[Ir-l] Libel legacy of ousted aristocrat threatens internet

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Dec 27 02:28:29 GMT 2005


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://technology.guardian.co.uk/news/story/0,16559,1674047,00.html

Libel legacy of ousted aristocrat threatens internet

· Pressure to limit global reach of archaic UK law
· Rich foreigners make use of 156-year-old judgment

David Pallister
The Guardian, Tuesday December 27, 2005


A 156-year-old pillar of libel law prompted by an eccentric German duke which 
has allowed wealthy foreigners to sue in English courts could be declared 
obsolete, in a move that would have profound implications for the future of 
the internet.

The Department of Constitutional Affairs wants to re-examine the judgment, 
which set the precedent after it ruled in favour of the Duke of Brunswick in 
1849. The department is to launch a public consultation into whether the 
judgment is still relevant, following sustained criticism from lawyers and 
judges.

The ruling, Duke of Brunswick v Harmer, remains a bedrock of England's archaic 
defamation laws. It says that each individual publication of a libel gives 
rise to a separate cause of action - the so-called multiple publication rule.

Translated onto the global reach of the internet, this has had what lawyers 
call "chilling effects" on freedom of expression. Under it, an individual who 
downloads something he or she regards as libellous can in principle sue a 
publication based anywhere in the world. The legal action can be taken either 
in his or her own country or in England.

For the celebrities and overseas businessmen who sue through the high court in 
the Strand, all they have to show is that the story had more than a minimal 
circulation and that they had connections to England and a reputation to 
defend there. With defamation actions generally on the decline, they have 
provided new rich pickings for the libel bar as suits from afar afield as 
Russia and Saudi Arabia have been prosecuted in London.

In 1848 the Duke of Brunswick, then living in Paris, sent his manservant off 
to the British Museum to get a copy of the Weekly Dispatch published 17 years 
previously which he believed had defamed him. He also got a copy from the 
Dispatch's London publisher. Despite a limitation rule of six years in those 
days, the court of Queen's Bench decided that these receipts constituted a 
new publication of a libel and a cause for action. He was awarded £500, a 
huge sum at the time.

The duke's rule, says the media lawyer Mark Stephens, "is bringing the English 
libel courts into disrepute, with the rich jetting in from all over the world 
to launder their reputations".

Dan Tench, a specialist media lawyer at Olswangs, thinks it ought to go. "The 
duke's case is one of the hoariest of old precedents. It also is 
unconscionable that it is still considered good law today."

Earlier this year the court of appeal said that if a latter-day duke tried to 
sue in similar circumstances he would be given short shrift. "We would today 
condemn the entire exercise as an abuse of process," Lord Phillips, master of 
the rolls, said.

Three years ago in the high court of Australia, one judge remarked: "The idea 
that this court should solve the present problem by reference to judicial 
remarks made in England in a case, decided more than 150 years ago, involving 
the conduct of the manservant of a duke, dispatched to procure a back issue 
of a newspaper of minuscule circulation, is not immediately appealing to me." 
In a report on defamation and the internet produced in December 2002, the Law 
Commission suggested a review that would consider the way the US approaches 
the problem. Under America's single publication rule there is only one act of 
publication, when an article first appears, and only one cause of global 
action, in the place of publication. With internet users now nudging a 
billion, the threat of unpredictable litigation has grown. In England the 
cases have principally involved foreign businessmen, often Russians accused 
of wrongdoing, and Saudis accused of financing terrorism post 9/11. None of 
these accusations has stuck.

The Russian tycoon Boris Berezovsky's case against the US magazine Forbes (UK 
circulation 2,000) took six years to resolve in his favour in 2003, going to 
the House of Lords. Forbes' lawyers argued that the case should have been 
tried in the US or Russia. But the Lords prayed in aid the duke's rule, 
adding that Mr Berezovsky could sue in England because he had links and a 
reputation to protect here.

In a forthright minority opinion about libel tourists, Lord Hoffman laid out 
what he called "the common sense of the matter". Mr Berezovsky, he said, 
"wants the verdict of an English court that he has been acquitted of the 
allegations in the article, for use wherever in the world his business may 
take him. He does not want to sue in the United States because he considers 
it too likely that he will lose. He does not want to sue in Russia for the 
unusual reason that other people might think it was too likely that he would 
win."

But with new questions being asked about the judgment's relevance in an age of 
fast-changing internet publishing, the duke's grip over libel law may soon be 
loosened.

Profile: The Duke of Brunswick
While the principles of the Duke of Brunswick case are engraved on every libel 
lawyer's heart, nobody really knows what gross calumny was heaped on the duke 
in the issue of September 19 1830 of the Weekly Dispatch. Copies of the paper 
for that year are missing from the records of the British Library and the 
Library of Congress.

But it is likely that the offending article referred to an event seven days 
earlier when the people of his north German dukedom rose up against his 
autocratic tendencies and sent him packing, to live the next 43 years in 
dissolute and litigious exile in London, Paris and Geneva. Variously 
described as paranoid, obsessive and indiscreet, he once remarked that were 
it not for his enormous wealth, he would be in an insane asylum. In Paris he 
was a regular at the great restaurants with his heavily painted face, dyed 
black wig and extreme corpulence, brought on by a vast consumption of sweets.

In his efforts to regain his lands from Karl II, King of Hanover, Friedrich 
Herzog von Braunschweig-Wolfenbüttel set the precedent for immunity of heads 
of states that led to the Pinochet case six years ago. But it was not only as 
a prodigious litigant that he is remembered. He fancied himself as a 
competent chess player; in 1858, in one of the most famous defeats in the 
history of the game, he lost to the American prodigy Paul Morphy who gave a 
virtuoso attacking performance in the duke's private box at the Paris Opera. 
The duke was also the century's most acquisitive collector of rare coloured 
diamonds, including the Brunswick Blue and the Agra Pink, which he kept in a 
strong box protected by a fearsome array of mechanical security devices. An 
article written shortly after his death described him stepping out for the 
evening in diamond-festooned costumes; once he confided to some female guests 
at a party that crown jewels were also embroidered on his underclothes.

His legacy may be on the way out but his presence will certainly live on. At 
his death in 1873 he bequeathed his fortune to the city of Geneva, where he 
had spent the last three years of his life, on condition that it bury him in 
an ornate monument which would be the exact replica of Verona's 14th-century 
Scaligeri family mausoleum. It stands on the Quai du Mont-Blanc.


- -- 

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul's new book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/book.html

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFDsKbTpKOsa4QY6KURAuuWAJ9cEVYNHq64XPdZw45ybI9815y9sACgoV32
jmCD3Qkw9jZ1bZ5G8BOonOA=
=7Ufg
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list