[Ir-l] Google defies US over search data

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Fri Jan 20 20:00:16 GMT 2006


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4630694.stm

Google defies US over search data

BBC News, 20/1/2006


The internet search engine Google is resisting efforts by the US Department of 
Justice to force it to hand over data about what people are looking for.

Google was asked for information on the types of query submitted over a week, 
and the websites included in its index.

The department wants the data to try to show in court it has the right 
approach in enforcing an online pornography law.

It says the order will not violate personal privacy, but Google says it is too 
broad and threatens trade secrets.

Privacy groups say any sample could reveal the identities of Google users 
indirectly. And they say the demand is a worrying precedent, because the 
government also wants to make more use of internet data for fighting crime 
and terrorism.

However, the Department of Justice has said that several of Google's main 
competitors have already complied.


Act blocked

The department first issued a request for the data last August.

It wants:

    * A list of terms entered into the search engine during an unspecified 
single week, potentially tens of millions of queries

    * A million randomly selected web addresses from various Google databases.

The US government is seeking to defend the 1998 Child Online Protection Act, 
which has been blocked by the Supreme Court because of legal challenges over 
how it is enforced. 

 Google's refusal to comply prompted US Attorney General Alberto Gonzales to 
ask a federal judge in the state of California on Wednesday for an order to 
hand over the records.

But Google's lawyers said it would fight the order.

"Google is not a party to this lawsuit and their demand for information 
overreaches," associate general counsel Nicole Wong said in a written 
statement.

"We had lengthy discussions with them to try to resolve this, but were not 
able to, and we intend to resist their motion vigorously."


Search decisions

Google has also said that providing the data would make its users think it was 
willing to reveal personal information about them, as well as giving 
competitors access to trade secrets.

 One of its search rivals, Yahoo, said it had already complied with a similar 
government subpoena "on a limited basis and did not provide any personally 
identifiable information".

And Microsoft said in a statement that it "works closely with law enforcement 
officials worldwide to assist them when requested".

"It is our policy to respond to legal requests in a very responsive and timely 
manner in full compliance with applicable law," it said. 





http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4631924.stm

Google data request fuels fears

By Mark Ward
Technology Correspondent, BBC News, 20/1/2006


At first glance it is hard to understand why the US Government's Justice 
Department wants Google to hand over a week's worth of search data.

To begin with, this would be a huge amount of information to paw through. In 
an average week, Google handles between 500 million and a billion searches.

While this is far less than the US government's request for 60 days worth of 
data, it is likely to produce a huge file tens, if not hundreds, of gigabytes 
in size.

At the same time, the US government wants a random sample of one million 
websites that people have searched for.

One of Google's defences against the Justice Department request is that it 
already has data from other search firms such as Yahoo, AOL and MSN.

However, government lawyers argue that the way Google ranks and classifies the 
data it returns to searchers will prove particularly useful for its purposes.

Essentially it wants data from search engines to prove how easy it is to 
stumble over porn on the net. If it can prove this the result might be 
onerous regulation for many websites.

In court documents the US government said it had tried to generate the same 
information using the Internet Archive website but did not get the results it 
wanted.


Dangerous game

It is well known that net service firms and search engines do hand over 
records to law enforcement agencies who need the data for ongoing criminal 
investigations.

In many cases data found in computer memory caches or searches people have 
done online have been used in successful prosecutions. 

But in the UK and US there are laws in place that limit how much and what 
types of information can be requested. So-called "fishing expeditions" in 
which police forces or intelligence works request data and look through it 
for people that have committed crimes are outlawed.

Danny Sullivan, net consultant and founder of Search Engine Watch, said the 
request Google is fighting was not tied to any criminal investigation by law 
enforcement organisations.

"This is a weird one and is not something that has come up before," he told 
the BBC News website.

He said the fear was that the US Government wanted to set a precedent with 
this request so it can turn to search firms whenever they want, for whatever 
data is deemed important.

Certainly, he said, the data being requested is innocuous and has little in it 
that could tie it to individuals.

But, said Mr Sullivan, because the potential is there to link people with 
searches for particular terms, such as bomb making materials, the worry is 
that governments will use the data to monitor and spy on civilians.

Increasingly, he said, search firms were working to personalise their service 
and it is possible to tie some searches to particular users or machines.


Information online

It is clear that the more that people do via the net, the greater the chance 
to keep an eye on them. And it is not just data from Google that can be 
useful.

In early January talented hacker Tom Owad showed what could be done with 
Amazon's wish list to uncover "subversives".

Mr Owad downloaded the five gigabytes of raw data that makes up the wishlists 
of the 260,000 Amazon customers that share a common male name.

Writing about his work, Mr Owad said it would be easy to use this data to find 
out which people are looking for banned books or works considered to be 
dangerous.

Writing about the row, net analyst John Battelle said net users were only just 
beginning to come to terms with the trust they transfer to firms such as 
Google, Yahoo and others to properly safeguard often deeply personal 
information.

"And I'm not sure either we or they are entirely sure what to do with the 
implications of such a transfer," he wrote. "Just thinking about these 
implications makes a reasonable person's head hurt." 


- -- 

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul's new book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/book.html

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFD0UFVpKOsa4QY6KURAniQAJ9HEPkEMEwLFZWTW089FTV/Z0H6ywCfYdk2
i265dmjreW0qw/jVU4m/iro=
=viqw
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list