[Ir-l] EU: Data Retention proposal partly illegal, say Council and Commission lawyers

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Jun 7 13:41:15 BST 2005


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://www.statewatch.org/news/2005/apr/02eu-data-retention.htm

EU: Data Retention proposal partly illegal, say Council and Commission lawyers


The Legal Services of both the Council and Commission have argued that the 
controversial proposal for a Framework Decision on the retention of telephone 
and Internet data, proposed last April by the UK and several other Member 
States, is partly illegal.

The Legal Services have confined themselves to examining the issue of whether 
part of the proposed Framework Decision falls within the scope of EC law (the 
'first pillar', dealing with economic issues, among others) or within the 
scope of the 'third pillar' (Title VI of the TEU, dealing with criminal law 
and policing). Both Legal Services conclude that the provisions in the 
proposed Framework Decision dealing with the obligations on service providers 
to retain and collect data on the use of phones and the Internet would be 
illegal, because this issue should instead be addressed by EC 'internal 
market' legislation on the regulation of telecommunications. In fact, a 
controversial EC Directive of 2002 already addressed this issue, by leaving 
Member States a discretionary option to require telecoms service providers to 
retain data on public use of telephones and the Internet for use by the law 
enforcement agecnies. The proposed Framework Decision would go further by 
making it mandatory for Member States to impose such requirements on telecoms 
service providers and by laying down some detail on the precise obligations 
that must be imposed.

The practical impact of the two Legal Services' opinions, if they are accepted 
by the EU institutions and the Member States, is that the proposed Framework 
Decision will have to be amended to take out all provisions relating to the 
obligations of telecom service providers. These provisions will instead 
appear in a separate parallel proposal for a Directive, which the Commission 
has already said it will propose in the near future. The decision-making 
procedure for the Directive will be very different from that applying to the 
Framework Decision: it will have to be proposed by the Commission (rather 
than the Member States); the Council will vote by a 'qualified 
majority' (rather than unanimity); and the European Parliament will have 
equal powers with the Council (the Member States' ministers) over adoption of 
the legislation (rather than being consulted only). The EU's Court of Justice 
also will have much wider jurisdiction over the Directive than it will have 
over the Framework Decision.

Unfortunately, the two Legal Services failed to consider whether the proposed 
measures, whatever form they take, would infringe the right to privacy or 
not. As the prior Statewatch analysis of the proposed Framework Decision 
showed, the initial proposal suffered from profound and fundamental flaws. In 
light of these flaws, the initial proposal cannot be justified in light of 
the right to privacy guaranteed by the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, the 
general principles of EU law, Article 8 of the European Convention on Human 
Rights, national constitutions and other international human rights treaties. 
But if the proposed Framework Decision is split into two measures as 
suggested by the legal services, the European Parliament will have the 
opportunity to show its concerns about the right to privacy and insist upon 
vetoing the proposed Directive or insisting upon fundamental changes to it, 
in order to ensure that this fundamental human right is protected.

This would also be an opportunity for the European Parliament to insist upon a 
proper initial impact assessment to examine whether the huge cost which the 
proposal would entail for an industry crucial to Europe's economic growth can 
be justified, in light of the less intrusive but more effective measures that 
could be taken to focus police investigations on persons who are reasonably 
suspected of involvement in serious crime - instead of mass surveillance of 
the entire society.

Tony Bunyan, Statewatch editor, comments:

"The proposal should be withdrawn as the law enforcement agencies have all the 
powers they need. If it goes ahead and the costs are bourne by the 
communications industry we will all end up having to pay to be placed under 
surveillance by the state!"

1. Council Legal Service Opinion (document: 7688/05, French., pdf)
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2005/apr/Council-legal-opinion-data-retention.pdf

2. European Commission's Legal Opinion (SEC(2005) 420, French, pdf)
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2005/apr/Commission-legal-opinion-data-retention.pdf

3. Latest draft of the proposal: Draft Framework Decision on the retention of 
data processed and stored in connection with the provision of publicly 
available electronic communications services or data on public communications 
networks for the purpose of prevention, investigation, detection and 
prosecution of crime and criminal offences including terrorism (document: 
6566/05, pdf)
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2005/apr/draft-data-retention-proposal.pdf

4. EU: Mandatory data retention national parliaments express concern and 
opposition
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2004/dec/03data-retention-parls.htm

5. Statewatch analysis of data retention proposal
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2004/apr/21dataretention.htm

6. Statewatch analysis: Data protection or data retention? (pdf)
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2001/sep/dataprot.pdf

- -- 


"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, 
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are 
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom, 
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness, 
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with 
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFCpZXxwRj1MJJ12hcRAnMmAKDOGMx0g5NrGld4t/0dtq00MokQCQCg1gjB
bd48BzbFRiIelIFIxwvrjrw=
=nucb
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list