[Ir-l] IWF civil liberties resignation

Dave Bird dave at xemu.demon.co.uk
Wed Feb 27 20:58:21 GMT 2002


In article <3.0.5.32.20020219225437.0079c100 at mail.gaia.org>, by way of
Tony Gosling <tony at gaia.org> <roger.?@anotherfinemess.co.uk> writes
>Watching the Internet watchers 
>
>net.wars 
>By Wendy M. Grossman, 15/02/2002 09:58:50 BST
>http://www.theinquirer.net/15020203.htm

 Thanks, Wendy, excellent press article.
>
>THE INTERNET WATCH Foundation announced rather invisibly this week a change
>of policy: "We will now recommend to UK ISPs that they do not carry
>newsgroups which IWF identifies as regularly hosting child pornography. We
>will use statistics from our own monitoring to identify the groups that
>fall into this category."
>
>Board member Malcolm Hutty promptly resigned. He was the only civil
>liberties activist they had; he is general director of the Campaign Against
>Censorship of the Internet in Britain (Here). Also gone, earlier, over this
>sort of issue are Demon Internet's Clive Feather, an ISP representative,
>and deputy chief executive Ruth Dixon. 
>
>Here are some of the newsgroups he says will be removed if the IWF gets its
>way: alt.binaries.pictures.gill-anderson;
>alt.binaries.pictures.teen-idols.princewilliam;
>alt.binaries.pictures.spice-girls; alt.binaries.pictures.kids;
>alt.penthouse.sex.girls; alt.binaries.pictures.erotica.teen;
>alt.activism.children.whatisa-pedophile. 
>
>This list raises the suspicion that what's operating here is a typically
>computerish blunt-instrument approach – the kind of thing that had
>residents of Scunthorpe unable to register with the prudish AOL when it
>first opened up in the UK.
>
>The IWF started as a back-of-an-envelope idea scribbled by Pipex founder
>Peter Dawe on the eve of a September 1996 meeting on Internet safety. The
>meeting itself was a slightly acrimonious affair: it had been set off in
>part by media pressure in the form of a tabloidly horrid Observer article
>sledge-hammering two wholly innocent well-known Net figures as the "key
>links in the international paedophile chain." In addition, police had
>recently circulated a list of 133 newsgroups they wanted banned outright 
>
>Although the police present at the meeting insisted they had never intended
>their list of 133 newsgroups circulated to ISPs as a guide to the location
>of illegal material (essentially, child pornography) as a threat, the
>undertone, as I wrote in the now-defunct Netizen at the time, was one of
>"you do something about it, or we'll do something about it". The IWF,
>adopted as government policy two weeks later, was that something.
>
>It was supposed to be a hotline for reporting material of concern, with a
>team following up those reports and advising ISPs to remove the material if
>it in fact was illegal. It talked about ratings, and including illegally
>duplicated copyrighted material in its remit, and even sell cleaned-up
>Usenet feeds to ISPs that wanted them. It never got around to most of that,
>though it has made noises occasionally which ensured that worried Net
>activists kept an eye on it. 
>
>Over time, however, the IWF seemed to become mostly harmless. For one
>thing, the climate has changed. While pedophiles are still the bogeymen of
>the hour, the focus is much less on the Net as the source of the problem.
>Most people have some familiarity with email and the Web now, and while
>concerns about Internet safety continue, they are ebbing, as the dark
>panics about schoolchildren exchanging pornography on floppy disks in
>playgrounds did before them. For another, the growth of filtering software
>and the Web have changed the equation somewhat. 
>
>Usenet is a minority interest now, albeit one I happen to share, and
>cleaning up Usenet feeds matters less if the mainstream problem is access
>to Web sites with built-in images and chatrooms that are hosted overseas.
>As the Internet has become mainstream, the truth of what Netheads said all
>along has become plain to more people: the real, heinous problem is child
>abuse, which happens in the physical world. Whatever happens to a child in
>the virtual world pales by comparison.
>
>Maybe this is why the IWF suddenly feels the need to become more active –
>it was feeling neglected. What's disturbing is the secrecy the IWF
>apparently intends to apply to its method for choosing what to ban.
>Blocking software has long operated this way in constructing its filtering
>databases, but at least you can reverse-engineer software and test it to
>find out what it's doing, as Bennett Haselton has for five years now
>(peacefire.org). The only way you can reverse-engineer a board is to get a
>mole on it. The IWF's composition now seems to be almost wholly either
>police (present or former, such as Jim Reynolds, a consultant on
>pedophilia), specialists in child protection issues (Nigel Williams,
>Childnet International (http://www.childnet-int.org), and John Carr, NCH
>Action for Children), or representatives of the council of ISPs that fund
>the organisation. 
>
>Roger Darlington, the IWF's chair, is the exception: he is head of research
>for the National Communications Union. 
>
>What's worse, though, is that the IWF was set up precisely to avoid the
>kind of policy it's now proposing to enact. The IWF is supposed to deal
>with illegal material. It is not supposed to be in the business of
>protecting children, turning the Internet into a children's playground, or
>deciding that the Spice Girls are bad (however much we might be inclined to
>agree with them). What its policy means is throwing out whole tracts of
>legal material because some illegal material may be embedded in them. 
>
>In 1996, I wrote, "They came for child pornography at 3pm on September 23,
>1996, and no one put up a hand in protest," though the line was cut in
>production (See here). Well, they came for pictures of Gillian Anderson on
>February 13, 2002. Anybody?
>
>Previous Columns
>Big Brothers
>The Sound of Money
>Battle of the titans
>By any other name
>Creative Accounting
>Dumber people can run Windows
>2001 in review
>Care in the community
>Remembrance of postings past
>BT's Stupid Patent Tricks
>Preserving our freedoms
>It's beginning to look a lot like Christmas
>Net is the mother of re-invention
>Save the Cookie
>Digital rights and the new era of world terrorism
>
>Wendy M. Grossman, whose Web site is pelicancross ing.net, is author of
>From Anarchy to Power: the Net Comes of Age (NYU Press, 2001), net.wars
>(NYU Press, 1998), and the Daily Telegraph A-Z Guide to the Internet
>(Macmillan, 2001). She can be reached at this email address.
>
>Copyright on all articles published in the INQUIRER is hers.
>http://www.theinquirer.net/15020203.htm
>
> The Inquirer 
>© 2002 Breakthrough
>Publishing Ltd
>
>All rights reserved.
>
>Discuss this story on our Message Forum 
>Back to Front
>
>
>
>
> 
> 
>
> 
> 
>
> 
> 
> 
>
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> http://www.theinquirer.net/15020203.htm
> 
>
>
>
>--
>Get personalised email addresses at http://another.com
>--
>Tony Gosling
>10-12 Picton Street
>Bristol
>BS6 5QA
>England
>+44 (0)117 944 6219
>
>tony at gaia.org
>http://www.bilderberg.org
>http://www.public-interest.co.uk
>
>"US foreign policy can be defined as follows: 'Kiss my arse or I'll kick
>your head in.'"  Harold Pinter --- see
>http://www.guardian.co.uk/letters/story/0,3604,309521,00.html
>
>US foreign policy is run by a private business club: The Council on Foreign
>Relations --- http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/2807
>
>ps. If you get the "S" and the "11" and superimpose them you get a dollar
>sign. Coincidence of course!
>_______________________________________________
>Ir-l mailing list
>Ir-l at gn.apc.org
>http://mailman.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/ir-l

-- 
   ^-^-^-@@-^-;-^   http://www.xemu.demon.co.uk/
        (..)__u     news:alt.smoking.mooses

       happy as a clam at high tide -. <_" .-._.-.




More information about the Ir-l mailing list