[Ir-l] Priceless thinking at the BBC

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun Apr 24 07:42:04 BST 2005


http://observer.guardian.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,1468695,00.html

The Networker

Priceless thinking at the BBC

The Observer, Sunday April 24, 2005


Photography shapes our world - and our perception of it. Think of the Vietnam 
war and what comes unbidden into your mind? Here's my guess: that photograph 
of the naked little girl running in terror after a napalm attack. Marilyn 
Monroe? That wonderful picture of her standing over a ventilator outlet with 
her skirt swirling up. The liberation of France? Henri Cartier-Bresson's shot 
of a woman collaborator being denounced in the street. And so it goes: we 
think in images. And many, if not most of them, are still provided by 
photography.

But then ask yourself: what if, when the technology was being invented, the 
law had required that before you took a photograph of anyone or anything, you 
had to ask permission? Imagine how restricted photography - both as reportage 
and art - would have been. And how impoverished our culture as a result.

Now spool forward a century or so. A film-maker is shooting a low-budget 
documentary about a musical performance. He discovers that the character of 
Homer Simpson appears for three-and-a-half seconds, on a barely visible 
television, in the background of a key shot. In accordance with the strict 
intellectual property (IP) laws that apply today, he has to ask broadcaster 
Fox, owner of The Simpsons , for permission to include the shot. The 
response? Sure - on payment of a $10,000 fee.

That's the world we now inhabit. And if the big multimedia organisations get 
their way, control of intellectual property will become even tighter. Until 
recently, everything was going their way. Clueless legislators were 
bamboozled by lobbying propaganda about the need to protect 'property' and 
stamp out 'piracy' and 'theft'. Mass media - generally owned by outfits with 
a vested interest in strong IP law - reported the issue in terms that were at 
best uninformed and at worst rabidly partisan.

And nobody, beyond a few isolated voices, spoke out for the public interest. 
Or pointed out the implications for free culture of a world in which every 
idea, and every expression of an idea, is 'owned' by someone (usually a 
company). Nobody asked what would become of music if every songwriter had to 
pay a royalty on every idea they'd borrowed from earlier songs. Or what would 
happen to film-making if the rights to every out-of-focus billboard, chair, 
poster or magazine cover had to be cleared and paid for before movies could 
be released.

The answer, of course, is simple. It is that creativity would be stifled 
because the barrier to entry to the market for cultural products would be too 
high for everyone except corporations. There would still be innovation and 
competition, but only on the terms that multimedia conglomerates would allow. 
The Disneys, Time-Warners, Pearsons and Bertelsmanns of this world would do 
fine. And everyone else would be kept in their place as passive consumers of 
whatever content-owners deigned to provide for their entertainment.

Until recently, this was the way the world was heading. But now something 
significant has happened to buck the trend. The BBC - the world's greatest 
creator of high-quality multimedia products - has finally launched its 
Creative Archive. The project - first announced by former director-general 
Greg Dyke in August 2003, and much delayed as BBC staff grappled with the 
rights issues implicit in it - will allow British residents to download clips 
of BBC factual programmes from bbc.co.uk for non-commercial use, keep them on 
their PCs, manipulate and share them, thereby making the BBC archives more 
accessible to licence-fee payers.

The content is not available yet but the licences under which it will be 
provided have now been published. In the next, pilot, phase of the project 
the Creative Archive will make 100 hours of BBC content available. The early 
stuff will come from the corporation's stupendous archive of nature and 
wildlife programmes, for two reasons: the IP issues are less complex because 
the BBC owns most of the rights; and nature programming will be of immediate 
use to important target groups, like schoolchildren doing their own video 
projects. And although some people are critical of this (one cynic described 
the content as 'shagging marmots'), there's no doubt about where this is 
heading. The world's leading public-service broadcaster is declaring it 
believes that creative output for which the public has paid should be in the 
public domain.

This is big news. Some years ago, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology 
blew the nascent educational-content business out of the water by making its 
courseware available for free on the web. Who would pay for content from 
Mickey Mouse universities when MIT's was free? By challenging the IP mania 
that threatens to engulf us, the Creative Archive project is doing something 
similar. And in the process showing us what public-service broadcasting is 
for.
-- 

==============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html




More information about the Ir-l mailing list