[Ir-l] [IR-L]: IoD voices its concern over e-mail interception plan
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Jun 14 19:47:19 BST 2000
from http://www.iod.co.uk/rip.html
IoD voices its concern over e-mail interception plan
The Institute of Directors has added its voice to the growing concern within
the business community over the Government's proposed e-mail interception
bill. The Regulation of Investigatory Powers Bill (the "RIP Bill") should be
amended during its passage through the House of Lords next week, urged the
IoD's head of e-business policy, Prof. Jim Norton.
The IoD is concerned that, despite the obviously worthy anti-crime aims, the
definitions used in the Bill could be interpreted far too broadly. Prof.
Norton said:
"I fully support the aims of this Bill in bringing UK interception powers
within the scope of the European Convention on Human Rights. However I have
real worries about much of the detail. Loose definitions and drafting might
allow future administrations scope to re-interpret and extend the use of
these powers far beyond the Government's stated goals.
"They could, for example, be used by a wide range of officials, and not just
the more obvious police and security services, to require access to
encryption keys. Is it really the intention to provide Inland Revenue or VAT
inspectors or DTI Company investigators with these powers? Even the car park
attendant at the Home Office seems to have them under current drafting!"
Prof. Norton went on to say:
"Confusion also exists between law enforcement access to the content of
'messages' which requires at least some form of authorising warrant; and
access to information about these messages Ð so called 'communications data'
which under present drafting does not require a warrant. In the e-commerce
world such 'communications data' is much more meaningful than simply the
source and destination telephone numbers and the duration of the call that
was the equivalent for telephone calls. In principle every click of the
mouse, every page visited, or button clicked could be regarded as such data
and collected with impunity."
Worried that the Government is scoring an 'own goal' for the UK e-commerce
industry with the RIP Bill, Prof. Norton urges that Internet policy should
not be treated as a national issue and the DTI should act to secure
international agreement.
Prof. Norton said:
"Individuals in multi-national businesses may find themselves placed in an
invidious position through the operation of this Bill. If an employee is
served with an order to release highly sensitive encryption keys, they are
likely also to be served with a 'gagging order' preventing them from
informing others in the company (such as senior management or security
staff) that the integrity of their encryption systems has been potentially
compromised. The employee is protected in this country against the
consequences of that action. This protection does not extend outside the UK
to other jurisdictions such as that of the parent company. They may made
need to be very careful where they travel!"
Prof. Norton commented that:
"The UK stance on this Bill is worrying many companies Ð especially
multi-nationals who contrast the proposed UK legislation against far more
business friendly proposals in Ireland, France and Germany and even the
USA."
As he endorsed suggested amendments to the Bill, already put forward by the
British Chambers of Commerce, Prof. Norton nevertheless reiterated the IoD's
determination to work with the Government to achieve the common goal of
making the UK the best location in the world for e-commerce.
Ends
9.6.00
Contact Points:
Jim Norton, head of e-business policy, tel: 020 7451 3111
Steve Reardon, Director of Communications, tel: 020 7451 3263
Richard Taylor, Press Officer, tel: 020 7451 3264 e-mail: press at iod.co.uk
-------------------
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other
but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound." (Edward
Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
THE FREE RANGE ACTIVISM NETWORK
Facilitators -
Paul Mobbs - mobbsey at gn.ac.org, tel./fax 01295 261864
Tim Shaw - timshaw at gn.apc.org, tel./fax 01558 685353
Website - http://www.gn.apc.org/pmhp/rangers/
--------------------
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list