[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: IR in Zimbabwe - email surveillance
Jim Holland
privacy at mango.zw
Thu Jun 15 17:44:18 BST 2000
Hi
On 15 Jun 2000, Robin Gaskell wrote:
> Thanks Karen for alerting us to this. The question of Net security
> is not an English one. Even Zimbabwe feels the necessity to join the
> big boys in politically filtering the Net!!!
In the case of Zimbabwe there is no mention of what is going to happen in
accordance with the legislation (which was apparently signed by the
President a couple of days ago). It could be used for political filtering
- in fact it could be used for almost any purpose whatsoever.
Tucked away inside the Zimbabwe Postal and Telecommunications Bill, 1999,
which is mainly concerned with privatisation and the regulatory
environment that will apply are the following two clauses:
Section 98 (2) provides that "if, in the opinion of the President,
it is necessary in the interests of national security or the maintenance
of law and order" he may give a direction that requires service providers
to intercept or monitor specific communications or suspend services to
named persons.
Section 103 gives unfettered powers to the President to give both
general and specific directions to service providers "if they appear to
be requisite or expedient in the interests of national security or
relations with the government of a country or territory outside
Zimbabwe". Section 103 also makes it an offence for a service provider
to disclose anything done in accordance with such a Presidential
direction if so ordered.
There is no provision for any court to have to authorise any directions
given by the President under Section 103, and no recourse is provided to
any court of appeal against such directions.
Penalties for any breach of the Act range from the equivalent of approximately
US$5000 to not less than US$25000 and/or two years imprisonment.
> Who still needs to be convinced that this is a global conspiracy, on
> the part of 'intelligence' organisations, to "harmonise" regulations for
> phone-tapping and Net-snooping all around the world?
> How else would these almost identically worded bills be coming into
> parliaments around the globe at the same time?
I don't think the Zimbabwe legislation is a very good case to support the
above argument. Basically there are just two key sections that relate to
interception and monitoring in the 116 sections of the Bill. I think they
are a model for any authoritarian regime -- just allow the President to
require you to do whatever he wants you to do.
Here we are totally preoccupied with the forthcoming general election that
must rank as one of the least fair ever seen. It is characterised by
state-sponsored violence, intimidation, unfair bureaucratic rule changes,
denial of access to the state media, destruction of property and vehicles,
theft of materials, theft of identity documents required for voting,
burning of houses and offices, looting, raping, and endless beatings,
kidnappings, torture and mutilations by the ruling party's private militia
of so-called war veterans. It is really just indescribable.
Recently armed officials purporting to be policemen (but presumably from
the ruling ZANU PF party) came through the MANGO premises looking for
Sekai Holland, an opposition candidate, and accused her of being involved
in the murder of one of the white farmers. They said her car was seen at
his farm on the day of the murder. Fortunately she was able to prove that
she had sold it many weeks previously and they left disappointed.
Later she was taken at gunpoint from a UNDP-sponsored workshop on Women in
Politics that she was running in her rural constituency and held "for her
own protection" for a day and a half without food, washing or sleeping
facilities at the local police station. She was eventually released
without charge, but many of her supporters were beaten in the meantime, their
houses destroyed, her campaign funds stolen and her vehicle burnt.
Let us get through this election and then we can go back to the issue of
this draconian piece of legislation.
Regards
Jim Holland
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list