[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: supervising interceptions
William Palfreman
william at palfreman.com
Sat May 13 20:55:13 BST 2000
Hang on. Why should *any* emails be intercepted? Ok, so I am in favor of
real crimes being illegal, like murder and so forth, but I don't see why I
should the government should be given special legal privilages that don't
apply to me, like being able to open other people's mail/email. If someone
commits a crime then THEN look through their mail, after there is at least
some solid evidence (like a body). And it should be a non-privilige based
process too - where the government has no more rights at all than me, and
if they can get a wiretap then so can I. No one should be able to get
court permission to go through someones mail until at aleast after the
someone has actually been charged with a real crime. And by real crime I
don't mean failure to to prove that you have paid all the tax you should
have or failure to hand over your public key to nice Mr. Straw. The
individual should be the complete equal of those who currently think they
are the government.
So John, what I am really saying to you I that there just shouldn't be any
interception, full stop. If they have found a body under your bed then
maybe they could seize your computer, but to have pre-emptive inteception
is wrong - it impies that the government is superior to the individual,
and and that instead of innocent till proven guilty we are all guilty and
have to prove our innocence per email.
--
W. Palfreman.
On Mon, 8 May 2000, John Valentine wrote:
> If interceptions are sometimes permissable, then who to do it. UK has no
> separation between legislature and executive, but does have nominal
> separation between judiciary and the other two. Should we be propsing some
> kind of judicial committee? Or perhaps the film censorship system could be
> looked at as a model? As Don implied, it is outrageous that service
> providers should have to hard-wire to M15.
>
> Anyway, doesn't M15 have only an internal (to UK) role? How will it
> distinguish between internal and international email traffic? If I was a
> non-UK citizen I might have something to say about my correspondance being
> read by the internal spy service.
>
> John Valentine
>
> ('Evil will triumph because good men do nothing' Edmund Burke)
>
>
> __________________________________________________
> Do You Yahoo!?
> Talk to your friends online with Yahoo! Messenger.
> http://im.yahoo.com
>
>
>
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list