[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Some useful reviews.
Philip Stokes
philip.stokes at btinternet.com
Sun May 28 12:08:58 BST 2000
There are a couple of very germane reviews in London Review of Books of 1st
June 2000 [Vol 22, No 11]. If you get the chance, they're worth reading in
themselves ... and of course following through to the books.
Bernard Porter's article "How the Judges Stood in the Way of Socialism" [pp
27-8] is a review of The Struggle for Civil Liberties: Political Freedom and
the Rule of Law in Britain 1914-1945, by Ewing & Gearty [Oxford: OUP, 2000].
It is a sharp review of a book which is very critical of the received notion
that civil liberties here are protected by the common law. This struck a
chord with me, since although I'm not in the law myself, my early background
was permeated by it, and I can recall hearing, in my teens, several homilies
on the virtues of common law, which left me slightly unconvinced; not least
because of the near religiosity of the delivery. The detailed accounts of
cases and their outcomes picked up in the review suggest that I might not
have been wrong, certainly in those areas where government is keen to use
the law to enforce political ends.
Brian Rotman's article, "Pretty Good Privacy" [pp 15-16] reviews three
books, of which Privacy on the Line: The Politics of Wiretapping and
Encryption, by Diffie & Landau [Cambridge Mass: MIT, 1999] is highly
relevant in these RIP days. Rotman draws attention to the radical changes in
notions of privacy brought about by current developments in IT and comms; it
reads as an important spelling-out of issues that I think just about
everyone will have sensed.
All well worth attention.
Dr Philip Stokes
philip.stokes at btinternet.com
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list