[Ir-l] Internet's new wave proves hard to catch

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun Jun 26 12:43:26 BST 2005


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://observer.guardian.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,1514516,00.html

Internet's new wave proves hard to catch

The press wants to get bloggers on its side, but a US experiment shows it may 
not be easy, writes Rafael Behr

The Observer, Sunday June 26, 2005


What would happen if a newspaper invited readers to an editorial conference 
down the pub? First to arrive would be fans of the paper, keen to get 
involved. Next would be curious bystanders, drawn by the heat of debate. Last 
would be the drunken idiots, ranting and swearing incoherently until they 
were escorted from the premises.

At closing time the newspaper would be left with no editorial - and a lot of 
spilt beer to wipe up.

That is pretty much what happened when the LA Times last week opened up its 
editorial comment on Iraq to public amendment online. It was called a 
wikitorial, from 'wiki' - originally Hawaiian for 'quickly', now internetese 
for a page that can be edited by allcomers. It is one of the many innovations 
that old media see happening, know is important, but don't know why.

Perhaps a pub is not the best analogy of what happened last week. You have to 
be an adult to get into a pub, and people behave better when you can look 
them in the eye. On the internet anonymity breeds mischief. Sometimes malice.

At first the comment piece evolved sensibly. But once the newspaper's online 
monitor had gone to bed all hell broke loose. Discussion of US exit strategy 
from Iraq gave way to 'Fuck USA' and hardcore pornography. The feature was 
pulled after 48 hours.

The newspaper, cheered perhaps by the high ratio of encouragement to derision 
in bloggers' post mortems, has promised to revive the idea with better 
policing.

'I hope the LA Times gets back on the bike and rides again,' said Jeff Jarvis 
at Buzzmachine, an influential media blog. 'I salute them for the effort.'

The LATimes is right to show deference to the blogosphere. US media used to 
look at the internet as a potential cash cow - a way to milk new money from 
old content. Then, last year, a ragtag army of online commentators hounded 
Dan Rather, the CBS news anchor, out of his job for running with a false 
story.

Now the old media see the new as a circus tiger. It is cute, it does tricks, 
people pay to look at it - but one day it might rip your throat out. The LA 
Times's approach to its wikitorial was timid and patronising at the same 
time, and that was the problem. The tiger will be stroked, but when it smells 
weakness it bites.

It is often assumed that newspaper journalists do not understand the internet 
because of complacency or technological illiteracy. Both exist. But a third 
factor is just as important: the journalist's outmoded self-image.

The fourth estate likes to think of itself as maverick. It is the gadfly that 
exists to prick the vanities of power. This mythology of journalism does not 
have room for a fifth estate that is more maverick and exists to prick the 
vanities of the media.

With the wikitorial the Times probably thought it was inviting readers to join 
it on the barricades. But it was opening the gates to the Winter Palace. 
Predictably, the mob went on the rampage.

This was just one episode in an ongoing cold war between the US media and the 
blogosphere. It makes for an interesting comparison with another blogging 
story that blew up on this side of the Atlantic last week.

'Au blog, citoyens', screamed the front page of leftwing daily Libération, 
echoing the call to arms in the 'Marseillaise'. Inside, the newspaper devoted 
a double-page spread to the story of Christophe Grébert, a blogger from the 
small town of Puteaux who used his site, monputeaux.com, to report on the 
politics of the local town hall. He is being pursued by the mayor for 
defamation, a development that guarantees him worldwide internet martyrdom.

Along with a celebration of citizen blogs around the country, Libération 
hinted its support for Grébert in an editorial comment. 'The law should 
certainly punish malevolent rumour, defamation and intimidation,' the 
newspaper said. 'But it is more important still that the law is not subverted 
by those who want to limit the field of free speech and fair comment. Blogs 
can be a powerful tool in the service of democracy.'

It is hard to imagine a US newspaper weighing in so heavily in favour of a 
blogger. At least not without a nervous caveat about the sacred calling of 
the professional journalist and a swipe at intemperate amateurs.

But French newspapers have come to a relatively easy accommodation with the 
internet parvenus. Even Le Monde, by reputation one of the stuffiest 
publications in the world, has a coterie of citizen-correspondents blogging 
under the paper's masthead.

But then blogging, with its emphasis on solidarity, common endeavour and 
direct action, could have been custom-made for France. This is the nation, 
after all, that was dragged into the modern era by a revolutionary mob and 
for whom collective protest and taking to the streets are part of the 
political DNA. This is also the nation that learns rhetorical flourish at 
school the way other nations learn maths. It is not surprising that France is 
the European country with the highest number of blogs - about 3 million, 
compared to about 900,000 in Britain. But French newspapers are losing 
circulation in line with the global trend.

Newspaper editors and media owners are increasingly convinced that somewhere 
on the internet lies the answer to their declining sales woes. But they don't 
know where to look.

The LA Times wikitorial represents one approach - to join 'em in the hope, 
eventually of beating 'em at their own game. It is risky. And it isn't really 
journalism. But that is why it is appealing. Risky plus new equals sexy.

Libération's front page represents another approach - looking to the internet 
not for ways to do business but for stories - and not just stories for 
technology supplements. Instead of trying to erect their own internet 
barricades, newspapers would do well to stand by and report from other 
peoples' barricades. It isn't very sexy, but at least it is journalism.

The Observer has a blog at www.observer.co.uk/blog

- -- 


"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, 
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are 
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom, 
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness, 
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with 
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFCvpTfwRj1MJJ12hcRAl+wAJ0QdGLqxfAzL6/Sa2LSewq/R1T+GgCfdHEF
oB0GQkIXezz/xmXDWUK0Dh8=
=9oKQ
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list