[Ir-l] FBI targets Net phoning

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Aug 13 23:06:25 BST 2008


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://news.com.com/2100-1028-5056424.html

FBI targets Net phoning

By Declan McCullagh
Staff Writer, CNET News.com
July 29, 2003, 4:00 AM PT

Internet telephone calls are fast becoming a national security threat that 
must be countered with new police wiretap rules, according to an FBI proposal 
presented quietly to regulators this month. 

 Representatives of the FBI's Electronic Surveillance Technology Section in 
Chantilly, Va., have met at least twice in the past three weeks with senior 
officials of the Federal Communications Commission to lobby for proposed new 
Internet eavesdropping rules. The FBI-drafted plan seeks to force broadband 
providers to provide more efficient, standardized surveillance facilities and 
could substantially change the way that cable modem and DSL (digital 
subscriber line) companies operate.

The new rules are necessary, because terrorists could otherwise frustrate 
legitimate wiretaps by placing phone calls over the Internet, warns a summary 
of a July 10 meeting with the FCC that the FBI prepared. "Broadband networks 
may ultimately replace narrowband networks," the summary says. "This trend 
offers increasing opportunities for terrorists, spies and criminals to evade 
lawful electronic surveillance." 

In the last year, Internet telephony (also called voice over Internet 
Protocol, or VoIP) has grown increasingly popular among consumers and 
businesses with high-speed connections. Flat-rate plans cost between $20 and 
$40 a month for unlimited local and long-distance calls. One of the smaller 
VoIP providers, Vonage, recently said it has about 34,000 customers and 
expects to have 1 million by late 2004.

According to the proposal that the FCC is considering, any company offering 
cable modem or DSL service to residences or businesses would be required to 
comply with a thicket of federal regulations that would establish a central 
hub for police surveillance of their customers. The proposal has alarmed 
civil libertarians who fear that it might jeopardize privacy and warn that 
the existence of such hubs could facilitate broad surveillance of other 
Internet communications such as e-mail, Web browsing and instant messaging.

Under existing federal wiretapping laws, the FBI already has the ability to 
seek a court order to conduct surveillance of any broadband user though its 
DCS1000 system, previously called Carnivore. But the bureau worries that 
unless Internet providers offer surveillance hubs based on common standards, 
lawbreakers can evade or, at the very least, complicate surveillance by using 
VOIP providers such as Vonage, Time Warner Cable, Net2Phone, 8X8, deltathree 
and DigitalVoice.

Digital wiretapping
The origins of this debate date back nine years, to when the FBI persuaded 
Congress to enact a controversial law called the Communications Assistance 
for Law Enforcement Act, or CALEA. Louis Freeh, FBI director at the time, 
testified in 1994 that emerging technologies such as call forwarding, call 
waiting and cellular phones had frustrated surveillance efforts.

Congress responded to the FBI's concern by requiring that telecommunications 
services rewire their networks to provide police with guaranteed access for 
wiretaps. Legislators also granted the FCC substantial leeway in defining 
what types of companies must comply. So far, the FCC has interpreted CALEA's 
wiretap-ready requirements to cover only traditional analog and wireless 
telephone service. 

In the last year, Internet telephony (also called voice over Internet 
Protocol, or VoIP) has grown increasingly popular among consumers and 
businesses with high-speed connections. Flat-rate plans cost between $20 and 
$40 a month for unlimited local and long-distance calls. One of the smaller 
VoIP providers, Vonage, recently said it has about 34,000 customers and 
expects to have 1 million by late 2004.

According to the proposal that the FCC is considering, any company offering 
cable modem or DSL service to residences or businesses would be required to 
comply with a thicket of federal regulations that would establish a central 
hub for police surveillance of their customers. The proposal has alarmed 
civil libertarians who fear that it might jeopardize privacy and warn that 
the existence of such hubs could facilitate broad surveillance of other 
Internet communications such as e-mail, Web browsing and instant messaging.

Under existing federal wiretapping laws, the FBI already has the ability to 
seek a court order to conduct surveillance of any broadband user though its 
DCS1000 system, previously called Carnivore. But the bureau worries that 
unless Internet providers offer surveillance hubs based on common standards, 
lawbreakers can evade or, at the very least, complicate surveillance by using 
VOIP providers such as Vonage, Time Warner Cable, Net2Phone, 8X8, deltathree 
and DigitalVoice.

Digital wiretapping
The origins of this debate date back nine years, to when the FBI persuaded 
Congress to enact a controversial law called the Communications Assistance 
for Law Enforcement Act, or CALEA. Louis Freeh, FBI director at the time, 
testified in 1994 that emerging technologies such as call forwarding, call 
waiting and cellular phones had frustrated surveillance efforts.

Congress responded to the FBI's concern by requiring that telecommunications 
services rewire their networks to provide police with guaranteed access for 
wiretaps. Legislators also granted the FCC substantial leeway in defining 
what types of companies must comply. So far, the FCC has interpreted CALEA's 
wiretap-ready requirements to cover only traditional analog and wireless 
telephone service. 

Barry Steinhardt, director of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)'s 
technology and liberty program, said the FCC could not legally extend CALEA 
to cover the Internet without additional action by Congress. "CALEA does not 
apply to 'information services,' which was the then term of art for the 
Internet," Steinhardt said. "Voice over IP is just that, a voice service over 
the Net. CALEA should not, and so far has not, applied to VOIP."

The FBI proposal is before the FCC, which has jurisdiction over DSL and cable 
modem providers and is expected to rule on the matter this fall. "It's 
pending before the commission, and we plan to address the question," an FCC 
spokesman said.

How to follow the law
It's unclear what a broadband provider must do if the FCC extends CALEA's 
reach, and the regulations survive a possible court challenge from privacy 
groups such as the ACLU or network providers who do not wish to comply.

Martin King, an attorney in the FBI's general counsel's office who attended 
the July 10 meeting, said the bureau would not elaborate on its request to 
the FCC. "On this particular matter, we are going to decline to comment," 
King said.

Colleen Boothby, a former FCC official who is now a partner at Levine, 
Blaszak, Block & Boothby, said the implications of the FBI's proposal would 
vary based on how a broadband provider's system is configured.

"It's going to depend on what facilities they have," Boothby said. "When 
designing systems and configuring software and hardware, they have to 
preserve the government's ability to eavesdrop. Does it mean physical 
electrical closets? Does it mean an extra server in a secure room? It means 
as many varied things as there are variations in network design."

Lawrence Plumb, a spokesman for Verizon Communications, said: "How does a 
service provider architect its broadband network and equipment to be 
CALEA-compliant? The exact answer to 'how' isn't known."

Companies would be reimbursed for their costs to comply with CALEA. When 
enacting the law, Congress earmarked $500 million to reimburse telephone and 
cellular providers for their expenses.

Police encountered similar problems when wiretaps on customers using data 
services such as mMode from AT&T Wireless and PCS Vision from Sprint PCS 
could intercept only voice communications. Earlier this year, VeriSign, Cisco 
and other members of an industry consortium announced a set of products that 
would permit police to eavesdrop on wireless data transmissions.

FBI meetings
The FBI appears to have first presented its proposal to the FCC last year. But 
in the July 10 and July 22 meetings, the bureau extended it to say that if 
broadband providers cannot isolate specific VOIP calls to and from individual 
users, they must give police access to the "full pipe"--which, by including 
the complete simultaneous communications of hundreds or thousands of 
customers, could raise substantial privacy concerns.

A summary of the meeting prepared by the FBI said the FCC could "require 
carriers to make the full pipe available and leave law enforcement to perform 
the required minimization. This approach is already used when ISPs provide 
non-CALEA technical assistance for lawfully ordered electronic surveillance."

The July 22 meeting at the FCC included John Pignataro, deputy superintendent 
of Maryland's state police force, two attorneys for the FBI's Electronic 
Surveillance Technology Section, and Leslie Szwajkowski, the head of that 
section's policy unit. They met with a senior advisor to FCC Commissioner 
Kevin Martin. During the July 11 meeting, FBI representatives met with 10 
officials from the FCC's Wireline Competition Bureau, its Media Bureau and 
the Office of Strategic Planning and Policy Analysis.

 The meetings, according to summaries prepared by the FBI, stressed that 
"broadband telephony involves packet-mode communications, which are more 
difficult to intercept than circuit-mode communications. The need for 
CALEA-standardized broadband intercept capabilities is especially urgent in 
light of today's heightened threats to homeland security and the ongoing 
tendency of criminals to use the most clandestine modes of communication."

In an interview, however, a Vonage representative said the VOIP provider had 
never received a request from a police agency to do a live voice 
interception, though the company has been served with subpoenas for stored 
customer information. "We have been subpoenaed, I believe, several times for 
call records and call data," Vonage's Brooke Schulz said. "We've responded to 
those subpoenas very, very quickly. Because of the way our service is set up, 
we have all this data on hand, and it's very easy to do."

Schulz said if Vonage were to receive a proper request to perform a live voice 
interception, it would be trivial to comply with, because all the company's 
VOIP calls flow through central servers. "We are able to copy the data stream 
and send it in tandem to another location," Schulz said. "You can essentially 
send it to the law enforcement agency you need to send it to, as long as they 
have the proper equipment and the proper interconnect."

Because Vonage's network already is accessible to police armed with a legal 
wiretap order, Schulz said she was mystified by the FBI's proposal to the 
FCC. "We really don't know where it's coming from," she said.

Why the proposal?
The FBI declined to elaborate on the justification for its proposal. An FBI 
agent who attended the pair of meetings and spoke on condition of anonymity 
said that "if it's pending, we don't want to be talking about it."

One explanation for the proposal is that not all VOIP networks flow through a 
service that can be readily wiretapped. For instance, Pulver.com's Free World 
Dialup connects about 38,000 subscribers in 150 countries who typically use 
Cisco ATA-186 and Cisco 7960 VoIP phones to talk to each other directly.

The best place to intercept those types of VoIP calls would likely be at the 
user's broadband provider.

A second explanation for the FBI's proposal is that, by requiring broadband 
providers to comply with CALEA, police would have an easier time wiretapping 
other types of Internet communications such as e-mail, Web browsing and 
instant-messaging services. 

David Sobel, general counsel of the Electronic Privacy Information Center, 
said: "It seems that current practices are providing the government with full 
access" to VoIP calls.

Baker, the CALEA attorney at Steptoe and Johnson, said: "It would be very 
difficult to set up a network so that you could only intercept voice packets 
and not the others. The likely result here is that you'll have modifications 
that are useful for law enforcement not just for voice packets but for other 
packets as well."

Yet another reason for the FBI's proposal, Baker said, is that the bureau is 
very interested in details about a VoIP phone call, not just the conversation 
itself. Those details, such as who was on the call, are called "punch list 
items" according to CALEA. "It's not about content but about getting 
call-identifying information or traffic analysis," Baker said. "Who was on 
the line, how long they stayed on, who did they put on hold--things like 
that. The FBI has always wanted to get that information served up very 
neatly, promptly and conveniently."

Some Internet providers have welcomed the FBI as an ally on this issue, which 
has arisen as part of an FCC proceeding over broadband deregulation and how 
to classify Internet access. By lobbying the FCC, the bureau is essentially 
seeking to expand the scope of CALEA, which says telecommunications services 
must ensure that their equipment and facilities are capable of "expeditiously 
isolating and enabling the government, pursuant to a court order or other 
lawful authorization," to intercept all communications from a specific 
customer.

FCC Chairman Michael Powell has indicated that he would like to move more 
Internet access services into the category of "information services," which 
have fewer regulations and likely would not be subject to CALEA. That alarms 
DSL providers such as EarthLink, which fear that deregulation means that 
former Baby Bells such as Verizon and BellSouth will raise their rates for 
access to the copper wire that runs to telephone subscribers' homes.

"The FBI is really an ally of sorts," said David Baker, EarthLink's vice 
president for law and public policy. "They're saying to the FCC, look, you 
guys are thinking of classifying everything as an information service, but 
you have to be aware of the implications."

EarthLink's Baker said "we're already seeing anticompetitive activities on the 
part of the phone companies even under the current rules. You do away with 
those rules, and you're ensuring that customers will have no choice but DSL 
provided by the phone company." Unless the FBI's proposal succeeds, he said, 
"everything that travels over a DSL connection, be it voice or e-mail, would 
be out of the reach of law enforcement. That would be a tremendous loophole 
and a breach of national security." 





==========

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey.html
public key - http://www.fraw.org.uk/keylist.html



-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.2-rc1-SuSE (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQFIo1rhtEaNwM05jx0RAtw5AJ9UEIAd9VJxkRKGEW/yc9ACCq30HQCfWXiQ
WwfR5+pozL1i7atxDuUrcfY=
=s5r0
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----




More information about the Ir-l mailing list