[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: supervising interceptions
John Valentine
jv_sw17 at yahoo.co.uk
Tue May 16 21:06:51 BST 2000
William Palfreman said that he didn't see why email interception in
justified for any reason. It's interesting to note that (re conventional
policing) pre-emptive arrest has not been legitimate for very long (since
after WWII I think). Before that, arrest was only allowed to secure
appearance at trial, ie after investigation was complete, and evidence of
pre-charge questionning could get a prosecution thrown out. Now of course,
pre-emptive arrest is commonplace, routine - it is unthinkable that the
police would bring a charge without having questionned the defendant in the
police station, but that is what used to happen. The parallels with RIP are
obvious - rather than wait for a crime to be committed, and then investigate
it, the police want the legal right to pre-empt crime. Which is hard to
argue against, except to point out the unregulated chaos, dodgy confessions,
gross miscarriages of justice that rocked the crim justice system to its
core in the late 80s and 90s are the inevitable result of unregulated
pre-emptive investigation. The Police and Criminal Evidence Act (1986) was
landmark in its attempt to control pre-emptive arrest, and at least set down
some basic rights and procedures. Perhaps we will have to wait for a similar
series of miscarriages resulting from RIP before a PACE-equivalent act is
brought in to impose some control. Meanwhile, I still think that a fluency
in the Human Rights Act (October 2000) might be useful, and a hope that
juries (and even maguistrates) will throw these cases out.
John Valentine
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Talk to your friends online with Yahoo! Messenger.
http://im.yahoo.com
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list