
As fraudsters get more sophisticated in their methods for fleecing customers,
the banks are re-evaluating their security, reports Ken Young
The Guardian, Thursday November 18, 2004
Sophisticated "phishing" attacks that lure PC users to fake websites are
prompting security experts to question whether the current password-based
security systems are adequate to cope with the growth in fraud. And if the
banks fail to act, this could undermine confidence in online banking, and the
whole e-commerce industry.
UK banks now have more than 14 million customers who benefit from 24-hour
access to their accounts from PCs with a web browser. Although subscriber
growth has slowed recently, the total number of subscribers has doubled since
June 2002.
However, phishing - the activity of gaining passwords and other personal data
to use to remove funds illegally - is a multimillion pound problem. The most
common example is the use of fake emails that purport to come from your bank.
These invite you to confirm your password on fake bank web pages set up by
the fraudsters. Internet security firm Messagelabs says it is intercepting
50,000 such emails and more than 80 new phishing websites every day.
Around £4.5m has already been refunded to about 2,000 customers, according to
the Association for Payment Clearing Services (Apacs).
The problem for banks is that fraudsters are getting smarter. They have
started using virus technologies, such as sending emails with Trojan
keylogging software that tracks your keystrokes or even grabs screenshots
while you are connected to your bank. By logging your actions, they are able
to get all the password details they need to enter your account. Clearly,
under these circumstances, any system that relies on a single unchanging
password is inherently insecure.
Nearly all banks use a password system that requires two or three pieces of
information to control access to accounts: user name, password and a third
item. Many banks - including Barclays, Lloyds and First Direct - ask users
for a random selection of characters from the password, and sometimes the
third item is the answer to a selection of pre-agreed questions, such as:
What is the name of your dog?
But what happens if you are the victim of phishing? At the moment, the banks
say they will reimburse anyone "inadvertently" defrauded through phishing.
However, last weekend, Apacs revealed that the banks may withdraw this policy
if they believe customers have not paid sufficient heed to the safety advice
available.
An Apacs spokeswoman, Sandra Quinn, says the banks are also looking closely at
stronger forms of security such as dynamic (variable) passwords. "Our
e-commerce group is looking at it. The key issue is whether banks should
collaborate on one system or develop their own systems," she says.
"We have seen a massive increase in phishing so there is agreement that
something must be done. The most likely outcome is a pilot project later this
year," says Quinn.
A variable password system requires the bank to issue a token device that can
generate a unique numeric password each time the customer wants to connect
online. This random number is automatically synchronised with the bank's
server. Alternatively, a card reader can be connected to the user's PC.
Identification specialists agree that another level of authentication will
make a big difference. "The adoption of an additional authentication step for
high-risk transactions, such as making a payment to a new account, could
dramatically reduce the financial exposure to the customer," says Paul
Butterworth, product marketing director at Aspace Solutions, an identity
management firm.
"Unless banks rapidly introduce anti-phishing technologies, fraud will rise to
a level where internet banking becomes a commercial liability."
But there are two problems with this approach: cost and user acceptance.
Tokens cost about £35 per customer, and cost even more to administer,
maintain and replace. There is also evidence that customers prefer simple
password systems, though this may change if phishing attacks continue to
increase. It is also unknown how well a token system would scale up to serve
millions of users if a unified system were adopted by the banks, as is the
case with Chip and Pin, the new authorisation system for credit cards.
What seems most likely is that tokens will be used first with business
customers. In Australia, Westpac Bank has already told its business customers
they will have to use tokens if their transactions involve more than
Aus$5,000 (£2,073) in one day. Previously, it had a Aus$25,000 limit. The
bank is also thought to be considering tokens for its 1.5m personal online
customers.
Jon Fell, a partner at Masons Solicitors, says banks need to take security
more seriously. "Banks are waking up to this, but you have to wonder if they
could do more. The problem is they are between a rock and a hard place with
phishing. What they really want is the government to spend more on educating
people of the dangers. The problem is, recent research by Apacs found that 4%
of people said they would reply with password details to an email if they
thought it was from their bank."
All the evidence suggests the phishers are capable of constantly developing
new ways of using social engineering to fool customers. Raising consumer
awareness will help, but it would have to be a continuous process, with new
lessons being learned to cope with each new form of attack.
Few experts believe this approach will be as effective, in the long run, as a
move to variable passwords and the widespread adoption of secure email
technology.
· Send comments to online.feedback at guardian.co.uk. Please include address and
phone number. If you do not want your email address published, please say so.
--
==============
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list