[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Zimbabwe Postal and Telecommunications Bill, 1999
MANGO System Administrator
privacy at mango.zw
Mon May 15 08:26:05 BST 2000
The above Bill was rushed through Zimbabwe's Parliament and passed on
Wednesday 8 March with no sign of any substantive parliamentary let alone
public debate. Its primary purpose is to establish a regulatory authority
called the Postal and Telecommunications Authority (PTA), which will
regulate and license postal and telecommunication service providers. It
also provides for the very popular privatisation of the Posts and
Telecommunications Corporation which currently has a monopoly in many
areas.
It seems that the Bill was being pushed through by private sector
interests whose primary concern was in seeing the privatisation process
being implemented as quickly as possible. Unfortunately they did not
include Internet Service Providers in any of their recent consultations,
so there has been no feedback, let alone input, from ISPs in the
preparation of this Bill. ISPs have had a liaison committee that meets
with Government from time to time, but this committee was not given any
notice of the fact that the Bill was coming before Parliament, and were
not even informed about a seminar on the Bill that was held between
Government and the above private sector interests at the end of last
month.
MANGO, a non-profit e-mail service, heard of the contents of the Bill
only a few days before it was passed by Parliament. We immediately got hold
of a copy and started lobbying ISPs and other interested parties due to the
following disturbing elements in the Bill:
The Board of the PTA will not be an independent board, as it is
appointed by the President with no public input whatsoever. While
the President should endeavour to secure members who are representative
of groups or sectors of the community having an interest in postal
services and telecommunications there is no mechanism to ensure that
these are not partisan appointees (apart from disqualifying those who
are senior members of political parties). [ Section 6 (2)]
The lack of independence of the Board is ensured by giving the Minister
the power to give it policy directions [Section 25] and to direct it to
"reverse, suspend or rescind its decisions or actions" after consultation
with the President [Section 26].
Transitional arrangements for current service providers are very vague,
with no guarantee that an organisation such as MANGO would be allowed
to continue to operate during the period from the law coming into effect
until their application for a licence had been determined.
Telecommunications licences can be refused if the PTA "considers that it
would not be in the public interest to issue a licence to the applicant".
Unlike rejections for other reasons, no opportunity is given for the
applicant to make any representations in such a case.
ISPs that are not Zimbabwean-owned (at least one and possibly two of
the three major ISPs are in this category) would not be entitled to a
licence unless they agreed to a majority Zimbabwean shareholding.
Section 98 (2) provides that "if, in the opinion of the President,
it is necessary in the interests of national security or the maintenance
of law and order" he may give a direction that requires service providers
to intercept or monitor specific communications or suspend services to
named persons.
Section 103 gives unfettered powers to the President to give both
general and specific directions to service providers "if they appear to
be requisite or expedient in the interests of national security or
relations with the government of a country or territory outside
Zimbabwe". Section 103 also makes it an offence for a service provider
to disclose anything done in accordance with such a Presidential
direction if so ordered.
There is no provision for any court to have to authorise any directions
given by the President under Section 103, and no recourse is provided to
any court of appeal against such directions.
Penalties for any breach of the Act range from the equivalent of approximately
US$5000 to not less than US$25000 and/or two years imprisonment.
Those who have followed recent political developments in Zimbabwe will be
aware of the fact that a national referendum was recently held to endorse
a new constitution. The draft was rejected and we remain subject to the
old, many-times-amended Lancaster House constitution. This fortunately
contains some significant guarantees in Section 20 (Protection of freedom
of expression):
(1) Except with his own consent or by way of parental discipline,
no person shall be hindered in the enjoyment of his freedom
of expression, that is to say, freedom to hold opinions and
to receive and impart ideas and information without
interference, and freedom from interference with his
correspondence.
The Constitution goes on to qualify the above rights in "the interests of
defence, public safety, public order, the economic interests of the State,
public morality or public health" and various other cases. However such
qualification of these rights is subject to being "reasonably justifiable
in a democratic society" [Section 20 (2)]. I would not consider the
apparently unfettered powers given to the President in the Bill to fall
within that category.
I would also think that the lack of any appeal procedure against
directions from the President would violate Section 18 (9) of the
Constitution, which guarantees every person "a fair hearing within a
reasonable time by an independent and impartial court or other
adjudicating authority established by law in the determination of the
existence or extent of his civil rights or obligations." The appeals
procedure specified in Section 96 of the Bill does not seem to cover
appeals against directions by the President.
MANGO lodged a formal written protest to Parliament before the Bill was
finally passed, but to no effect. We are now liaising with ISPs and human
rights groups to continue to lobby for the amendment of the Act (which
will come into effect in the fairly near future, as it is simply awaiting
Presidential signature). Feedback about the experience of ISPs with
similar legislation in other African countries would be most welcome.
Regards
Jim Holland
System Administrator
MANGO - Zimbabwe's non-profit e-mail service
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list