[Ir-l] "Ransomware" -- grey area in law?
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun Mar 4 01:37:26 GMT 2007
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
http://technology.guardian.co.uk/weekly/story/0,,2023190,00.html
My PC is being held to ransom
Is it legal to lock people out of their own computers? Michael Pollitt
examines an online billing system that uses what could be considered
strongarm tactics
The Guardian, Thursday March 1st 2007
Ted Kenyon doesn't like being pursued for money by his computer. Retired and
living in the west country, he prefers using his PC to download MP3 files.
But whenever he turned it on recently, he was confronted by a large popup
window demanding payment. He closed it - only to see it instantly appear
again.
While advertising popups often plague net users, Kenyon's experience seemed
worryingly different. He saw that the window was from a company in Leeds
called Micro Bill Systems asking for £19.99, with the explanation that his
computer had been used to sign up to a website. After suffering the annoying
problem for some time, he emailed the Guardian for help.
Kenyon is always careful about protecting his PC. He was using fully updated
Windows XP Professional along with Norton Internet Security 2007, Spybot
Search & Destroy, AVG anti-spyware and Sophos anti-rootkit. He'd seen popups
before but this one stayed longer each day, hindering his computer use. "The
popup starts about 30 seconds after the PC is turned on and lasts for about
four minutes before the window can be closed. While the bill is displayed,
you cannot minimise it or open any other window in front of it, as it always
hogs the top window slot," he says.
Locked out
The Guardian soon found Katie Singleton, who runs her own web business, with
the same problem. One day she noticed a window on her PC - headed "MBS direct
billing" - demanding money.
"They were charging £19.99 for something called Sexpassport, which I had never
heard of and certainly never used. The popup started appearing intermittently
and could be clicked out of, but after a few weeks it started to appear more
frequently and would then lock me out of the system for up to two minutes,"
says Singleton. Kenyon and Singleton insist that they never signed up to a
website; both fought to regain control of their PCs.
After several unsuccessful attempts, Singleton bought some anti-spyware
software from Pareto Logic to do the job. Also struggling, Kenyon eventually
followed advice in a user forum and deleted the unwanted files manually.
Other people have been reporting the same thing - an unexpected bill that
increasingly disrupts PC use. The website involved is sexxxpassport, operated
by an Australian company using billing software provided by Micro Bill
Systems. The site offers a three-day free trial for anonymous access,
following which charges are made - there's a long list of terms and
conditions too.
Simon Briskman, a partner in the technology law group at Field Fisher
Waterhouse LLP, worries about the effects such problems have on consumer
confidence in the internet. "I think it's very clever," he says. "We haven't
seen something like this before and it looks like somebody has thought very
carefully through the issues of producing the terms. But all the same, nearly
all the victims are going to be consumers and consumer contracts have to be
fair - I don't think these terms are fair."
According to the terms, unless the bill is paid, the software will disrupt
your computer use for longer each day. There are up to four daily periods of
10 minutes when the window demanding payment is locked and cannot be
minimised. Restarting the computer offers no relief and may result in even
more disruption.
Briskman also reckons that, if the billing software is installed without
consent, it may breach the Computer Misuse Act 1990. But leaving aside the
embarrassing suggestion of telling the police you've been involuntarily
signed-up to a pornographic website, Briskman offers another solution: "I'm
extremely sympathetic with people suffering from this because it's difficult
to do anything other than pay these people off. More effectively, complain to
the OFT [Office of Fair Trading]."
As the director of malware research at computer security company Prevx,
Jacques Erasmus has spent days investigating the software involved. Erasmus
started hacking in his early teens, a self-taught skill that led to a
challenging IT career. Prevx provides solutions to protect PCs above and
beyond the ordinary security software that Kenyon used.
Erasmus signed up a test PC to see how the billing software works. After user
permission was given, two mutually protected files were installed in a system
directory and the registry modified. The software is then hard for
non-technical users to remove. "Once a user's free period has expired, the
application installed on the machine will start popping up relentless
messages and fullscreen popups that cannot be closed instructing the user to
pay their bill," says Erasmus. "These activities are both ruthless and on the
borderline of ransomware applications."
So how did Kenyon and Singleton get it? Erasmus has searched hard for an
"exploit" where the billing software might be dropped silently onto PCs
visiting malicious websites or distributed through other methods such as a
botnet. "There is no evidence of it being installed by a dropper of any
kind," says Erasmus. "The best way to remove this is to use Prevx1, which
will scan your machine to check if you are infected and cure the infection if
it is infected." Prevx1 also prevents the software installing in the first
place.
Ashley Bateup, the managing director of Micro Bill Systems in Leeds, rebuts
any suggestions of silent installations. He says his company has developed a
new internet billing system which is used by its only UK customer,
sexxxpassport, and claims 100,000 users.
Software removal
"The most common situation giving rise to these complaints is where a member
of the household downloads the software without actually reading the terms
and conditions or warning, and once they realise they have contracted for a
service they refuse to admit their use to the computer owner, who then
assumes their PC has been infected in some way," says Bateup. "Our customer
service team's experience is that people seem to move into denial with their
spouses or partners when pornography use is at question."
If another member of the household is responsible, then the browser history
may show this; the company claims to have comprehensive access logs too.
Bateup says that one woman who rang to complain was shocked to discover her
husband had visited the porn site many times despite his denials. However,
Kenyon and Singleton categorically deny that they or anyone else in their
households visited the website. So what about software removal for cases like
theirs?
"If the software was easily removable few people would pay for the service
they had already consumed," says Bateup. "The software operates a reminder
procedure to encourage people to settle their accounts. If the consumer
settles their account and cancels their subscription, the software can be
uninstalled simply."
As to the terms and conditions being lawful and fair, Bateup adds that he
contacted the OFT - as well as Trading Standards - last October to inform
them of the company's business intentions. Asked about this, the OFT said it
does not normally comment on individual cases - which does not resolve
whether it thinks MBS's tactics are indeed fair and lawful. The mystery
remains, though. Someone must be mistaken. But who?
- --
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government,
nor are we for this party nor against the other but we are
for justice and mercy and truth and peace and true freedom,
that these may be exalted in our nation, and that goodness,
righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity with
God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
Paul's book, "Energy Beyond Oil", is out now!
For details see http://www.fraw.org.uk/ebo/
Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey/index.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.2 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQFF6iLfpKOsa4QY6KURAsXgAJ41rF6eJOREzv7fEKocpvYHji++oACfbOqv
QysD/gfQajBsNSeEcN8KRiY=
=1trg
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list