[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: Demon have closed one of my sites

William Palfreman william at palfreman.com
Thu Jun 22 15:20:41 BST 2000


Frankly, the obvious thing to do is to host your website either in Ireland
or the US.  We have known for a long time now that the UK is a
threatening environment for the internet.  Walk.

-- 
W. Palfreman.

On Thu, 22 Jun 2000, Chris Bailey wrote:

> At 15:42 21/06/2000 +0100, Tony Gosling wrote:
> >I have been corresponding with Demon internet over the closure of this
> >entire site due to one 'offending' paragraph.
> 
> Hi Tony,
.> 
> This whole issue of closing down websites was the subject of a sharp 
> argument between myself and Richard Clayton from Demon at the Internet 
> Service Providers Association legal forum last week.
> 
> Basically the policy Demon now has, and which was being advocated by the 
> ISPA for all ISPs was to immediately remove any "defamatory" material when 
> it was challenged by someone and to only put it back after obtaining 
> indemnities. This was supposedly due to the Lawrence Godfrey settlement.
> 
> In fact, as the lawyers finally admitted at the forum, the Lawrence Godfrey 
> case has actually changed nothing. Demon and other ISPAs are simply using 
> it as an excuse to avoid any controversial material that might carry any 
> risk to them at all. A suggestion was being put forward of having a list of 
> known "trouble makers", who presumably would be blacklisted by the ISPs.
> 
> As recent articles in Internet Magazine calling for a user Bill of Rights 
> have pointed out, this policy leaves the user with virtually no rights at 
> all. GreenNet is looking carefully at this whole question at the moment and 
> examining the legal implications of giving definite guarantees to users 
> about defending controversial material. As you probably know, GreenNet has 
> successfully defended such material in the past when other ISPs have refused.
> 
> Chris Bailey
>   
> 
> 
> 







More information about the Ir-l mailing list