[Ir-l] Blogger sacked for sounding off
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Jan 12 11:44:48 GMT 2005
http://www.guardian.co.uk/online/weblogs/story/0,14024,1388466,00.html
Blogger sacked for sounding off
"Waterstone's says bookseller brought firm into disrepute"
Patrick Barkham
The Guardian, Wednesday January 12, 2005
A bookseller has become the first blogger in Britain to be sacked from his job
because he kept an online diary in which he occasionally mentioned bad days
at work and satirised his "sandal-wearing" boss.
Joe Gordon, 37, worked for Waterstone's in Edinburgh for 11 years but says he
was dismissed without warning for "gross misconduct" and "bringing the
company into disrepute" through the comments he posted on his weblog.
Published authors and some of the 5 million self-published bloggers around the
globe said it was extraordinary that a company advertising itself as a
bastion of freedom of speech had acted so swiftly to sack Mr Gordon, who
mentions everything from the US elections to his home city of Edinburgh in
the satirical blog he writes in his spare time.
Mr Gordon, a senior bookseller who rarely mentioned work in his blog and did
not directly identify his branch of Waterstone's, said he had offered to stop
posting anything about his working life online when the company called a
disciplinary meeting. According to his union, Waterstone's rejected his plea
despite it not having any guidelines on whether its employees are allowed to
keep weblogs.
"This wasn't a sustained attack," Mr Gordon told the Guardian. "I was not
deliberately trying to harm the company. I was venting my spleen.
"This was moaning about not getting your birthday off or not getting on with
your boss. I wasn't libelling anyone or giving away trade secrets."
Mr Gordon joined Waterstone's while a student in 1993, a year after he began a
satirical newsletter which evolved into his blog, called the Woolamaloo
Gazette.
Named after Monty Python's fictional University of Woolloomooloo, the blog
contains the typical musings of online diarists across the world, linking to
interesting websites and sounding off about current affairs and favourite
films. There is much to please Waterstone's: most of the blog is devoted to
extolling the virtues of reading and Mr Gordon's favourite science fiction
and graphic novels.
In the past two months, the bookseller, who helped set up a branch of
Waterstone's, ran bookclubs and appeared on radio and TV for his company,
mentioned his work twice.
On one occasion, he ranted about his "sandal-wearing" manager he nicknamed
"Evil Boss", which he said was a caricature like the "Pointy Haired Boss" in
the Dilbert cartoons. In another posting, Mr Gordon joked about
"Bastardstone's".
After he was suspended pending an investigation into his blog, he was called
before a formal disciplinary meeting and sacked last week.
"The book trade can only exist with freedom of speech and information," he
said last night. "It is a big personal blow to me to lose my job and it also
has grave implications beyond that - for anybody who works for any company
and blogs, which is thousands of people."
The move has also alarmed the global internet community. Mr Gordon has
received dozens of emails from other bloggers who have heard about his
plight, with some pledging to boycott Waterstone's.
While Boris Johnson wrote about his sacking from the Tory frontbench on his
blog, it is believed to be the first time in Britain a blogger has been
dismissed for what they published on the web.
In the US, Ellen Simonetti was sacked from her job as a flight attendant for
Delta Air Lines after her bosses saw pictures of her posing in her uniform on
her website, which recounted the adventures of an anonymous flight attendant
who worked for "Anonymous Airline".
Jessica Cutler, a 24-year-old secretary at a senator's office who wrote about
selling sex to officials in Washington under the online name of
Washingtonienne, was outed on the internet and sacked from her job.
The literary world has also spoken out against the sacking. Richard Morgan,
the science fiction author, has written a letter of protest to Waterstone's.
"This bears comparison with taking disciplinary action based on private
conversations overheard in a pub, and raises some disturbing issues of
freedom of speech," he said.
"Waterstone's is, after all, a bookseller, whose stock in trade is the
purveying of opinion, not all of it palatable to those concerned. The action
that has been taken so far bears more resemblance to the behaviour of an
American fast-food chain than a company who deal in intellectual freedoms and
the concerns of a pluralist liberal society."
Five years ago, an award-winning advertising campaign for Waterstone's focused
on the importance of freedom of speech. One image featured a burned book with
the slogan: "Adolf Hitler, Pol Pot & Mao Tse-Tung were right about one thing.
The Power of Books."
A spokeswoman for Waterstone's confirmed Mr Gordon had been sacked. "At this
stage we can't comment on it," she said. "He has two opportunities to appeal
after he receives his letter of dismissal through the post."
The Retail Books Association, which represents 6,000 people working in the
book trade, said it would help Mr Gordon appeal against his dismissal. If an
appeal with a regional area manager is rejected, the blogger could take the
matter to an employment tribunal.
According to the RBA, Waterstone's should introduce guidelines determining
what its employers can say online about their work.
"We are hopeful we can get him reinstated," said David Pickles, president of
the RBA. "We feel it was heavy-handed and they have overreacted. The company
has no guidelines to say 'please don't' [write about work on a weblog]. They
shouldn't use a hammer to crack a nut.
"Some of the products they sell that are on open view to the public upset
people far more. If MPs can slag each other off in parliament and the press,
then surely Joe having a bad day and putting it down on the website should be
allowed.
"As long as there is no one being discriminating or offensive, if it is just
fun and opinion, then I can't see it being a problem. It's just how he felt
on the day."
Adventures with Evil Boss
Monday, Dec 13 2004
On the way home from a dreadful day at work (I should really have phoned in
sick but couldn't face the hassle this causes), I walked rather than catching
the bus to get the blood flowing a little. Not far from my flat is a new
bakery/pastry store, The Old Bakehouse, which also has an art gallery in the
basement. Delicious pastries and artwork? Now how cool is that? Groovy.
Tuesday, Nov 16
Bad things recently. Having to pay Edinburgh bastard moneygrubbing council's
tax, may they choke on every penny. Return to shift working as Evil Boss
decrees even those now in stockroom must do late and early shifts, which is a
waste of time for that post.
Xmas working hours brought in early - first shift now starts at 7.30 bloody
am, which is fucking ridiculous.
Evil Boss fucking me off by refusing my requests for a day's holiday on the
31st of December for my birthday and the first week of January off as I have
taken for the last few years ...
Evil Boss then has cheek to ask me to work one of the bloody bank holidays in
the week he refused me off. Cheeky smegger. Said no.
Noticing he has put me down for one of those days anyway, the sandal-wearing
bastard. Words will be exchanged - if he gives me my birthday off I will do
his bank holiday day. If not, he can kiss my magnificent Celtic ass, since it
is voluntary.
Monday Nov 8
Yes, my day slaving for Bastardstone's was lightened (never an easy task on a
Monday) by one of the avalanche of humour books that appear before Xmas, Far
From [Dull] and Other Places by Dominic Greyer ...
Amusing myself this week with Rich Hall's excellent biography of his redneck
"uncle", Otis Lee Crenshaw: I Blame Society, and probably pissing everyone in
our staffroom out by laughing my arse off.
--
==============
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list