[Ir-l] ISPs the weakest link when it comes to free speech

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Oct 19 21:05:10 BST 2004


http://observer.guardian.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,1329036,00.html

ISPs the weakest link when it comes to free speech

John Naughton, The Networker
The Observer, Sunday October 17, 2004


FIVE years ago, I had a conversation with a friend of mine - a very eminent 
scholar who specialises in international relations. He looks like someone out 
of central casting - grey hair, an absent-minded bearing, with a penchant for 
elegant but crumpled corduroy suits. He has an acute sense of history, and 
often seems to view everything from an altitude of 30,000 feet. We were 
talking about the internet, and the challenge it represented to the 
established order. I had outlined what I saw as the amazing potential of the 
network to transform access to information, make it impossible for 
governments and media establishments to hush up scandals, undermine 
established corporations, create new kinds of businesses which had hitherto 
been inconceivable, etc, etc - in short, to change the world.

My friend courteously heard me out. Then he said: 'Well, we'll see. Perhaps 
this technology is indeed a revolutionary threat to the established order. 
But I wouldn't bet on it.'

Five years on, I'm not so sure I would bet on it either. Consider this report 
from Thursday's Guardian. 'Last week, Rackspace, a [web] hosting company with 
headquarters in Texas, handed two of its London-based servers to the FBI 
after a subpoena for their contents was issued by a US district court. The 
servers contained material belonging to the Independent Media Centre - better 
known as Indymedia (www.indymedia.org) - a conglomeration of global radical 
anti-globalisation sites produced by ordinary citizens.'

Now one of the interesting things about Indymedia is that much of its content 
is produced by amateurs - what it calls 'citizen journalists'. Its Internet 
Service Provider, Rackspace, said it was merely complying with a court order 
'which establishes procedures for countries to assist each other in 
investigations such as international terrorism, kidnapping and money 
laundering'. Indymedia has been unable to find out why its material has been 
seized and its sites disabled. Is it because, somewhere in its web pages, 
there are genuinely sinister things? Or just material that someone - the 
Attorney-General of the United States, for example - doesn't like? In the 
Kafkaesque world bequeathed to us by Osama bin Laden and his opponents, we 
simply don't know.

The moral of the Indymedia story is that, when push comes to shove with the 
established order, the internet usually blinks first. While in principle the 
net provides the most unfettered and uncensored communications medium in 
history, in practice it has a critical weak link - the fact that in order to 
access the net, everyone has to go through an ISP. And ISPs are, for the most 
part, commercial companies - organisations owned by shareholders and run by 
accountants and lawyers who tend to see the upholding of liberty and free 
speech as loss-making activities best avoided. What this means is that the 
moment a threatening letter arrives, they tend to take down the site 'just to 
be on the safe side'.

And usually they do this without examining whether the complaint has even 
superficial validity. You think I jest? Well, consider the findings of an 
experiment conducted recently by an activist group called 'Bits of Freedom'. 
They signed up with 10 Dutch ISPs and then put online a work by a famous 
Dutch author, Multatuli, who died more than 100 years ago. The online 
versions stated that the work was in the public domain. The group then set up 
a fake society which claimed to be the copyright holder of the work and sent 
out complaints to all 10 ISPs using a Hotmail address, demanding that they 
take down this 'copyrighted' material. Seven out of ten removed the site - 
one within just three hours. One ISP forwarded all the personal details of 
the site owner to the sender of the fake takedown notice without even being 
asked to do so. Only one ISP pointed out that the copyright on the work had 
expired many years ago. Or, to put it another way, only one of the 10 ISPs 
bothered to look at the supposedly offending material.

The moral is clear. If you want to censor someone, just get your lawyer to 
write a snotty letter to the ISP that hosts his or her site. More generally, 
those of us who worry about freedom will have to address the issue of ISPs. 
There may be a case, for example, for NGOs across the world to band together 
to set up an ISP which would be prepared to investigate and vigorously 
contest complaints and injunctions from the established order. The days when 
we could assume that we could 'publish and be damned' on the net are over.


john.naughton at observer.co.uk www.briefhistory.com/ footnotes/ 
-- 

==============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html




More information about the Ir-l mailing list