[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: Demon have closed one of my sites

Chris Bailey chrisbailey at gn.apc.org
Thu Jun 22 11:30:48 BST 2000


At 15:42 21/06/2000 +0100, Tony Gosling wrote:
>I have been corresponding with Demon internet over the closure of this
>entire site due to one 'offending' paragraph.

Hi Tony,

This whole issue of closing down websites was the subject of a sharp 
argument between myself and Richard Clayton from Demon at the Internet 
Service Providers Association legal forum last week.

Basically the policy Demon now has, and which was being advocated by the 
ISPA for all ISPs was to immediately remove any "defamatory" material when 
it was challenged by someone and to only put it back after obtaining 
indemnities. This was supposedly due to the Lawrence Godfrey settlement.

In fact, as the lawyers finally admitted at the forum, the Lawrence Godfrey 
case has actually changed nothing. Demon and other ISPAs are simply using 
it as an excuse to avoid any controversial material that might carry any 
risk to them at all. A suggestion was being put forward of having a list of 
known "trouble makers", who presumably would be blacklisted by the ISPs.

As recent articles in Internet Magazine calling for a user Bill of Rights 
have pointed out, this policy leaves the user with virtually no rights at 
all. GreenNet is looking carefully at this whole question at the moment and 
examining the legal implications of giving definite guarantees to users 
about defending controversial material. As you probably know, GreenNet has 
successfully defended such material in the past when other ISPs have refused.

Chris Bailey
  






More information about the Ir-l mailing list