[Ir-l] Unlocked - come in and help yourselves (MS security rant)

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Thu Sep 27 09:17:55 BST 2001


http://www.observer.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,556375,00.html
 
Unlocked - come in and help  yourselves 

The Networker, John Naughton, The Observer, Sunday September 23, 2001

Let us get one thing straight: the Nimda worm/ virus which caused 
intermittent havoc last week is not - as innumerable media reports have put 
it - an 'internet worm/virus'. It is a
Microsoft worm/virus.

Only computers running Microsoft Windows operating systems, browsers and 
email programs, or Web servers running Microsoft IIS software, are vulnerable 
to the vicious little beastie. Nimda attacks at least a dozen known 
vulnerabilities in Microsoft IIS and can also spread via open shares to other 
connected machines on a network. Computers that do not run Microsoft software 
are not, repeat not, vulnerable to this particular attack. 

Using Microsoft email software is like putting a large billboard outside your 
house saying 'Unlocked - come in and help yourself'. 

This is not just an issue of semantics. By failing to identify the 
vulnerabilities of Microsoft software, the media give an impression of online 
security that is grossly misleading. And this has several serious 
consequences.

First, it gives people the idea that all internet activity is intrinsically 
insecure - which reinforces their reluctance to buy things online. 

Second, it lets Microsoft off the hook. Instead of being pilloried (or 
prosecuted) for marketing insecure products, the company escapes public 
castigation because the internet is blamed for its corporate shortcomings. 

And third, journalistic misrepresentation of the real cause of Nimda-type 
vulnerabilities enables public authorities that are hooked on Microsoft 
products - such as our own dear e-envoy's office - to avoid critical scrutiny 
by overseers such as the National Audit Office. 

There is worse to come. On 25 October, Microsoft will launch its new XP 
operating system to a traumatised world. This is an astonishingly ambitious 
product - an attempt, as one of my techie colleagues put it, 'finally to do 
Windows properly'. 

It is also, however, a monster. If you were thinking of running it on your 
trusty two-year-old PC, for example, forget it. XP is, in the words of David 
Pogue of the New York Times, 'power-mad'. Microsoft's official minimum 
requirements are a 300-megahertz processor and 64 megabytes of memory. 'But 
that,' writes Pogue, 'is like saying that the minimum requirements for 
marriage are two adults and a blood test. Without at least 400 megahertz and 
128 megabytes of Ram, Windows XP exhibits all the spunk of tomato paste. 
Note, too, that if your computer is more than about 18 months old, you may 
have to update its BIOS (a core nugget of computer code) before installing 
XP, a procedure about as user-friendly as a wet cat.' 

The public policy implications are obvious. Schools, hospitals and other 
publicly funded institutions will come under relentless pressure from New 
Labour's Microsoft junkies to upgrade to XP so that they can reap its 
putative 'benefits'. But in order to comply they must junk most of their 
existing PCs, which are perfectly adequate for their purposes, and would be 
for years to come if they ran non-Microsoft software. 

These difficulties pale into insignificance, however, alongside XP's 
potential to facilitate 'denial of service' attacks on a hitherto 
unimaginable scale. This is because its design allows programs to have what 
is called 'raw socket-level' access to the net. In non-technical terms this 
means that if computers running XP are penetrated by malicious hackers, they 
can be used as zombies to generate denial of service attacks that are much 
harder to detect and block than previous DoS attacks have been. 

Security expert Steve Gibson, who has been highlighting the problem for 
months, says: 'For the first time ever, applications running under the Home 
Edition of Windows XP will be easily able, without modifying the operating 
system in any way, to generate the most damaging forms of internet attacks.' 

Welcome to the future, Microsoft-style. 


john.naughton at observer.co.uk 

www.briefhistory.com/footnotes 




More information about the Ir-l mailing list