[Ir-l] Torvalds: No GPL 3 for Linux

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Thu Jan 26 23:08:44 GMT 2006


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://news.com.com/Torvalds+No+GPL+3+for+Linux/2100-7344_3-6031504.html??tag=st.txt.caro

Torvalds: No GPL 3 for Linux

By Stephen Shankland
Staff Writer, CNET News.com
Published: January 26, 2006


update Linus Torvalds said Wednesday that he won't convert Linux to version 3 
of the General Public License, as he objects to digital rights management 
provisions in the proposed update.

The position is a significant--though not entirely unexpected--rejection of 
the update, the first to the seminal license in 15 years. Linux, the kernel 
at the heart of an operating system that clones much of generally proprietary 
Unix, is considered the best-known and most successful example of open-source 
software.

"Conversion isn't going to happen," Torvalds said in a posting to the Linux 
kernel mailing list. "I don't think the GPL v3 conversion is going to happen 
for the kernel, since I personally don't want to convert any of my code."

Torvalds specifically objected to one new provision in the GPL 3 draft that 
opposes digital rights management, which is technology that uses encryption 
to control the use of content and running of software. "I think it's insane 
to require people to make their private signing keys available, for example. 
I wouldn't do it," he said. 

 The GPL is a legal document and manifesto of the free software and 
open-source movements. It outlines several freedoms for collaborative 
software development, stipulating that a program's underlying source code may 
be seen, copied, modified and distributed.

The Linux-GPL issue highlights a long-running philosophical split in the 
collaborative programming movements. Torvalds represents a pragmatic approach 
that accommodates computer industry prevailing practices. For example, 
Torvalds worked for years on proprietary software at chip designer Transmeta, 
and he permits proprietary video card drivers to be loaded as modules into 
the Linux kernel.

On the other side of the divide is Richard Stallman, founder and president of 
the Free Software Foundation. His goals are explicitly ethical and social, 
and his principles are unbending. "The foundation believes that free 
software--that is, software that can be freely studied, copied, modified, 
reused, redistributed and shared by its users--is the only ethically 
satisfactory form of software development, as free and open scientific 
research is the only ethically satisfactory context for the conduct of 
mathematics, physics or biology," Stallman and FSF attorney Eben Moglen wrote 
in a GPL 3 background article.

GPL 3 draft released
The Free Software Foundation released the first public draft of GPL 3 earlier 
in January. The move began what's expected to be about a year's worth of 
discussion and revision.

The GPL 3 draft contains new words opposing digital rights management, which 
Stallman and Moglen regard as technology that restricts freedoms users must 
have.

"As a free software license, this license intrinsically disfavors technical 
attempts to restrict users' freedom to copy, modify and share copyrighted 
works," the draft license states. "No permission is given...for modes of 
distribution that deny users that run covered works the full exercise of the 
legal rights granted by this license."

In other words, some form of locking of GPL code to prevent changes from an 
authorized version is forbidden.

Torvalds' position is not a surprise. In a 2003 posting to the kernel mailing 
list, the Linux founder explicitly opened the door to DRM.

"I also don't necessarily like DRM myself," Torvalds wrote. "But...I'm an 
'Oppenheimer,' and I refuse to play politics with Linux, and I think you can 
use Linux for whatever you want to--which very much includes things I don't 
necessarily personally approve of."

Torvalds founded the Linux project in 1991, the same year the current GPL 
version 2 was released, and is still its leader. His kernel project 
dovetailed with work Stallman had already began to create a free clone of 
Unix, called Gnu's Not Unix (GNU). Because of that combination, the Free 
Software Foundation prefers the entire operating system be called 
GNU/Linux--though it has other important components, such as the Xorg 
graphics system, that come from other groups. 

In a 2004 interview, Torvalds indicated he wants the GPL to serve nothing 
beyond the single function of keeping source code open.

"I really want a license to do just two things: Make the code available to 
others, and make sure that improvements stay that way. That's really it. 
Nothing more, nothing less. Everything else is fluff." 

 Because of that cautious stance, Torvalds specifically didn't follow with 
Linux the Free Software Foundation's recommendation to describe a software 
project as governed by version 2 or "any later version."

The issue of moving to GPL 3 is grounded in copyrights. Many open-source 
projects, such as MySQL or OpenSolaris, require that programmers turn over 
copyrights to a central organization. That organization then grants the 
programmers a license of their own to the software source code in question. 
But with Linux, the copyrights are held by a large number of individuals and 
companies that contributed the code.

To convert Linux to GPL 3, it's likely more than just Torvalds' approval would 
be required. For example, when the SpamAssassin project converted to the 
Apache License so it could become part of the Apache Software Foundation, 
project organizers spent months getting explicit permission for the change 
from about 100 copyright holders. Even then, not all contributors could be 
found, and some software had to be rewritten. 

 The Free Software Foundation also has lodged objections about Torvalds. In an 
interview after the GPL 3 draft was released, Moglen said Torvalds doesn't 
use a "pure GPL" and that practices such as permitting proprietary video 
drivers violate the license.

Missing out
Keeping Linux with GPL 2 means the project won't be able to take advantage of 
some changes. And some experts believe GPL 3 is better.

"I think it's a definite improvement. It clarifies where there is ambiguity 
and deals with issues that have come up over time," said Mark Radcliffe, an 
intellectual property attorney with DLA Piper Rudnick Gray Cary who 
represents the Open Source Initiative and who is overseeing some gathering of 
commentary for the GPL 3.

Regarding rights management, Radcliffe said Stallman "views DRM as potentially 
evil. He wants to make it very clear that DRM is not permitted, and you 
cannot implement DRM systems using GPL code."

But Radcliffe also believes those fears could be overstated, judging by the 
commercial failures of attempts to control software in the past--such as with 
hardware "dongles" that must be attached to a computer before a particular 
program will run. "The practical risk of it being applied to software is 
lower than it being applied to content," he said. 


- -- 

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul's new book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/book.html

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.5 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFD2VZ8pKOsa4QY6KURAmRlAKC0W6XEtFz0EDvpm4g0A3R6+bUgOwCfROnC
K7iv+McWewqnhlN3rj1/yx4=
=g88z
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list