[Ir-l] Mercury News 17/10/2001: "A modest proposal for national IDs"

Caspar Bowden cb at fipr.org
Sat Oct 20 21:41:11 BST 2001


http://www0.mercurycenter.com/business/top/033152.htm 
A modest proposal for national IDs
BY SCOTT HERHOLD
stocks.comment(TM) 
You could hear the snickering recently when Oracle CEO Larry Ellison and
Sun chief Scott McNealy endorsed the idea of a national identity card.
Ever so slyly, the critics suggested these fine gentlemen were just
hawking their products -- Ellison with the servicing of a vast database,
and McNealy through the sale of new servers.

The cynics are altogether wrong. And it's time that someone said so.
These two valley CEOs are simply trying to serve their country. And
frankly, Silicon Valley could do with a lot more of their
entrepreneurial patriotism.

If McNealy and Ellison have erred, it's in thinking too small. National
ID cards are essential, yes. And more Oracle databases and Sun servers
are badly needed. But for the sake of the nation, we ought to be
thinking much bigger.

So I'd like to make a modest proposal for bolstering our national
security through Silicon Valley's unique offerings. I call it the ``Save
America and the Nasdaq from Terrorists Act'' (SANTA).

The act is premised on the idea that blanketing the nation with
electronic devices is the path to salvation. As long as we're going to
spend $100 billion in reviving the economy, technology shouldn't go
cheated.

Begin with the national identity card -- a high-tech identifier that
could control your access to driving, flying, even health insurance.
It's a good first step.

But SANTA would go further by providing every American with a Motorola
cell phone that he or she would have to carry at all times.

Equipped with special transmitters, these phones would serve several
vital purposes. They would inform the FBI of the location of every
person. They would make the job infinitely easier for search-and-rescue
crews looking for hikers or elderly drivers. And finally, if authorities
needed to talk to a suspected terrorist, they could just call him.

For children too young to carry a cell phone -- or for seniors who
suffer from dementia -- the act would mandate the implanting of a tiny
Intel chip just below the shoulder, a procedure that can be done quickly
and painlessly at any clinic. (To ensure completion, the arm bracelets
of babies leaving the hospital would bear the words ``Intel Inside.'')

To promote online security, the act would require every user to sign up
for Microsoft's Passport and Hotmail services, which would provide
secure transaction and e-mail -- with Microsoft keeping a record of
everyone's online wanderings. With a few keystrokes, law enforcement
could thus know just exactly who visited the Taliban's Web site -- and
whether their e-mail contained threatening words like ``Judge Jackson''
or ``divestiture.'' It would eliminate the messy, labor-intensive
process of seizing a computer and unraveling hard drives.

Finally, the act would require the installation of at least one video
camera in every room of every American house and business -- bolstered
by broadband connections from Covad or AT&T.

Combined with the cell phones, we will thus have a near-complete record
of every suspicious movement. Politicians know about a chicken in every
pot. This is a Webcam in every room.

And while the act would not mandate it, a congressional resolution would
encourage ``a thousand points of light'' in battling terrorism. It would
encourage Intuit, for example, to share the online TurboTax returns of
questionable filers with the FBI -- which has the same problems dealing
with the IRS bureaucracy that we all do.

Now I can already hear the carping from the civil libertarians and the
anti-Microsoft crowd. They'll say that this is an outrageous violation
of our freedoms, that the government has no right to know our every
movement and every thought. Most shabbily, they'll argue that the act is
a vehicle for promoting the financial self-interest of Silicon Valley.

But this is a national emergency, a time when all of us have to make
sacrifices. It's time for high-tech companies to give up petty rivalries
and join together to win multibillion-dollar government contracts. It's
time to see that the security of the community outweighs the yearnings
of the individual.

Yes, valley companies might sell a lot more gear, a lot more software.
But is good business while serving the nation in its time of crisis so
reprehensible? Isn't this better for the economy than bailing out the
airline or insurance industries? 

This isn't a matter of boosting stock prices. It isn't a matter of
padding next quarter's numbers. Silicon Valley just wants to help.




------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------
Scott Herhold's Stocks.comment appears every Monday and Thursday. Write
him at the San Jose Mercury News, 750 Ridder Park Drive, San Jose,
Calif. 95190; e-mail sherhold at sjmercury.com; phone (408) 920-5877. To
read the columns online, see www.siliconvalley.com/opinion/herhold/




More information about the Ir-l mailing list