[Ir-l] Laptop wars: The £50 computer under attack from a Silicon Valley giant

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sat Jun 9 20:23:34 BST 2007


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://news.independent.co.uk/sci_tech/article2618226.ece

Laptop wars: The £50 computer under attack from a Silicon Valley giant

It could transform life for billions of children, but one man's charitable 
dream of a £50 computer is under attack from a Silicon Valley giant.

By Simon Usborne
The Independent, 6 June 2007


In 2005, when Nicholas Negroponte of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology 
announced his vision, experts queued up to say it couldn't be done, and that 
the professor's plan was little more than a well-intentioned dream. Yet 
Negroponte was not proposing a manned mission to Mars, or a new theory of 
nuclear fusion - just a plan to make affordable laptops for the children of 
the developing world.

Early on, the omens were not good; when Negroponte employed Kofi Annan, no 
less, to unveil a prototype at a world summit in Tunisia, then the UN 
secretary general, managed to break the wind-up handle designed to power the 
computer in homes or schools without electricity. As a red-faced Negroponte 
hurriedly moved proceedings on, some observers, including the computer-chip 
giant Intel, dismissed the laptop as a "gadget".

But now, with support from big corporations and component makers, Negroponte's 
vision has become reality. The initiative, dubbed OLPC (One Laptop Per Child) 
has produced a laptop hailed by its makers as " revolutionary". It costs just 
$176 (£88), and is made available to governments who will order them in 
batches of 250,000 at a time.

But, just as orders are due to be placed, Intel has changed its tune as it 
jostles for position, with others who once doubted Negroponte's dream, in a 
market that could be worth billions.

The idea for a cheap, durable laptop for children in the developing world came 
to Negroponte eight years ago in Cambodia. The professor and his family had 
set up a school in a remote village and given each of its pupils a laptop. 
According to Negroponte, the village, which at the time had no running water 
or electricity, was transformed. Attendance at the school went up by 50 per 
cent, and the first English word the children spoke was " Google".

Seeing the potential for computers to link isolated or impoverished 
communities to the wider world, and to get more kids into class, Negroponte 
began thinking big and OLPC was born. Its mission statement is: "To provide 
children around the world with new opportunities to explore." The challenge: 
to build a cheap, child-friendly laptop that could be shipped by the million 
and survive the trip to school in sandstorms or monsoon rains.

With financing from Google and other big names, Negroponte and a team of 
engineers and programmers spent two years developing the XO. It might look 
like a sleek version of a My First Computer, but beneath the cute exterior it 
packs a hi-tech punch. By combining low-cost yet high-performance components 
with ground-breaking power-saving features, OLPC has created " a revolution 
in computing".

That's how computer expert Wayan Vota describes the XO. Vota is the director 
of Geekcorps, a US organisation that helps developing countries embrace 
technology, and editor of the independent OLPCnews.com. He says: "It's a 
whole revisualisation of the concept of a laptop and how a computer can 
work."

As the laptop took shape, Negroponte embarked on a glad-handing tour of the 
developing world to market his machine, and his dream. The Kofi Annan " 
wind-up" incident soon forgotten (and the troublesome crank handle dispensed 
with), Negroponte signed pilot contracts with a series of education ministers 
and world leaders, including Libya's Muammar Gaddafi and Nigeria's President 
Obasanjo, who was so effusive about the "enchanting" OLPC project that 
Negroponte vowed to turn the XO green and white - the colours of the Nigerian 
flag.

With interest across the developing world, and even in countries such as 
Australia and the USA, it is no surprise that the laptop establishment 
(working very much for profit) is playing catch-up. Vota says it's a simple 
equation: "There are around one billion people in the developed world, and 
that's almost a saturated market. There are more than four billion people in 
the developing world. Which market do you want a share of?"

In China alone, there are 200 million children. Worldwide, Negroponte 
estimates, there are more than a billion children who could get laptops. " 
Companies look at those numbers and say, 'If we're not there, we're toast,'."

One of those companies is Intel, which had earlier scorned OLPC. Now things 
have changed - and, last month, the race to bring computers to the developing 
world turned nasty. Appearing on the American CBS network's current affairs 
show 60 Minutes, Negroponte said Intel "should be ashamed of itself", 
claiming that the chipmaker has tried to drive OLPC out of business and "hurt 
the mission enormously". How? By " aggressively" marketing a rival laptop in 
countries OLPC is set to sign up.

With its colourful casing and chunky handle, Intel's Classmate laptop seems to 
have much in common with the XO. But, also on CBS, Intel's chairman Craig 
Barrett dismissed Negroponte's charges as "crazy", adding: " We're not trying 
to drive him out of business; we're trying to bring capability to young 
people and there are a lot of opportunities for us to work together."

Negroponte revealed a marketing document he said Intel had distributed to the 
government of Nigeria. An extract, emailed to The Independent by OLPC's 
Walter Bender, reads: "Although the OLPC organisation is making a strong 
attempt to address the computing needs of Nigerian schools, its approach has 
six major shortcomings." The perceived flaws the document lists include "less 
than fully functional hardware", "lack of multimedia digital content" and "no 
plans to develop connectivity" . Bender describes these claims as 
"fabrication".

Confronted with the document on 60 Minutes, Barrett admitted that it was 
genuine and described it as an attempt by "someone at Intel" to compare the 
Classmate with the XO. "That's the way our business works," he added. But 
Negroponte claims the real reason behind Intel's strategy is petty corporate 
rivalry. One of the components that make the XO so inexpensive is a low-end 
processor made by AMD, the world's second-largest chipmaker and Intel's 
biggest rival. Negroponte told CBS: "Intel and AMD fight viciously and we're 
just sort of caught in the middle."

Vota describes Negroponte's outrage at Intel's approach as "the pot calling 
the kettle black". He says: "From the beginning, Negroponte focused on price 
and in his original mission statement he said he would welcome a competitor 
who could build a laptop cheaper, so I think it's pretty cheeky for him now 
to bemoan competition. With a projected market of one billion, are you 
expecting companies to play nice?"

It is unclear whether the emergence of competition has affected Negroponte's 
project, but recent developments suggest OLPC is being forced to scale down 
its plans. Earlier this year, Negroponte had predicted that production of the 
XO would top a million a month by the end of the year. But as a deadline for 
huge orders passed last Thursday without comment from OLPC, that figure has 
been revised to three million in the first year from September.

The lower-than-expected uptake has affected the XO's price, which was famously 
set at $100 but is now $176. However, Bender is confident that with 
sufficient orders, it will reach the $100 target, and could dip as low as $50 
as the technology is refined.

If OLPC is in trouble, help could arrive from consumers in the developed 
world. The OLPC mission may be humanitarian, but Negroponte and team have 
hinted that a version of the XO could appear in computer stores alongside 
expensive machines from the likes of Dell and Apple.

Bender claims OLPC's mission would not be compromised by this: "Some of the 
profit would be used to subsidise the cost of laptops for children." 
Negroponte has suggested that laptops would be sold in pairs - one for the 
consumer and one for someone in the developing world.

Even if OLPC sticks to its mission, Quanta Computer, the world's largest 
laptop manufacturer and maker of the XO, says it is developing a consumer 
laptop that could sell for $200 (£100) as early as next year. Gartner, the 
research firm, forecast two years ago that global laptop sales in 2007 would 
exceed 70 million. The firm recently revised that figure to 102 million and 
expects sales to rise by almost 20 per cent a year for the next four years.

And Vota says the technology developed for the XO will have as great an impact 
on high-end laptops as on low-cost alternatives. "This machine will radically 
change the whole laptop industry," he says.

Vota singles out the XO's maximum 24-hour battery life as one of the machine's 
best features. Unlike standard computer chips, the XO's processor turns 
itself off when not busy and can even shut down in the pause between typing 
words. Along with other power-saving features, it means the XO runs on as 
little as two watts, compared to the 20-40 watts of standard laptops and the 
100 watts-plus guzzled by a PC. "You'll be looking to a point where you can 
measure battery life in days," Vota says. "I would love to have that."

Whoever wins the race to satisfy our appetite for ever-cheaper and more 
advanced computers, it's the children of the developing world - those at the 
heart of Negroponte's mission - who will benefit most. The Luciana de Abreu 
School in the city of Porto Alegre in Brazil took delivery of 100 OLPC 
laptops in March as one of the project's trials. Before then, the school's 
550 students had little or no access to computers.

Iron Otana, the school's principal, says his pupils "adore" their new 
computers. "The children who use the laptops are much more motivated and 
stimulated. Attendance is much higher and they have become much more 
spontaneous," he says. "And those who haven't got one have been frantically 
figuring out how to get involved."

What makes the XO special

* Screen

Supplied by the Taiwanese firm Chi Mei, the 7.5-inch LCD uses one-seventh the 
power of standard screens and is one-third the price. It has a " sunlight 
readable" mode.

* Memory

The XO does away with a fragile hard disk in favour of a gigabyte of Flash 
storage, supplied by Samsung. Without moving parts, it is much more robust 
and reliable.

* Processor

Instead of constantly checking that all systems are go (even if nothing is 
happening), the XO's processor, made by AMD, turns itself off in idle 
periods, even between keystrokes.

* Casing

The casing is totally sealed when the laptop lid is closed, keeping out dust 
and water. It is 2mm thick (the standard is 1.3mm) and has rounded edges for 
added strength.

* Keyboard

Made from a single piece of sealed rubber, the keyboard is spillage- and 
rain-proof. A separate touchpad allows drawing and writing using a stylus or 
finger.

* Antennae

XOs use inbuilt wireless routers, supplied by the US firm Marvell, to form a 
mesh network. Only one machine needs a net connection; the others can 
piggy-back.

* Hinge

The screen can be rotated using its "transformer hinge" and the laptop closed 
to turn it into an e-book or games console. The display automatically flips 
to stay upright.

* Battery

With a 24-hour life in e-book mode, the XO's battery is charged via a " power 
brick" hooked up to a hand crank, car battery or solar panel - or even a 
cow-powered generator.

* Operating system

XO laptops are shipped with Sugar, a Linux-based interface custom-designed by 
the open-source software firm Red Hat. It allows children to see what 
activities the community is involved in


- -- 


"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')

Paul's book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/

Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.2 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFGav47pKOsa4QY6KURArbrAKCNgVYgqtQMkwLvbLhrkg2C5+vzBwCfTn8l
M7+oy3Al4A/BizBgNuHuh5A=
=2tw2
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----


More information about the Ir-l mailing list