[Ir-l] An excellent program about the 'hole in the wall' computer project in India

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed May 4 00:04:06 BST 2005


Hi all,

Caught this today -- a really excellent two-part series on the 'hole in the 
wall' computer projects in India [http://www.niitholeinthewall.com/]. You can 
listen to the programme online (up to 7 days after transmission) at:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/progs/listenagain.shtml
(under 'H').

I've included the web site article about the project below.

I'll probably rip the audio from the web and MP3 it if anyone's interested.


P.




http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/4498511.stm

Teach-yourself computing for kids

BBC News Online, Monday, 2 May, 2005
By Mark Rickards
BBC News, Rajasthan

Today is an important day for one Indian boy, nine-year-old Narput Singh. 

Something new is arriving in his remote village of Varna in the dusty, dry 
state of Rajasthan.

Something he has never had a chance to see before - it is a computer.

The digital divide seems at its greatest in India. On one side you have some 
of the most advanced work in IT taking place in cities like Bangalore or 
Delhi.

On the other you have children who have little or no access to new technology 
and live in conditions where clean water and electricity are still luxuries.

It is this divide that one man, Sugata Mitra, intends to bridge.

He was first struck by it looking out of his office window.


Breaking barriers

Inside his IT compound he could see the young techno-savvy professionals, 
belts hung with electronic gadgets.

Beyond the perimeter fence, he could see the dispossessed children sleeping 
rough in a shanty town. 

He decided it was time to break a hole in the wall and give the children 
outside a chance to see what a computer was.

He cut a hole and hooked one up. What happened next amazed him. They taught 
themselves how to use it.

Sugata took his experiment further and set up computers amongst the 
underprivileged communities of Delhi.

He built special kiosks where only children could reach the keyboard, and left 
them connected to the internet. In each case the results were the same.

Without adult intervention, the children got to grips with the technology, 
even with their limited understanding of English.

Sugata was able to make some important but controversial observations.

"Groups of children given adequate digital resources can meet the objectives 
of primary education on their own - most of the objectives."


Teaching themselves

In the thousands of small villages across the length and breadth of India, 
this clearly has enormous implications.

If the schools cannot provide access to both computers and trained teachers, 
then perhaps Sugata's approach could work.

And for the children of Varna, the day has come. 

 The Hole in the Wall project is to leave a computer in their village, and it 
will be up to Narput Singh and his friends to work out how to use it.

The moment the box is open, the children swarm around it.

They've never even seen the packaging before and some of them are rubbing bits 
of polystyrene on their arms, even trying a bite of it.

Sugata gives a short talk before letting them loose.

"Who can ride a bicycle?" he asks. Forty hands shoot up.

"And who taught you?" There is some confusion and shaking of heads.

"No-one taught you," he says. "It's a skill you can learn on your own."

He turns to the computer behind him. "And the computer is like a bicycle."


Fun and games

With the computer switched on, the children press all the keys and every mouse 
button.

But Sugata has noticed a pattern emerging after the first initial chaos.

"You find that the noise level begins to come down, and from somewhere a 
leader appears.

"Often his face is not visible in the crowd, but he is controlling the mouse 
because suddenly you see the mouse begin to move in an orderly fashion.

"And then suddenly a lot of children's voices will say 'Oh, that pointer can 
be moved!' And then you see the first click, which - believe it or not - 
happens within the first three minutes."

Narput Singh has the mouse and takes control. And within three minutes he has 
clicked and, to his surprise and pleasure, inadvertently opened a game.

He doesn't distinguish between educational games and those that are just for 
fun, and he is soon learning English words through a painting game with 
colours to fill in.

Whilst he is picking up the use of the computer directly, others around him 
are absorbing what he does.


Scarce resources

For Sugata, it is this group learning which is significant.

"We know that in nine months the entire group of children in a village would 
have reached approximately the level of an office secretary, which means they 
know dragging and dropping files, they know downloading, they can play video 
and audio and they can surf the internet".

Not everyone is enthralled with Sugata's results.

Tom Standage, technology editor of the Economist, is sceptical of such 
projects.

He points out that Bill Gates chose not to drop computers across the 
developing world as part of aid packages, preferring to concentrate on 
medicines and other more practical help for poor communities.

"Do you really want to have the maintenance of PCs in villages? Couldn't you 
have spent the money on a water pump? I'm not saying there's no benefit to 
it, but it may have been that the resources could have been used elsewhere in 
a way which helped more people."

It costs Sugata about $1,900 for every computer put into a village, and he 
believes it is worth it.

Most of the cost goes in maintenance as the technology has to withstand a 
tremendous pounding from the elements and the users.

But, as the sun sets and the desert cools, Narput Singh is still engrossed, 
and will be for some hours to come.

The adults of the village also welcome the new developments, believing it will 
offer their offspring much better chances than they have had themselves.

"The internet is the future," says one elder, "and our children have dreams."

Time will show whether the dreams are turned to dust in the desert, or whether 
the computer can make a lasting difference to these children's lives.

Mark Rickards is a senior producer with BBC Radio Four.

A Hole in the Wall, presented by BBC South Asia Correspondent Navdip Dhariwal, 
will be broadcast on 3rd May at 1000 -1030 GMT on BBC Radio Four. 


-- 

==============

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our
nation, and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace
and unity with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html




More information about the Ir-l mailing list