[Ir-l] Wired: Governor Calls for 'Cyber Court'

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Fri Oct 19 23:05:18 BST 2001


http://www.wired.com/news/conflict/0,2100,47676,00.html

Governor Calls for 'Cyber Court' 

By Declan McCullagh 
WIRED, 2:00 a.m. Oct. 18, 2001 PDT


WASHINGTON -- Malicious hackers, look out.

A government anti-terrorism commission will recommend that Congress create a 
shadowy court to oversee investigations of suspected computer intruders.

Gov. James Gilmore (R-Virginia), the commission's chairman, said Wednesday 
that federal judges have been far too sluggish in approving search warrants 
and eavesdropping of online miscreants. 

Instead, Gilmore told the House Science committee, the commission will 
recommend that a "cyber court" be created with extraordinary powers to 
authorize electronic surveillance and secret searches of suspected hackers' 
homes and offices.

Police investigations are currently hamstrung by a lack of "effective 
procedures and understanding by many in the judiciary concerning the nature 
and urgency of cyber security," Gilmore said.

Wednesday's hearing comes after members of the House and Senate voted 
overwhelmingly last week to grant police more surveillance powers, including 
the ability to conduct Internet wiretaps without court orders in some 
circumstances. President Bush asked Congress for the legislation after the 
Sept. 11 attacks.

The Gilmore commission's recommendations tend to carry weight in Washington: 
Bush already acted on the group's advice to create an Office of Homeland 
Security. Gilmore's current job as chairman of the Republican Party and his 
reputation of being tech-savvy -- AOL Time Warner's online operations are in 
Virginia -- add to his clout.

Rep. Vernon Ehlers (R-Michigan) suggested additional punitive measures. "I 
think hackers should also be considered terrorists and sentences that hackers 
get should be in line with terrorist sentences," Ehlers said.

Some drafts of the anti-terrorism legislation that has been wending its way 
through Congress have included life prison sentences for convicted hackers, 
though the latest version reserves that penalty only for exceptional cases.

Gilmore offered few details on the proposal to create a hacker-court. A House 
press release says only that the commission will recommend the "establishment 
of a special 'Cyber Court' patterned after the court established in the 
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act."

The so-called FISA court is notorious among civil libertarians for being a 
secret, seven-judge court that meets behind closed doors to approve 
surveillance requests in "national security" cases. Proceedings are sealed 
and judges do not require "probable cause" -- a legal standard required in 
ordinary investigations -- before ordering eavesdropping or surreptitious 
entries to plant listening devices.

Congress created the FISA court in 1978 to oversee foreign intelligence 
investigations that were too sensitive to take through the normal process. 
The FISA judges review the Justice Department's requests and, with the 
exception of one or two cases, have always approved them.

Because the FISA court meets in secret, and its orders are sealed, subjects 
are often unaware they're under surveillance.

Gilmore also called for an "unprecedented partnership between the public and 
private sectors" in sharing intelligence and real-time information. In a nod 
to privacy, he recommended that Congress create a not-for-profit entity to 
oversee the process.

Chairman Sherwood Boehlert (R-New York) seemed to agree, saying, "market 
forces have given most in private industry little incentive to invest in 
computer security even as their reliance on the Internet grows."

Gilmore went a step further, saying it was necessary to have "an entity to 
develop and implement" plans to improve network security.

Boehlert said the committee is beginning to draft legislation on this topic. 
He didn't offer any dates, but said he'd take into account the Gilmore 
commission's recommendations.

Ben Polen contributed to this report.




More information about the Ir-l mailing list