[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: Introduction: Jim Holland from MANGO in Zimbabwe

William Palfreman william at palfreman.com
Tue May 16 00:22:07 BST 2000


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

I don't really understand these two emails.  Given what is going on
in Zimbabwe at the moment obviously you and your users need to
routinely use PGP encoding for almost all you mail.  If you want to
encryptyour destinations too, have a look at www.fortify.com, I think
theycan do that for you.  Else check out some links from PGP things
on the internet.  

I have made some comments below.

- - ----- Original Message ----- 
From: MANGO System Administrator <privacy at mango.zw>
To: Multiple recipients of list <ir-l at gn.apc.org>
Sent: Monday, May 15, 2000 9:44 AM
Subject: [IR-L]: Introduction: Jim Holland from MANGO in Zimbabwe


> Hi to everyone on this list.
> 
> I am the system administrator of MANGO, a non-profit e-mail service
> operating in Zimbabwe.  We are a partner organisation in the APC
> (Association for Progressive Communications). 
>
> 
> My background:
> 
> Australian national, living in Zimbabwe since 1982
> 
> Mechanical Engineer by training, worked for the Zimbabwe
> Government as a water engineer (village water supplies/drought
> relief programmes) from 1982 to 1995
> 
> System Administrator of MANGO from 1995 to present
> 
> While coming from a technical background, I was a political
> activist while living in Australia, with key areas of interest
> being support for Aboriginal Land (and other) Rights and for the
> liberation struggle in Southern Africa (particularly for what
> was then called ZANU, now ZANU-PF).

Are you still linked to them?

> We in Zimbabwe are about to experience at first hand the
> ramifications of a piece of legislation (the Postal and
> Telecommunications Bill, 1999) that gives the President unfettered
> powers to require ISPs to intercept, monitor and block Internet
> communications, and, as if that was not sufficient, to do or not do
> anything else that he may determine, and be forced to keep quiet
> about it if so instructed.  I will post a full summary in my next
> message.  
 
> It is also understood that the Government is planning to install
> its own monitoring system that will be hard-wired to the country's
> Internet pipes  and possibly to individual ISPs.  Lack of funds
> appears to be the hindrance to this at the moment.  

Use PGP.  Route packets with encrypted heads via decrypting servers
in other countries - generally Canada or the Caribbean.  That way
neither the content, origin or destination of the packets will be
visible.

 
> We are particularly concerned by the precedent set by the passage
> of the UK's RIP Bill because this has already been used by the
> Government here to justify its PT Bill.  And the Government media
> really crowed at the news that Britain was setting up the MI5
> Internet surveillance centre!  

I don't think there is really any comparison.  Our government is on a
silly mission to disinvent the wheel re PGP, yours is organising
pogroms and stripping people of their nationality on the basis of
their skin colour.  If you really are a (white) Australian then data
privacy is the least of your worries.
 
> The direct relevance is that MANGO and other ISPs may be able to
> challenge the PT Bill on Constitutional grounds (see next message),
> but the Zimbabwe Constitution specifically states that any
> restrictions on freedom of expression or provision for interference
> with correspondence should be in accordance with what is
> "reasonably justifiable in a democratic society". Unfortunately
> Britain has just widened the goal posts.  

Your constitution and courts are already being utterly ignored by
your government.  Talking in these terms only generate false hope.

> 
> Speaking now in my personal capacity: I assume that outsiders are
> aware of the fact that in this period leading up to general
> elections,   

What general elections?  No date has been set, although Parliament
has been dissolved, possibly for good.

> Zimbabwe is
> now in a state where the rule of law has broken down. 
> State-sponsored criminals and thugs are intimidating the opposition
> to ZANU-PF by beating, burning, torturing, gang-raping and
> murdering individuals and family members, as well as destroying
> their homes and property, where people are suspected of supporting
> the opposition or even failing to give sufficiently whole-hearted
> support to ZANU-PF.  

There is also the issue of the pogroms.

>  The police appear to have
> been instructed to ignore complaints of violence carried out by
> ZANU-PF supporters.  And court orders are simply ignored by the
> state.  In this situation you can imagine the concern of
> individuals that their e-mail may be intercepted.  One prominent
> opposition activist making extensive use of e-mail for campaigning
> purposes was badly beaten, and had his house trashed and used as a
> public toilet.   

You could start using PGP, but if it were me I would be packing my
bags.
 
> I have in front of me an article about the PT Bill in the
> Government-run Sunday News.  Its concluding argument: "What have
> individuals got to fear with their mail being intercepted if they
> are not involved in any subversive activities?".  I think they
> should be very afraid indeed.  

Yes, and not just of the PT Bill.  Mugabe is establishing a Nazi
state.  Your PT Bill is just a symptom of a wider problem.  The
Nazi's introduced any number of similar repressive laws in the 1930s.
 The bigger picture, though, is if you are not out within the next
6-24 months you are going to be murdered for your race.
 
> MANGO itself is non-political and has decided to postpone public
> action against the new legislation until after the election (if we
> have one, that is), on the grounds that such action would be
> interpreted as being part of the opposition's electoral campaign. 
> However we are working with other ISPs locally, who are similarly
> concerned, to be able to mount a legal challenge as soon as
> appropriate.   
> 
> Regards
> 
> Jim Holland
> MANGO System Administrator

You have no grounds for optimism whatsoever.  Things won't be better
after a general election, they will be worse.  No doubt plenty of
German Jews held out high hopes for the 1938 elections (98% Nazi
victory), no doubt many people in Germany at the time thought it was
time for a change and said so, and said how much they disapproved of
the anti-Jewish rhetoric coming from the German government at the
time.  But such things don't make a damn bit of difference in the
end.  There is nothing special about Zimbabwe, there is no special
Zimbabwe spirit that will ensure this works out all right in the end.
 Even if you have taken Zimbabwean citizenship and (guess here) you
have familial connections to Zimbabwe now, and you and you family
never suffer from any discrimination, it is inevitable that sooner or
later you will all be killed.  If you are worried about racism in
Australia you could consider going to Zambia or Mozambique instead. 
I here they are both ok countries now, although you will know better
than me.

Regards and good luck,
Bill.


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGPfreeware 6.5.1 for non-commercial use <http://www.pgp.com>
Comment: Both keys at www.impac.freeserve.co.uk/wfpkeys.asc

iQA/AwUBOSCGc4gQrLDCeDc9EQJhcwCg6zrfL46xeMr7fCfLe4VgaId+U94AoOmS
vm04+KUkk2Z13b56TWNgfGBF
=ObdU
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----







More information about the Ir-l mailing list