[Ir-l] Keyboard cops
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Thu Jun 2 19:38:21 BST 2005
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
http://news.independent.co.uk/world/science_technology/story.jsp?story=643152
Keyboard cops
Forget leaving fingerprints at the scene of the crime. Today's police know
that the hard evidence they find on your hard drive can put you behind bars,
says Jimmy Lee Shreeve
The Independent, 1st June 2005
Computer forensic analysts - the detectives of the digital world - are in big
demand. Electronic evidence is proving critical in solving crimes, with the
proliferation of computers, PDAs, mobile phones and even iPods.
An internet bookmark or deleted e-mail can be vital to securing a conviction.
In South Dakota, a woman was found drowned in her bath with high levels of
temazepam in her blood. It looked like suicide - until investigators looked
at her husband's computer and found he'd been researching painless killing
methods online. With this evidence, prosecutors were able to convict him.
Law-enforcement agencies have realised that electronic evidence can help catch
all kinds of criminals, not just hackers, and are scrambling to hire skilled
people. In Britain, the Metropolitan Police is advertising for recruits.
"Successful candidates will be involved in the analysis of computer-based
media, advising officers on their findings and giving evidence in court," the
advert says.
In the US, the FBI manages a growing number of computer forensics labs. In
1984, the bureau's magnetic media programme dealt with three cases; last
year, its labs handled more than 1,500.
"The whole market is growing exponentially," says Andy Frowen (pictured
above), a director of CCL-Forensics (www.ccl-forensics.com), a Warwickshire
company supplying computer forensic services to 10 UK constabularies. "More
people own PCs and are connected to the internet, and the police are
increasingly aware that these devices can be used to commit or facilitate
crime."
In the past, equipment was usually seized in connection with suspected
paedophile or hacking offences. But today, says Frowen, "they seize computers
in murder, rape and fraud cases. Almost every crime at some point touches a
computer."
It's crucial that the evidence stays intact, so digital forensic examiners
never work directly on suspects' computers. "Every time you look at a file,
it changes - the date stamp, for instance, would register the day and time
you opened the file, contaminating the evidence," says Neil Barrett, a
professor of criminology at Cranfield University and the author of Traces of
Guilt (Corgi, 2005).
"We preserve digital evidence using a method known as 'imaging' or 'freezing'.
A suspect's hard drive is removed and put in a computer that is 'write
blocked' and can't write to the disk. A forensic image is then taken of that
hard drive - an exact clone that can be examined."
The most widely used software for this is EnCase (www.guidancesoftware.com), a
proprietary Windows-based program. The mantra is: delete doesn't mean gone.
Deleting a file, emptying the bin or even reformatting a hard drive will not
necessarily get rid of evidence. This is because computers retain data even
after it has been deleted.
Not surprisingly, software is available that deletes and overwrites data. One
such program is the Privacy Suite from CyberScrub (www.cyberscrub.com), which
claims to "remove all evidence of online activity, erase previously 'deleted'
files, and securely destroy e-mail". Such programs have legitimate uses -
bank details or health records would be at risk if you sold your computer or
others gained access to it.
Criminals can use this to cover their tracks, but it is time-consuming. "It
can take four or five hours, which makes it less attractive to criminals
because they are put out of action for that time," says Chris Vaughan, the
senior forensic analyst at the Manchester computer forensics firm Cy4or
(www.cy4or.co.uk). "And to remove everything, the file-wiping software has to
know exactly where to wipe. If it doesn't get this right, traces will be
left."
So are criminals staying one step ahead of the law? "It's bizarre," says
Barrett. "The criminals should be one step ahead of us, because all they need
do is encrypt their files. Yet those we catch rarely do this. Maybe we're
only catching the idiots."
Computer forensics is most commonly used in cases of child pornography, which
means forensic analysts have to see upsetting images. Emma Webb-Hobson of
Cy4or says she copes by cutting her mind off from the subject. "The
comforting thing is that you're helping to stop this kind of crime," she
says.
Many in the legal process now need some technical knowledge. In the Harold
Shipman case, the doctor had modified evidence on his computer and was caught
out by the date stamp on the records. "That obviously requires a jury to
understand what a date stamp is and how it can and can't be modified,"
Barrett says. "That requires someone to provide an interpretation in plain
English."
Jeff Fischbach, a US computer forensic analyst, says one downside in digital
evidence-gathering is that people are being falsely charged. A client was
charged with possessing child porn on his computer, but Fischbach showed that
the images came from spam and pop-ups.
What can an innocent person do if their computer is seized by police? Vaughan
says: "Law enforcement agencies ask us to look for signs of intent - did
somebody run multiple searches for 'child pornography', or open and view an
illegal image hundreds of times?"
"So the advice to anybody who accidentally gets a pop-up is to close it
instantly and, if possible, delete the internet cache. The same goes for spam
that gets through filters - delete it. This will show that you didn't want
the material and didn't look at it for longer than you needed to."
The field of computer forensics is constantly evolving to keep pace with new
devices. Any device that can store data can be used to harbour indecent
images, illegal software or fraudulent documents.
But criminals should heed the words of the computer forensics expert John
Mallery: "The only secure computer [or digital device] is the one you never
turn on, bury in the ground and cover with dirt."
- --
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQFCn1IdwRj1MJJ12hcRAsiYAKDH1YTrddzuM77L8wmO4lqdjONqQwCcCgRQ
2QKFFv5wec7/gFLmOng+XSg=
=ipGC
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list