[Ir-l] IWF civil liberties resignation
Roland Perry
roland at linx.net
Thu Feb 28 09:03:35 GMT 2002
In message <fzslp+BthUf8EwRa at xemu.demon.co.uk>, Dave Bird
<dave at xemu.demon.co.uk> writes, Quoting Wendy Grossman's article:
>>THE INTERNET WATCH Foundation announced rather invisibly this week
The minutes of the meeting are now on the IWF Website.
>>a change
>>of policy: "We will now recommend to UK ISPs that they do not carry
>>newsgroups which IWF identifies as regularly hosting child pornography. We
>>will use statistics from our own monitoring to identify the groups that
>>fall into this category."
That motion was passed on 15th November. The motion passed recently was
"IWF recommends ISPs not to carry the groups on the list it produces
because they have names that appear to advertise or advocate paedophile
content or activity."
>>Board member Malcolm Hutty promptly resigned.
Indeed he did, although he said it was because of lack of discussion
time, rather than the point being discussed.
>>Here are some of the newsgroups he says will be removed if the IWF gets its
>>way: alt.binaries.pictures.gill-anderson;
>>alt.binaries.pictures.teen-idols.princewilliam;
>>alt.binaries.pictures.spice-girls; alt.binaries.pictures.kids;
>>alt.penthouse.sex.girls; alt.binaries.pictures.erotica.teen;
>>alt.activism.children.whatisa-pedophile.
All of these are actually examples, in the paper presented to the board,
of groups where the proposed mechanical rule would create a false
positive and therefore were included in support of a recommendation
(which was passed) that the names should *also* be subject to human
scrutiny.
--
Roland Perry | tel: +44 20 7645 3505 | roland at linx.org
Director of Public Policy | fax: +44 20 7645 3529 | http://www.linx.net
London Internet Exchange | mbl: +44 7909 68 0005 | /contact/roland
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list