[Ir-l] Big Brother is watching you

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun Oct 2 21:56:22 BST 2005


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://observer.guardian.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,1582721,00.html

Big Brother is watching you

Google not only gathers vast amounts of personal data, it aspires to global 
domination - and that's creepy, writes John Naughton

The Observer, Sunday October 2, 2005


A few months ago Bill Gates let slip an interesting thought about Google in an 
interview. It reminded him, he said, of Microsoft in its honeymoon period - 
ie. the decade 1985-95. This is the first time in recorded history that Gates 
has dignified a competitor by actually naming it in public: generally, he 
speaks only in paranoid generalities. But the Microsoft chairman knows 
trouble when he sees it, and Google does indeed pose a long-term threat to 
his profitable monopoly.

That's par for the course in the capitalist jungle. A more important question 
is whether Google spells trouble for the rest of us in the long run. And the 
answer to that could well be yes.

To understand why, we need to look back. It may be hard to credit it now, but 
Microsoft was once a cheeky start-up, run by college dropouts with long hair 
and a penchant for fast cars. It was founded at a time when the fledgling 
personal computer business was a labyrinth of incompatible hardware and 
software systems. In 1981, IBM effectively defined a de-facto hardware 
standard; and its erstwhile partner Microsoft defined the software standard 
by providing the operating system for the new, accountant-friendly IBM PC. 
Thus was order brought to an unruly industry. And thus was the foundation 
laid of Microsoft's subsequent prosperity - and its monopoly on desktop 
software.

We all know the rest of the story. Microsoft has grown and grown, to the point 
where its monopoly lock on desktop software makes it impossible for an 
upstart to supplant it: the world's organisations are so locked into the 
Microsoft Way that they cannot contemplate moving to a different operating 
system, even if it is cheaper or technically superior.

Yet, strangely, it would be wrong to conclude from this that Microsoft's 
position is unassailable. Granted, it has a stranglehold on the PC platform, 
and anyone who tries to compete on that territory is doomed to lose. The 
significance of Google's challenge is that it hasn't chosen to fight on that 
ground. Instead, it seeks to make the platform irrelevant.

And it's doing it. Here's an illustration. Ask any random audience of computer 
users the following questions. Who uses Microsoft software? (All hands go 
up.) Who uses open source software? (No hands.) Who uses Google? (All hands 
go up). 'Well', you say, 'that's a funny thing because you're all users of 
open source software: Google runs on Linux.' After the rueful laughter has 
died away, ponder on what that means. People want a particular computing 
service (in this case search), and don't really care what platform it's 
delivered on.

Since its inception in 1999, Google has focused almost exclusively on 
providing services that are platform-independent in this way. Its search 
engine can be accessed from any browser. Ditto Google Groups, Google Images, 
Google News, Froogle, Blogger, Google Mail, Google Talk and Google Maps. A 
few of its offerings (notably Google Earth, Desktop Search and Picasa, a neat 
program for handling and organising digital photographs) are written 
specifically to run under Microsoft Windows, but the most heavily used 
services are all independent of operating systems and hardware. The company 
has taken Scott McNealy's aphorism - 'the network is the computer' - and 
turned it into reality.

All of which is bad news for Mr Gates, whose prosperity is based on the 
proposition that the platform is the computer. But is it good news for the 
rest of us? Google's most intensively used services are accessed via the net, 
so all the data involved flows through Google's servers. And since these data 
are often fragments of intensely personal information - email, web 
clickstreams, instant messages, VoIP conversations - a single company is in a 
position to know more about each one of us than anyone would have thought 
possible even a decade ago.

Consider Gmail, Google's web-mail service. This provides two gigabytes of 
storage to each subscriber - enough to ensure that you never again have to 
delete a message. The flipside is that your messages reside forever on a 
Google server. What's more, Gmail is free because it is funded by 
advertising: Google's software scans every email, identifies key phrases, and 
puts what it regards as relevant ads on the right-hand side of the screen.

If you think that's creepy, you're right. Google's response is that the 
messages aren't actually 'read', that it's just a process akin to the one in 
which email messages are scanned by spam-blocking software. But that's 
disingenuous, because the ads selected for display are logged (they have to 
be, so that advertisers can be billed) and those logs will inevitably reveal 
something of the context, if not the content, of the scanned messages. Anyone 
who uses Gmail is therefore sacrificing a degree of privacy compared with 
someone who uses a conventional email service. That's why privacy and civil 
liberties groups have attacked Gmail on the grounds that it violates the 
trust of email service users - in particular non-Gmail users who send 
messages to Gmail subscribers. They point out that scanning creates lower 
expectations of privacy in the email medium and so establishes a potentially 
dangerous precedent.

Google's apparently unstoppable momentum is beginning to raise alarm bells 
across an industry that hitherto admired the company's cheeky, upstart ethos 
and the brilliance of its technology. This, after all, was an outfit that 
declared in its prospectus that its motto would be 'Don't do evil'. The 
implicit message from the co-founders, Larry Page and Sergey Brin, was: 
'We're basically good guys. You can trust us.' But that was then, and this is 
now, when Google has evolved into a multi-billion dollar corporation with 
aspirations to global domination. Its corporate mission, remember, is 'to 
organise the world's information and make it universally accessible and 
useful'. And when these guys say 'world', they mean it.

So there's a strong possibility that Google will indeed turn out to be Bill 
Gates's worst nightmare, transforming his grip on the PC platform into a 
wasting asset. But the corollary of that is a world in which millions - 
perhaps billions - of people will become users of Google services, and that 
the company will become custodians of their most intimate data. The day will 
come when Google knows more about each of us than we realise. And knowledge 
is power.

Should we trust a US corporation with it? You only have to ask the question to 
know the answer.


Ten things you didn't know about Google

1 It's a calculator. Type '25 miles in kilometres' (without the quotes) into 
the search box and see what happens.

2 It can be manipulated to produce desired results. Try typing 'miserable 
failure' (without the quotes) and see what happens. This is called 
Googlebombing.

3 Googlewhacking is a game where you have to think of a single word which, 
when typed into the search box, will produce just a single 'hit'.

4 How many pages does Google index? Answer: nobody knows. Google used to 
publish a number under the search box (when last seen it was over 8 billion) 
but it has stopped doing that - possibly because Yahoo is now claiming to 
index 20 billion pages.

5 It does really useful online maps of the UK. Go to maps.google.co.uk. And 
you can search for restaurants, churches, bars or schools just by typing the 
appropriate term (e.g. 'restaurants in Bedford') in the search box.

6 Google's two co-founders are each worth about $7 billion. They are just 32 
years old.

7 If you use Google's webmail, the messages reside forever on a Google server.

8 Google's power means that it knows more about each of us than any other 
internet search engine.

9 Google's Gmail software scans every email, identifies key phrases, and puts 
what it regards as relevant ads on the right-hand side of the screen.

10 Its services, such as Google Images, Google News, Froogle, Blogger, Google 
Mail and Google Maps can be accessed from any browser.

- -- 


"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, 
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are 
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom, 
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness, 
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with 
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul's new book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/book.html

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFDQEl3wRj1MJJ12hcRAtxZAJ9NPfCfgHD4oY5MdFk+o/Fqhh8ixwCgsIJF
ohXcce+v6vmQ+1nDCqkB2u4=
=scox
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list