[Ir-l] Who's reading your e-mail?

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sat Jul 1 11:25:24 BST 2006


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/5132512.stm

Who's reading your e-mail?

BBC News Online, Friday, 30 June 2006


New plans to scan e-mails for illegal images of child abuse may give the 
appearance that children are being safeguarded but they may not be as 
effective as they first seem, argues Technology commentator Bill Thompson. 

Every time you send an e-mail it passes through a series of computers on its 
way to the intended destination.

Most of them are owned and managed by internet service providers, although if 
you use webmail from Yahoo, Google or Microsoft then it may take a different 
route.

But whoever provides your e-mail, the chances are they are having a look at 
every message you send or receive.

At the moment, their reasons are mostly benign, since they are looking for 
spam, viruses and other nasty stuff that we wouldn't want anyway.

Google mail users have got used to the fact that their e-mails are being read 
by a machine looking for context-sensitive ads to put on the same page, and 
most of us have encountered a company that reads all incoming e-mail looking 
for rude or inappropriate words, even if it sometimes appears absurd.

I used to edit an arts e-mail newsletter, and one issue was rejected by 
several recipients because it had an article on the Ars Electronica prize, 
but even with its flaws this helpful scanning is something that has obvious 
benefits.

And my internet service provider (ISP) helpfully lets me choose whether to 
have them look for spam or let it all through for me to deal with.

But if a plan being put forward by five US-based net companies goes ahead, the 
same approach could be used to look for e-mailed images of child abuse.

And the consequences for all net users could be more serious than just losing 
the odd legitimate message to the spam filters.


Digital fingerprints

AOL, Yahoo, Microsoft, EarthLink and United Online have joined with the US 
National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) to create what 
they call a "Technology Coalition" to look for new ways to safeguard 
children.

Their first initiative is a plan to create a database of the images of child 
abuse they find, and process each to create a "digital fingerprint".

They will then look at e-mail attachments and images traded over peer-to-peer 
networks, swapped on messaging services, or posted on websites to try to spot 
illegal images. 

 However, they haven't yet said what will happen if they find one.

I rather hope they won't simply call the police, since with millions of images 
of all types being sent over the net every day, the chances of some false 
positives, when an entirely innocent drawing of a tree happens to generate 
the same code as an image of abuse, must be quite high.

But the lack of detail is typical of this sort of proposal.

The real goal, as so often with big initiatives from large companies around 
areas of public concern, is designed to show that "something is being done" 
and to tell government - in this case the US Attorney General Alberto 
Gonzales - that the situation is under control and no new laws or regulations 
are needed.

The scheme may actually work, especially since recent research from Binghamton 
University, New York, indicates that every digital camera has a different 
"signature" that can be used to identify which pictures it took. Looking for 
photos taken with known abusers' cameras might pay dividends.

However, the initial funding for the new coalition is only $1m, or roughly 
four cents for each of AOL's 25 million customers; so the suspicion has to 
remain that this is an attempt to get friendly headlines rather than really 
make a difference.

Yet it may be enough to deter the sort of government interference in their 
business that ISPs in the UK seem to be about to experience, because while 
the Senate likes to talk about how it will regulate the industry, they rarely 
get round to passing any actual laws.


Internet morality

In the UK, things tend to take a different course.

Just last week, the British Board of Film Censorship expressed an interest in 
taking web content under its wing.

Vernon Coaker, a parliamentary under-secretary in the Home Office, told MPs 
that the government expected that "by the end of 2007, all ISPs offering 
broadband internet connectivity to the UK general public [will] put in place 
technical measures that prevent their customers accessing websites containing 
illegal images of child abuse identified by the IWF (Internet Watch 
Foundation)".

The clear implication is that if they don't do it voluntarily then the law 
will be changed to force them to do so. 

The list of websites to which he referred is drawn up by the self-proclaimed 
guardians of Internet morality, the IWF.

The body, which has no statutory authority and no real legal powers, provides 
a hotline for people to report images of child abuse and works with the 
police to get sites hosting such abhorrent content removed.

Not content with this role, it also provides ISPs with a list of sites and web 
pages it has not managed to remove, but which it considers unacceptable or 
illegal under current law.

The ISPs then stop their customers from viewing the sites concerned, although 
generally they don't actually tell you that the material concerned is banned 
because it is considered illegal, they just return a "page not found" error.

Both schemes, one for tracking images as they are exchanged and the other for 
stopping web users from accessing pages that contain banned material, offer 
the illusion of effectiveness while doing nothing to deal with the real 
problem of adult paedophiles using the network to help them abuse children.

It is clear that most of the trade in these appalling images happens on 
restricted servers, and most of the files are carefully encrypted or 
obfuscated before they are sent over the public network.

The real danger with media-friendly announcements of new internet coalitions 
or self-congratulatory annual reports on the number of abusive images seized 
by the authorities is that it encourages a belief that the situation is 
somehow under control, when it so clearly is not.

The tension between our freedom to use the network and the need to safeguard 
children is a driving issue for the Internet's development, and we need to 
think far more deeply about it than we have managed to do so far.

There is no simple answer, and if we settle for one then we will neither 
protect children nor safeguard our liberties.


-- 

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul's book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/book.html

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 189 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman-new.greennet.org.uk/pipermail/ir-l/attachments/20060701/fea8ce39/attachment.pgp


More information about the Ir-l mailing list