[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Demon have closed one of my sites
Tony Gosling
tony at gaia.org
Wed Jun 21 15:39:27 BST 2000
I have been corresponding with Demon internet over the closure of this
entire site due to one 'offending' paragraph.
http://www.tlio.demon.co.uk/
I enclose the offending paragraph from the admittedly wayward VOMIT
(Victims Of Masonic Ill Treatment) newsletter. VOMIT's publisher informs
me it would have almost certainly have been the Lord Chancellor Irving or
one of his legal agents who ordered the site to be closed.
VOMIT were closed down a long time ago and now only send their weekly
newsletter out by fax or email - there is no archive.
I thought it might help to put a current living example of net censorship
on the list and I would be happy to receive any further advice anyone might
have - probably off-list.
My problem is the presumption that the material is illegal and the fact
that I have to sign a disclaimer before the site will go back up. Which
surely leaves me in a weak positio should I attempt to get the material
republished legally.
The law can tie an otherwise sane individual in knots!
My email is
tony at gaia.org
OFFENDING PARAGRAPH:
--------------------
DOCTOR IAN OLIVER - GRAMPIANS CHIEF CONSTABLE
Never before has a Chief Constable been so thoroughly bad- mouthed by the
establishment and by the Press. Creepy Dewar could not attack him on moral
grounds on account of the gymnastics of Cardinal Irvine (the seducer of
Dewar's wife), Geoffrey Robinson (adulterer and personal friend of
President Blair) and Cock Robin Cook (adulterer). One is bound to ask how
the good doctor was promoted in the first place. Doctor Oliver made only
one mistake. He proscribed Masonry. This is why the police authority and
Dewar are putting a spin on the facts. He is allegedly weird and mercenary.
He must quit his post immediately because the world will come to an end if
he doesn't. Doctor Oliver was prepared to go immediately provided he was
compensated for loss of earnings. It will cost ten times as much to go
through the procedures for sacking him. Freemasonry is petty, evil and
vindictive. It wants to be able to say that Doctor Oliver was sacked
because he was useless. He will be sacked because he proscribed Masonry -
for no other reason. The latest news is that Dr Oliver has silenced Dewar
and the police authority and made them keep to the
>Date: Fri, 16 Jun 2000 09:53:32 +0100
>To: Tony Gosling <tony at gaia.org>
>Cc: legalnotice at demon.net
>From: Mark Gracey <legalnotice at demon.net>
>Subject: Re: DO NOT IGNORE
>
>Thank you for your email.
>
>In message <3.0.1.16.20000615123907.13df3568 at gaia.org>, Tony Gosling
><tony at gaia.org> writes
>>Dear Mr Gracey,
>>
>>Please explain how data protection legislation affects this.
>>My solicitor friends say it does not.
>
>Our external solicitors seems to believe differently on this. They say
>that there is an issue because to disclose the original complaint would
>be disclosing personal information about the complainant such as their
>name and email address.
>
>Clearly we can send you a copy of the text of the complaint with all
>personal data removed, but I'm not sure that this helps you at all - if
>it does then let me know and I'll tell you how your site was reported to
>us.
>
>>
>>Anyway I think we both know who requested this be removed, please don't
>>play games.
>>
>>It could reflect badly on you should we end up in court.
>
>I can assure you that we are not playing games.
>
>We have often been asked to supply a copy of the original complaint or
>indeed identify the complainant, with complaints like this (for obvious
>reasons), which is why we have sought proper legal advice on this.
>
>We are not happy that we have had to remove access to your site, but the
>current state of UK law regarding defamation is such that if it is
>reported as containing defamatory comment (and it doesn't matter who by
>- i.e. it doesn't have to be the person who is being defamed that
>complains :( then it must be assessed. We referred your site to our
>solicitors because of the report we received and in their opinion there
>were parts of it which could bear defamatory meaning.
>
>If we failed to take any action then we could face legal action.
>>
>>PLEASE put me in touch with the 'offended' solicitors immediately.
>
>If you mean put you in touch with the complainant then we are happy to
>pass on (on your behalf) any correspondence you wish, from yourselves or
>from your solicitors.
>
>...Or are you referring to our solicitors who advised us on the
>material?
>>
>>I hope we can avoid getting into costly legal battle.
>>
>Indeed.
>
>Mark
>--
>Mark Gracey - Legal Liaison Manager - Thus Legal Services
>legalnotice at demon.net - tel: 0845 272 0666 - fax: 0870 052 2740
>Demon @ Thus plc - http://www.demon.net - http://www.let-it-be-thus.com
>Dalmore House, 310 St Vincent Street, Glasgow, G2 5BB CoRegNo: SC 192666
>
>Attachment Converted: "C:\GNITOOLS\EUDORA\ATTACH\signatu1.asc"
>
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list