[Ir-l] IWF civil liberties resignation
by way of Tony Gosling <tony at gaia.org>
roger. at anotherfinemess.co.uk
Tue Feb 19 22:54:37 GMT 2002
Watching the Internet watchers
net.wars
By Wendy M. Grossman, 15/02/2002 09:58:50 BST
http://www.theinquirer.net/15020203.htm
THE INTERNET WATCH Foundation announced rather invisibly this week a change
of policy: "We will now recommend to UK ISPs that they do not carry
newsgroups which IWF identifies as regularly hosting child pornography. We
will use statistics from our own monitoring to identify the groups that
fall into this category."
Board member Malcolm Hutty promptly resigned. He was the only civil
liberties activist they had; he is general director of the Campaign Against
Censorship of the Internet in Britain (Here). Also gone, earlier, over this
sort of issue are Demon Internet's Clive Feather, an ISP representative,
and deputy chief executive Ruth Dixon.
Here are some of the newsgroups he says will be removed if the IWF gets its
way: alt.binaries.pictures.gill-anderson;
alt.binaries.pictures.teen-idols.princewilliam;
alt.binaries.pictures.spice-girls; alt.binaries.pictures.kids;
alt.penthouse.sex.girls; alt.binaries.pictures.erotica.teen;
alt.activism.children.whatisa-pedophile.
This list raises the suspicion that what's operating here is a typically
computerish blunt-instrument approach the kind of thing that had
residents of Scunthorpe unable to register with the prudish AOL when it
first opened up in the UK.
The IWF started as a back-of-an-envelope idea scribbled by Pipex founder
Peter Dawe on the eve of a September 1996 meeting on Internet safety. The
meeting itself was a slightly acrimonious affair: it had been set off in
part by media pressure in the form of a tabloidly horrid Observer article
sledge-hammering two wholly innocent well-known Net figures as the "key
links in the international paedophile chain." In addition, police had
recently circulated a list of 133 newsgroups they wanted banned outright
Although the police present at the meeting insisted they had never intended
their list of 133 newsgroups circulated to ISPs as a guide to the location
of illegal material (essentially, child pornography) as a threat, the
undertone, as I wrote in the now-defunct Netizen at the time, was one of
"you do something about it, or we'll do something about it". The IWF,
adopted as government policy two weeks later, was that something.
It was supposed to be a hotline for reporting material of concern, with a
team following up those reports and advising ISPs to remove the material if
it in fact was illegal. It talked about ratings, and including illegally
duplicated copyrighted material in its remit, and even sell cleaned-up
Usenet feeds to ISPs that wanted them. It never got around to most of that,
though it has made noises occasionally which ensured that worried Net
activists kept an eye on it.
Over time, however, the IWF seemed to become mostly harmless. For one
thing, the climate has changed. While pedophiles are still the bogeymen of
the hour, the focus is much less on the Net as the source of the problem.
Most people have some familiarity with email and the Web now, and while
concerns about Internet safety continue, they are ebbing, as the dark
panics about schoolchildren exchanging pornography on floppy disks in
playgrounds did before them. For another, the growth of filtering software
and the Web have changed the equation somewhat.
Usenet is a minority interest now, albeit one I happen to share, and
cleaning up Usenet feeds matters less if the mainstream problem is access
to Web sites with built-in images and chatrooms that are hosted overseas.
As the Internet has become mainstream, the truth of what Netheads said all
along has become plain to more people: the real, heinous problem is child
abuse, which happens in the physical world. Whatever happens to a child in
the virtual world pales by comparison.
Maybe this is why the IWF suddenly feels the need to become more active
it was feeling neglected. What's disturbing is the secrecy the IWF
apparently intends to apply to its method for choosing what to ban.
Blocking software has long operated this way in constructing its filtering
databases, but at least you can reverse-engineer software and test it to
find out what it's doing, as Bennett Haselton has for five years now
(peacefire.org). The only way you can reverse-engineer a board is to get a
mole on it. The IWF's composition now seems to be almost wholly either
police (present or former, such as Jim Reynolds, a consultant on
pedophilia), specialists in child protection issues (Nigel Williams,
Childnet International (http://www.childnet-int.org), and John Carr, NCH
Action for Children), or representatives of the council of ISPs that fund
the organisation.
Roger Darlington, the IWF's chair, is the exception: he is head of research
for the National Communications Union.
What's worse, though, is that the IWF was set up precisely to avoid the
kind of policy it's now proposing to enact. The IWF is supposed to deal
with illegal material. It is not supposed to be in the business of
protecting children, turning the Internet into a children's playground, or
deciding that the Spice Girls are bad (however much we might be inclined to
agree with them). What its policy means is throwing out whole tracts of
legal material because some illegal material may be embedded in them.
In 1996, I wrote, "They came for child pornography at 3pm on September 23,
1996, and no one put up a hand in protest," though the line was cut in
production (See here). Well, they came for pictures of Gillian Anderson on
February 13, 2002. Anybody?
Previous Columns
Big Brothers
The Sound of Money
Battle of the titans
By any other name
Creative Accounting
Dumber people can run Windows
2001 in review
Care in the community
Remembrance of postings past
BT's Stupid Patent Tricks
Preserving our freedoms
It's beginning to look a lot like Christmas
Net is the mother of re-invention
Save the Cookie
Digital rights and the new era of world terrorism
Wendy M. Grossman, whose Web site is pelicancross ing.net, is author of
>From Anarchy to Power: the Net Comes of Age (NYU Press, 2001), net.wars
(NYU Press, 1998), and the Daily Telegraph A-Z Guide to the Internet
(Macmillan, 2001). She can be reached at this email address.
Copyright on all articles published in the INQUIRER is hers.
http://www.theinquirer.net/15020203.htm
The Inquirer
© 2002 Breakthrough
Publishing Ltd
All rights reserved.
Discuss this story on our Message Forum
Back to Front
http://www.theinquirer.net/15020203.htm
--
Get personalised email addresses at http://another.com
--
Tony Gosling
10-12 Picton Street
Bristol
BS6 5QA
England
+44 (0)117 944 6219
tony at gaia.org
http://www.bilderberg.org
http://www.public-interest.co.uk
"US foreign policy can be defined as follows: 'Kiss my arse or I'll kick
your head in.'" Harold Pinter --- see
http://www.guardian.co.uk/letters/story/0,3604,309521,00.html
US foreign policy is run by a private business club: The Council on Foreign
Relations --- http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/2807
ps. If you get the "S" and the "11" and superimpose them you get a dollar
sign. Coincidence of course!
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list