[Ir-l] ID cards doomed, say officials

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun Jul 9 17:37:01 BST 2006


http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspaper/0,,176-2262437,00.html

ID cards doomed, say officials

David Leppard
The Sunday Times, July 9th 2006


TONY BLAIR’S flagship identity cards scheme is set to fail and may not be 
introduced for a generation, according to leaked Whitehall e-mails from the 
senior officials responsible for the multi-billion-pound project.

The problems are so serious that ministers have been forced to draw up plans 
for a scaled-down “face-saving” version to meet their pledge of phasing in 
the cards from 2008.

However, civil servants say there is no evidence that even this compromise is 
“remotely feasible” and accuse ministers of “ignoring reality” by pressing 
ahead.

One official warns of a “botched operation” that could put back the 
introduction of ID cards for a generation. He added: “I conclude that we are 
setting ourselves up to fail.” Another admits he is planning Home Office 
strategy around the possibility that the scheme could be “canned completely”.

In one e-mail the prime minister is personally blamed for the fiasco with his 
proposal for a scaled-down or “early variant” version. “It was a Mr Blair 
apparently who wanted the ‘early variant’ card. Not my idea,” writes a top 
Home Office civil servant.

The e-mails expose another crisis for John Reid, the home secretary, who has 
already labelled his department as “not fit for purpose” following the recent 
foreign prisoners scandal.

The correspondence has been leaked by a senior official close to the Treasury. 
He acknowledges that the documents will infuriate ministers because they 
contradict the government’s public statements on ID cards.

Blair has repeatedly trumpeted the scheme as a centrepiece of the government’s 
efforts to combat terrorism, illegal immigration and crime. Ministers have 
rounded on critics who say the government has underestimated the cost and 
complexity of the technology.

Last year ministers rubbished claims by the London School of Economics that 
the scheme was too unwieldy and would cost as much as £19 billion, compared 
with the government’s estimate of £6 billion.

The government proposes that all Britain’s 50m adults will eventually carry 
the cards, which will include biometric data such as digitally encoded 
fingerprints or iris scans that could be checked against a huge database. The 
cards are to be introduced voluntarily from 2008 but, if re-elected, Labour 
proposes to make them compulsory for everyone over 16.

The e-mail correspondence last month was between Peter Smith, acting 
commercial director at the Identity and Passport Service, the Home Office 
agency set up to bring in the cards, and David Foord, the ID card project 
director at the Office of Government Commerce, which is responsible for 
vetting the project to ensure that the Treasury gets value for taxpayers’ 
money.

They reveal that the government is “rethinking” the entire scheme with an 
alternative “face-saving” compromise, which Smith blames on Blair. This 
“early variant” plan appears to involve collecting and storing biometric data 
on a temporary ID register but makes no mention of actually using it on 
cards.

However, officials doubt that this will work. Foord writes: “Just because 
ministers say do something does not mean we ignore reality — which is what 
seems to have happened on ID cards until [the contracts were due] to be 
issued and then reality could not be ignored any longer.”

He adds: “Even if everything went perfectly (which it will not) it is very 
debatable (given performance of government IT projects) whether whatever [the 
register] turns out to be (and that is a worry in itself) can be procured, 
delivered, tested and rolled out in just over two years and whether the 
resources exist within government and industry to run two overlapping 
procurements.

“What benchmark in the Home Office do we have that suggests that this is even 
remotely feasible? I conclude that we are setting ourselves up to fail.”
He reveals that the contracts for the ID card scheme are under threat because 
of “the amount of rethinking going on about identity management”. He also 
says they are “[un]affordable”; “lack clear benefits from which to 
demonstrate a return on investment”; and suffer from a “very serious shortage 
of appropriately qualified staff”.

Foord says: “I do not have a problem with ministers wanting a face-saving 
solution but we need to be clear with     . . . senior officials, special 
advisers and ministers just what this implies.” He then warns of a “botched 
introduction” of the scheme, adding: “If it is subject to a media feeding 
frenzy, which it might well be close to a general election, [it] could put 
back the introduction of ID cards for a generation and won’t do much for IPS 
credibility nor for the government’s election chances.”

Acknowledging these concerns, Smith says his IPS agency is planning around the 
possibility that the entire protect will fail. In a June 8 e-mail he writes: 
“We are designing the strategy so that [other contracts such as a contact 
centre for passport queries] are all sensible and viable contracts in their 
own right EVEN IF the ID card gets canned completely.”

In public, ministers have so far given no hint of any private fears about the 
viability of the scheme. But senior officials admit privately that the Home 
Office has abandoned its timetable for introducing cards.

Foord writes: “This has all the inauspicious signs of a project continuing to 
be driven by an arbitrary end date rather than reality. The early variant 
idea introduces huge risk on many levels.”

The problems in designing a workable system have meant a delay until March 
2007 in putting out contracts to tender to private companies to build and 
manage the scheme. They had been due this summer.

Another official involved in the project said: “Nobody expects this programme 
to work. It is basically on hold while ministers rethink their options. It’s 
impossible to imagine the full scheme being brought in before 2026.”

The disclosures will be seized on by critics who say it is too expensive, 
unworkable and a breach of privacy. The Tories plan to scrap the cards and 
use the money to build prisons.

Simon Davies, a member of the LSE team that said costs could rise to £19 
billion, said the rethink was “a vindication of all the concerns we have 
expressed about the costs and viability” of the scheme.

Last night the Home Office said it remained committed to an ID card scheme but 
had always maintained its introduction would be an “incremental” process. The 
cards are expected to cost about £93, which each citizen must pay when 
getting a new passport from 2010.

-- 

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul's book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/book.html

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 189 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman-new.greennet.org.uk/pipermail/ir-l/attachments/20060709/c0c37c64/attachment.pgp


More information about the Ir-l mailing list