[Ir-l] Black times for Microsoft

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Thu Nov 25 20:53:28 GMT 2004


http://www.guardian.co.uk/online/comment/story/0,12449,1359600,00.html

Black times for Microsoft

One of the software giant's most outspoken critics appears to have backed off, 
but the company's problems are far from over, writes Neil McIntosh

Guardian Online, Thursday November 25, 2004


Claims that Ed Black, one of Microsoft's most vociferous opponents, has 
pocketed millions of dollars in a settlement with the software giant will be 
greeted with fury by the company's opponents.

A $20m (£14m) payment to Black's employer - the Computer and Communications 
Industry Association (CCIA) - was made public earlier this month. The CCIA 
has been one of the fiercest critics of the company's behaviour during the 
lengthy series of legal challenges it has faced, so the settlement was met 
with some surprise.

Surprise turned to disbelief yesterday when it was alleged that Black was then 
given some of this money (estimates range from $2m to $10m), with the 
approval of the CCIA's board, although without the knowledge of Microsoft 
itself. Black has yet to deny the claims.

It is a remarkable turn of events after years of often-acrimonious struggle 
between the CCIA and Microsoft. Black has been a figurehead for resistance 
against Microsoft, calling the company "a rapacious monopoly", repeatedly 
accusing it of illegal behaviour and anti-competitive tactics, and as 
recently as spring of this year talking of using a European commission 
investigation to restore "consumer choice and innovation in multiple markets 
subject to the stranglehold of a monopolist".

Most industry observers felt the only outcome Black, and the CCIA, would 
accept would be the complete break-up of Microsoft.

Yesterday, Black insisted the CCIA had not been silenced by the money, and 
said the organization had not changed its position. "We have no obligation to 
stop our lobbying or our public relations efforts on areas outside the 
litigation," he said.

But mobile phone company Nokia - one of the IT giants now in Microsoft's 
sights as it attempts to break into the mobile phone arena - quit from the 
CCIA in protest at the deal, saying it was "inappropriate".

And, quickly, Black's lobbying appeared to take on a rather different tone to 
before. "Life is a constant reordering of priorities," he said when the 
Microsoft settlement was first announced. "For important and pragmatic 
reasons, we are choosing to move on with regard to this matter."

As Black discovers Zen-like calm over Microsoft's behaviour, does this mean 
the company's long-running, globe-spanning war against anti-trust laws is 
over? Not quite. A hearing today will examine why the CCIA and Novell - which 
also got $536m in settlement this month - have withdrawn their support for 
the European commission's stance on Microsoft.

The commission imposed a £350m fine on Microsoft earlier this year - a move 
welcomed by Black at the time as something that would help prevent Microsoft 
using its monopoly hold on the operating system market to also control the 
delivery of digital media such as video and audio.

The CCIA warned such control would hand enormous power to Microsoft, forcing 
"developers and consumers alike to bow to whatever demands or taxes Microsoft 
wishes to place on digital content".

Today, Real Networks, makers of the Real audio and video software, continues 
that fight alone, and the commission maintains its hearings - due to start in 
2006 - should still go ahead. But the enormous timescales - those hearings 
could last years - and Microsoft's enormous cash wealth make further 
settlements likely.

Indeed, the slow pace of the legal process has acted in Microsoft's favour all 
along. By the time it settled Netscape's claim against it with a $750m 
payment in 2003, Netscape was all but dead and had been bought by AOL/Time 
Warner. Microsoft's Internet Explorer had overwhelmed its pioneering rival.

It didn't matter that the tactics Microsoft used to gain victory were 
anti-competitive and illegal. As if to underline the scale of Netscape's 
defeat, the same settlement saw AOL agree a seven-year deal to use Internet 
Explorer for its own online services.

Even in the newer world of digital media, Real Networks is already struggling 
against the might of Microsoft. In digital media, claims Real, Microsoft is 
doing exactly as it did with Netscape years ago - doing as much as it can to 
force its media player on Windows users, and making life as difficult as 
possible for Real by hampering its technical and marketing efforts.

Microsoft undoubtedly wields enormous power because of its monopoly in 
operating system software, and the company is not afraid to use it to defend 
and promote other parts of its business. That, allied to mistakes by Real 
over product quality and strategic direction, make Microsoft a likely winner 
in this digital media battle, no matter what the courts say. Only Apple, 
thanks to the remarkable success of the iPod and its iTunes music store and 
software, is likely to offer real resistance in the longer term.

Not all is rosy in the garden for Microsoft. Away from the corporate big 
hitters and the courtrooms, danger is brewing for Bill Gates and Co. in the 
shape of small-scale innovation and the open source community.

Google now dominates search, and so far Microsoft's response - the MSN Search 
is a poor imitation. Worse for Microsoft, Google may be interested in a whole 
range of web services, as implied by its new Gmail service and its 
acquisition of Blogger.com - the easy-to-use web publishing tool that has 
helped spark a vibrant new class of website.

Meanwhile, the open source movement continues to trouble the company. The 
Apache web server, for instance, provides around 70% of the web pages you 
read (including these). And now the best web browser you can get is open 
source too, after version 1.0 of Firefox was released recently to huge 
acclaim.

Firefox is technically superior to a stagnating Internet Explorer, which 
Microsoft has paid little attention to since it won its monopoly grasp of the 
browser market. And the upstart rival doesn't rely on revenue streams to keep 
it alive - it's being given away free by a group of volunteer programmers. 
Here's one product Microsoft can't undercut.

Microsoft, its head turned by legal troubles, may also start to find its 
hugely profitable monopolies are like a ball and chain. As John Naughton 
recently explained in the Observer, Microsoft's very success might leave it 
trapped, unwilling to move because innovation may chip away at the Windows, 
Office and Internet Explorer monopolies that have served it so well until 
now.

For those left unhappy by Microsoft's tactics in the computer marketplace over 
the last decade, the march of progress might yet offer the greatest hope of 
cutting Microsoft down to size. Even this mighty company might find its 
billions in the bank are as nothing compared to its rivals' determination to 
take back pieces of the PC pie through innovation and hard work. 


-- 

==============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html




More information about the Ir-l mailing list